COUR D'APPEL D'AIX EN PROVENCE 10o Chambre ARRÊT AVANT DIRE DROIT DU 04 MARS 2008 No 2008 / Rôle No 06 / 14194 Edouard, Robert Y... C / Luc Z... S. A.

Several Chechen and Russian families also lived there. According to the applicants, Avar village residents had a tense relationship with their Chechen neighbours. 7.

à [Localité 4] de nationalité Française [Adresse 3] [Adresse 3] Représenté par Me Jean-baptiste LLATI de la SCP PARRAT-LLATI, avocat au barreau de PYRENEES-ORIENTALES, substitué par Me Pierre -Edouard

    The applicants were born in 1966 and 1939 respectively and live in the village of Chechen-Aul of the Grozny district, the Chechen Republic.

  The applicant in the second case is a Russian national who lives in Goyty (Chechen Republic).

    The applicants live in the village of Chechen-Aul, in the Groznenskiy District of the Chechen Republic. 7.     The applicants are married.

At the material time the Ibragimovs lived at 26   Bezymyannaya Street, Urus-Martan, the Chechen Republic.

    On 24 August 2004 the Supreme Court of the Chechen Republic upheld the first-instance judgment. 39.

Madame [V] [F] [L] [N], née le 23 juin 1952 à Allauch (13), décédée 30 décembre 2019 à Marseille 13ème (13013), tous deux demeurant 166A rue du Camas à MARSEILLE (13005) Ayant tous deux Me Samuel CHICHA

Keith AN..., 73°/ Mme AN..., demeurant ensemble Norton XF..., 38 West Saint-Selsey, Chichester W. BM..., (Grande-Bretagne), 74°/ M.

APPELANT Monsieur Pierre-Edouard X... ... 97139 LES ABYMES Représenté par Me MIGNOT, substituant Me Marie-claude COLOMBO avocat au barreau de la GUADELOUPE (bénéficie d'une aide juridictionnelle

Administration, the Ministry of Finance of the Chechen Republic and the Russian President.

faisant fonction de Présidente, Monsieur Ulysse PARODI, Vice président placé faisant fonction de conseiller Monsieur Bertrand MAUMONT, Conseiller, Greffier, lors des débats : Madame Kalliopi CAPO-CHICHI

    The applicants were born in 1957 and 1958 respectively and live in the village of Goyty, the Urus-Martan District, the Chechen Republic. 6.

Republic, the Special Envoy of the Russian President in the Chechen Republic for Rights and Freedoms and the Representative for Rights and Freedoms in Russia.

Republic, the Security Council of the Chechen Republic and the Chechen Administration. 13.

The second applicant lives in the village of Achkhoy-Martan, in the Chechen Republic. The other applicants live in the village of Gekhi, the Urus-Martan District, in the Chechen Republic. 7.

    On 1 June 1999 the Grozny prosecutor’s office sent the case against U.S. to the Supreme Sharia Court of the Chechen Republic. 18 .

    On 30 August 2001 the Department for Legal Affairs and Military Liaison of the Chechen Government informed the applicant that her complaints had been transferred to the Chechen Department

    The applicants are Russian nationals who, at the material time, lived in various districts of the Chechen Republic.