CEDH · CASELAW;DECISIONS;ADMISSIBILITY;ENG — 23 novembre 1999

.s800EAC49 { font-size:12pt } .s598389FD { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; font-size:16pt } .sBB9EE52A { font-family:Arial } .sFE10DC93 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center } .sD086E7B5 { margin-top:0pt; margin-left:70.9pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:-70.9pt } .s29100277 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold } .s4E40DB89 { width:1.67pt; text-indent:0pt; display:inline-block } .sD7C120C8 { margin-top:0pt; margin-left:106.35pt; margin-bottom:0pt } .s32563E28 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt } .sA1D3DA2E { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:justify } .s23A41E03 { width:36pt; display:inline-block } .sBA8DCCFC { width:35.45pt; display:inline-block } .sE55CAA3E { width:1.26pt; display:inline-block } .sA36B60A1 { font-family:Arial; font-style:italic } .s31BEBB9E { width:7.26pt; display:inline-block } .s9872C2C6 { width:15.43pt; display:inline-block } .s76CF415B { page-break-before:always; clear:both } .s55070D65 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:35.45pt; text-align:justify } .sE3D66594 { border:0.75pt solid #000000; border-collapse:collapse } .s41E9DBF5 { border-right-style:solid; border-right-width:0.75pt; border-bottom-style:solid; border-bottom-width:0.75pt; padding-right:5.03pt; padding-left:5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s2EB42ED2 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:10pt } .s24AC208E { border-right-style:solid; border-right-width:0.75pt; border-left-style:solid; border-left-width:0.75pt; border-bottom-style:solid; border-bottom-width:0.75pt; padding-right:5.03pt; padding-left:5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .sF004B676 { border-left-style:solid; border-left-width:0.75pt; border-bottom-style:solid; border-bottom-width:0.75pt; padding-right:5.03pt; padding-left:5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .sB30C44B0 { border-top-style:solid; border-top-width:0.75pt; border-right-style:solid; border-right-width:0.75pt; border-bottom-style:solid; border-bottom-width:0.75pt; padding-right:5.03pt; padding-left:5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s2EF62ED2 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:12pt } .sC3AB69A { border-style:solid; border-width:0.75pt; padding-right:5.03pt; padding-left:5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s2342A031 { border-top-style:solid; border-top-width:0.75pt; border-left-style:solid; border-left-width:0.75pt; border-bottom-style:solid; border-bottom-width:0.75pt; padding-right:5.03pt; padding-left:5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s6D76B7ED { height:110.65pt } .s166AB0A7 { height:14.25pt } .sF844B0A7 { height:15.15pt } .s546C9D04 { border-top-style:solid; border-top-width:0.75pt; border-right-style:solid; border-right-width:0.75pt; padding-right:5.03pt; padding-left:5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s40B7A780 { border-top-style:solid; border-top-width:0.75pt; border-right-style:solid; border-right-width:0.75pt; border-left-style:solid; border-left-width:0.75pt; padding-right:5.03pt; padding-left:5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s4F2EDFF { border-top-style:solid; border-top-width:0.75pt; border-left-style:solid; border-left-width:0.75pt; padding-right:5.03pt; padding-left:5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s146DE8B1 { height:41.2pt } .s31BB263B { height:27.3pt } .s9987F4D4 { height:143.45pt } .sC4E9E8B1 { height:42.7pt } .sA5FFE089 { height:71.45pt } .sEB6A263B { height:28.3pt } .s33BD88E { height:62.75pt } .s35B3B0A7 { height:17.65pt } .sE6400776 { height:50.4pt } .sD44A84D0 { width:13.96pt; display:inline-block } .s1B9C96E3 { width:14.2pt; display:inline-block } .s3A7C6575 { height:37.75pt } .s70CFB157 { height:172.25pt } .s2C64B0A7 { height:19.55pt } .s94EDF07F { height:91.65pt } .s5765B7ED { height:100.65pt } .sA04990AC { height:201.95pt } .sE4024500 { height:37.3pt } .sD7AA3557 { width:13.1pt; display:inline-block } .s75A32C27 { border-collapse:collapse } .s41240776 { height:55.9pt } .s13A7E8B1 { height:41.8pt } .s89EB962 { height:247.6pt } .s4BAE41EE { font-family:Arial; font-size:11pt } .s4A6B4500 { height:30.1pt } .s74C12B71 { border-top-style:solid; border-top-width:0.75pt; vertical-align:top } .sDE044F24 { height:70pt } .s8DD1D08A { vertical-align:top } .s9538EC41 { height:0pt } .s2769904 { width:133pt } .s51C73EE4 { width:77.95pt } .sBBBF7B84 { width:99.25pt } .sCCB4D898 { width:106.3pt } .sEC117C27 { width:82.65pt } .s8AFBD7B5 { width:2.4pt } .s96FB263B { height:20.8pt } .s1666B0A7 { height:13.55pt } .s8D02089D { height:84.1pt } .s2D2AB0A7 { height:12.45pt } .sC9AE26CC { height:125.9pt } .s19296A58 { height:211pt } .s53880C60 { height:128.35pt } .s49634500 { height:30.9pt } .sADC94CD6 { height:15pt } .s51433A61 { height:109.4pt } .sB47281F4 { height:125.1pt } .sE33C2762 { height:93.7pt } .s9E2C4F24 { height:78pt } .s65FA089D { height:88.5pt } .sC70726A0 { height:9.45pt } .s175A2762 { height:98.2pt } .s323F263B { height:27.7pt } .s1A749961 { height:112.3pt } .sEA3BF07F { height:92.55pt } .s773DEC48 { height:337.9pt } .sD1B5198 { height:154.6pt } .sF9192762 { height:99.6pt } .s13D6AFE5 { height:140.5pt } .sFC4B6575 { height:35.05pt } .s872D3B04 { height:126.4pt } .sBC9472E7 { height:253.3pt } .sC88726E3 { height:196.9pt } .sA2AE64EC { height:74.8pt } .s933A86D0 { height:150pt } .s59259832 { height:149.3pt } .s6F23989F { height:124.3pt } .s2BA8CAE { height:98pt } .sCB70891E { height:310pt } .s5BA4079A { width:22.66pt; display:inline-block } .s21B97EC1 { width:25.99pt; display:inline-block } .s8AFB426F { width:32.67pt; display:inline-block } .sC83B07C { margin-top:0pt; margin-left:36pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:justify } .sD5954E93 { width:13.35pt; display:inline-block } .s33E1B184 { width:256.83pt; display:inline-block } .s8EFC8F8 { width:32.36pt; display:inline-block } .sFBBFC6C9 { width:290.51pt; display:inline-block } .s598389F7 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; font-size:10pt } .s816FED87 { margin-top:0pt; margin-left:18.25pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; font-size:10pt } .sD5236D18 { margin-top:0pt; margin-left:18.25pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:12pt } .s6370E78A { height:15.2pt } .s22765D7A { height:23.35pt } .sFCAD071B { height:297.65pt } .s67FEE5D { height:116.05pt } .s8E7A0551 { height:283.05pt } .sF12D4627 { height:64.2pt } .s7FB60776 { height:57.1pt } .sAF98F512 { height:155.45pt } .s5925993A { height:141.3pt } .s1A696575 { height:34.95pt } .s4D3D43BA { height:3.85pt } .s9BC64EC { height:71.3pt } .s17EBE089 { height:78.35pt } .s94FF4627 { height:63.3pt } .sAD1F2E16 { height:105.85pt } .s1D75BA2C { height:295.6pt } .sC32064EC { height:77.5pt } .s292664EC { height:70.4pt } .s587354BA { height:261.75pt } FIRST SECTION   PARTIAL DECISION   AS TO THE ADMISSIBILITY OF   Applications Nos.   41137/98, 41139/98, 42144/98, 42145/98, 42770/98, 42772/98, 42776/98, 42781/98, 42784/98, 42787/98, 42790/98, 42794/98, 42820/98, 42822/98, 42825/98, 42826/98, 42827/98, 42830/98, 42831/98, 42834/98, 42842/98, 42872/98, 42875/98, 42878/98, 42894/98, 42899/98, 42904/98, 42905/98, 42907/98, 