Albuquerque,   Erik Møse,   Helen Keller,   Paul Lemmens,   Paul Mahoney,   Krzysztof Wojtyczek,   Faris Vehabović,   Egidijus Kūris,   Iulia Motoc, judges , and Johan

European Court of Human Rights (Third Section), sitting as a Chamber composed of:   Luis López Guerra, President,   Helena Jäderblom,   George Nicolaou,   Helen Keller,   Johannes

September   2013 as a Chamber composed of: Josep Casadevall, President,   Alvina Gyulumyan,   Guido Raimondi,   Corneliu Bîrsan,   Luis López Guerra,   Nona Tsotsoria,   Johannes

De Gaetano,   Julia Laffranque,   Paul Lemmens,   Paul Mahoney,   Johannes Silvis,   Dmitry Dedov,   Robert Spano,   Iulia Motoc,   Síofra O’Leary, judges, and Lawrence

Nußberger,   André Potocki,   Paul Lemmens,   Helena Jäderblom,   Valeriu Griţco,   Faris Vehabović,   Dmitry Dedov, judges,   Alejandro Saiz Arnaiz, ad hoc judge, and Johan

Jolien Schukking,   Lado Chanturia,   María Elósegui,   Ivana Jelić,   Raffaele Sabato,   Lorraine Schembri Orland,   Anja Seibert-Fohr,   Diana Sârcu , judges , and Johan

De Gaetano,   Angelika Nußberger, judges ,   Spyridon Flogaitis, ad hoc judge , and Johan Callewaert, Deputy Grand Chamber Registrar, Having deliberated in private on 4 May 2011 and 18 January

The parties were then invited to submit any additional observations on the merits which they wished to make.   8.