Giovanni Bonello, an advocate practising in Valletta.   3.       The Government are represented by their Agent, Mr.   Noel Buttigieg Scicluna.   4.

Malta , The European Court of Human Rights (Fourth Section), sitting as a Chamber composed of:   Nicolas Bratza, President,   Giovanni Bonello,   Ljiljana Mijović,   David Thór Björgvinsson

Bonello,   Mr   K. Traja,   Mr   S. Pavlovschi,   Mr   J. Šikuta,   Mrs   P. Hirvelä, judges, and Mr T.L.

according to domestic case-law, in instances where the merits of a case were complex and had aspects which fell under both ordinary and constitutional law, the constitutional action was to prevail ( Anthony

Bonello ,   Mr   K. Traja ,   Mr   S. Pavlovschi ,   Mr   J. Šikuta ,   Mrs   P. Hirvelä, judges , and Mrs F.