43342/98, 43345/98, 43370/98, 43372/98, 43809/98, 43810/98, 43816/98, 43817/98, 44284/98, 44703/98, 48257/99 against Turkey     The European Court of Human Rights (First Section) sitting on 23 November 1999 as a Chamber composed of     Mrs   E. Palm, President ,   Mr   J. Casadevall,   Mr   Gaukur Jörundsson,   Mr   R. Türmen,   Mr   C. Bîrsan,   Mrs   W. Thomassen,   Mr   R. Maruste, judges ,   and   Mr   M. O’Boyle, Section Registrar ;     Having regard to Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms;     Having regard to the applications, the introduction and registration dates of which are listed in the appendix as well as the names of the applicants;     Having regard to the reports provided for in Rule 49 of the Rules of Court;     Having deliberated;     Decides as follows: THE FACTS   The applicants, whose names are listed in the appendix, are Turkish nationals. They are represented before the Court by Mr Tekin Akıllıoğlu, a lawyer practising in Ankara.     The facts of the case, as submitted by the applicants, may be summarised as follows.     The General Directorate of National Roads and Highways (Devlet Karayolları Genel Müdürlüğü), a state body responsible, inter alia , for motorway construction, expropriated plots of land belonging to the applicants in İçel, Adana, Tarsus and İskenderun in order to build the Tarsus -İçel - Çukurova - İskenderun Motorway. A committee of experts assessed the value of the plots of land belonging to the applicants and these amounts were paid to them when the expropriation took place.     Following the applicants’ requests for increased compensation, the national courts awarded them additional compensation plus an interest at the statutory rate of 30 % per annum. The applicants appealed and the Court of Cassation upheld the decisions of the first instance courts. Between December 1997 and March 1998 the due amounts were paid to the applicants respectively.     All the details as to the date of transfer of title deed to the land, the final decision by the Court of Cassation, the amount of additional compensation and the date of payment are indicated in the tables below.       APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT No. 41137/98           1.Aydın ELİK   25.09.1996 05.12.1996 386.186.400.000 31.12.1997 2.Nedim UMAY   27.03.1996 10.06.1996 150.502.800.000 31.12.1997 3.Nedim UMAY   17.07.1996 23.12.1996   77.878.700.000 31.12.1997 4.Nevim DADÜK   19.06.1996 05.12.1996   26.790.480.000 31.12.1997 5. Davut TOPRAK     Ali TOPRAK     Hasibe TOPRAK     Gülperi TOPRAK     Gülseren TOPRAK     Sevgi DEMİR     Esmehan DEMİR     Nevim DADÜK       12.06.1996         05.12.1996           85.569.200.000         31.12.1997   No. 41139/98           1.Nehdet DEMİR 03.07.1996 23.12.1996   92.430.000.000 31.12.1997         APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 2.Malik TOPRAK    Süleyman TOPRAK    Asıf TOPRAK   05.06.1996     05.12.1996     113.131.400.000     31.12.1997   3. Süleyman TOPRAK     Selim DEMİR 27.06.1996   23.12.1996   68.526.180.000   31.12.1997   4. Nehdet DEMİR     Garip DEMİR     Cabir DEMİR   27.06.1996     23.12.1996       68.938.922.000     31.12.1997   5. Süleyman TOPRAK     Hasibe DADÜK         (TOPRAK)     Malik TOPRAK     Asıf TOPRAK     Atra DEMİR     Nehdet DEMİR     Garip DEMİR     Selim DEMİR     Bedriye TOPRAK     Cabir DEMİR         10.07.1996           23.12.1996           135.157.200.000         31.12.1997   6. Süleyman TOPRAK 19.06.1996 05.12.1996   59.682.600.000 31.12.1997 No. 42144/98           1. Fatma ATEŞ     Emine ÖRSEL     Zeliha GÖRMÜŞER   19.07.1995     16.05.1996        8.019.660.000     15.01.1998   