Virgilio da Silva Pontes qui la conduisait et en était le propriétaire.   Près d'Evora, ils entrèrent en collision avec un autre véhicule, propriété de M. Antonio dos Reis et piloté par M.

Italie , n o 31956/05, §§ 36 à 38, 4 décembre 2012, Rodrigues da Silva et Hoogkamer c. Pays-Bas , n o   50435/99, § 39, CEDH 2006 ‑ I, Meirelles c.

Miranda Rodrigues , Professor of Law       at the Catholic University of Oporto,   Counsel ; - for the Commission   Mr A.

.; and Rodrigues da Silva and Hoogkamer v. the Netherlands , no.

  58681/12, § 55, 1 March 2018, and Rodrigues da Silva and Hoogkamer v. the Netherlands, no. 50435/99, § 41, ECHR 2006-I).

December 2012 as a Chamber composed of: Josep Casadevall, President,   Alvina Gyulumyan,   Corneliu Bîrsan,   Ján Šikuta,   Luis López Guerra,   Nona Tsotsoria,   Johannes Silvis

previously held that where this is the case it is likely only to be in the most exceptional circumstances that the removal of the non-national family member will constitute a violation of Article 8 (see Rodrigues

continue this family life in the Netherlands....’ (67) In its subsequent case-law, the European Court has stuck to this approach (see for example the judgment of 31 January 2006 in the case of and Rodrigues

way of the family living in the country of origin of the alien concerned and whether there are factors of immigration control or considerations of public order weighing in favour of exclusion (see Rodrigues

Rodrigues da Silva and Hoogkamer v. the Netherlands [no. 50435/99, ECHR 2006-I] ..., and that of the [Administrative Jurisdiction] Division [of the Council of State] of 13   July   2009 (ECLI

  58681/12, § 55, 1 March 2018, and Rodrigues da Silva and Hoogkamer v. the Netherlands, no. 50435/99, § 41, ECHR 2006-I).