2. Cennet AVVURUR     Hülya ALPAKUT     Ali ALPAKUT     Nuran YILDIZ     Leyla TOROS     19.07.1995       23.05.1996          9.410.137.500       05.01.1998   3. Zahide EMİRLER     Aliye ASLAN 05.07.1995   23.05.1996    5.554.790.000    09.01.1998 4. Birsen ALPAKUT     Meral ERTEN     Mahmut ALPAKUT     Birsen ALPAKUT for                    Aslı ALPAKUT                     19.07.1995       23.05.1996       10.664.822.500       08.01.1998   No. 42145/98         1. Fethi ERDAŞ 14.06.1995 20.05.1996   17.926.370.000 09.01.1998     APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 2. Mehmet Sadık   BOLTAÇ   Melek BALKIŞ     21.06.1995     20.05.1996     24.520.800.000     05.01.1998 3. Ahmet GAMGAM 14.06.1995 23.05.1996   54.071.815.000 08.01.1998 4. Şadiye DİNLER 21.06.1995 23.05.1996     5.243.000.000 12.01.1998 5. Hüseyin COŞĞUN 14.06.1995 20.05.1996   13.839.480.000 05.01.1998 6. Celal EMİRLER     Yahya EMİRLER 05.07.1995   16.05.1996       5.554.790.000 15.01.1998   7. Mehmet Sadık BOLTAÇ     Melek BALKIŞ   14.06.1995     20.05.1996       45.497.280.000     05.01.1998   No. 42770/98         1. Emaş Endüstri Mineralleri A.Ş. 27.07.1994 05.02.1996 46.447.380.000 31.12.1997 No. 42772/98         1. Nuriye KARA 06.07.1993 05.05.1994          45.000.000 18.02.1998 2. Fethiye KARATAŞ     Rahime YILMAZ     İsmail KÖSE     Dudu BİLGEN     Mehmet KÖSE     22.07.1992       16.06.1994              105.253.856       18.02.1998   3. Ümmü YÜKSEL     Emine YÜKSEL     Eşe YÜKSEL     Fahriye YÜKSEL            Hacer YÜKSEL     Fatma YÜKSEL     Rahime YÜKSEL     Murat YÜKSEL     Fazilet YÜKSEL     Hürüye YÜKSEL     İsmail YÜKSEL     Ayşe YÜKSEL           19.02.1992             28.11.1994                    226.237.610             12.02.1998   4. Teslime YILMAZ   16.12.1992 14.02.1994          70.000.000 18.02.1998   APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 5. Sevimser BALIKÇIOĞLU     Ekrem Serdar BALIKÇIOĞLU     Kerem BALIKÇIOĞLU     Özer BALIKÇIOĞLU         17.02.1993         16.03.1995                     337.185.000              13.02.1998   No. 42776/98           1. Yılmaz ALTAY     Kamil YILMAZ     Yılmaz ARKAN   15.07.1993     20.01.1997       14.226.312.000     08.01.1998   2. Yılmaz ALTAY      Kamil YILMAZ     Yılmaz ARKAN   15.07.1993     27.01.1997       13.138.425.000     08.01.1998   3. Yılmaz ALTAY     Kamil YILMAZ     Yılmaz ARKAN   15.07.1993     03.02.1997       12.584.044.000     27.01.1998   4. Özdemir Ticaret Kollektif Şirketi - İbrahim Özdemir and his partners 15.06.1995 20.01.1997   44.557.220.000 05.01.1998 No. 42781/98           1. Mustafa AKDENİZ 21.10.1993 11.12.1995   38.836.500.000 05.01.1998 2. Hasan AKDENİZ 21.10.1993 11.12.1995   40.507.000.000 08.01.1998 3. Döne YILDIRIM 14.09.1995 20.01.1997     7.990.000.000 05.01.1998 4. Sultan SÖNMEZ 20.07.1993 05.02.1996   22.306.200.000                            05.01.1998 No. 42784/98           1. Beyhan ARIK 11.08.1993 30.05.1994         70.000.000 18.02.1998 2. Hasan KAPLAN     Ahmet TURGUT 20.10.1992   02.06.1994           50.000.000   18.02.1998   4. Hasan KAPLAN     Ahmet TURGUT 25.11.1991   25.05.1993           22.425.325   18.02.1998     APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 6.Fatma GÜVEN    Salih YÖRÜK    Emsal YÖRÜK    Ali YÖRÜK    Fatma YÖRÜK    ŞifeYÖRÜK    Mustafa YÖRÜK    Eşe YÖRÜK    Mehmet YÖRÜK    Emine KARA    NazmiyeTEZEL    Şerife YÖRÜK    Muhteber YÖRÜK    Ahmet YÖRÜK             11.09.1993               28.11.1994                    151.772.600               18.02.1998   7. Ayşe UYAR 15.10.1992 18.04.1994         48.618.360 18.02.1998 8. Fatma TURGUT 25.11.1991 27.05.1993         47.806.000 18.02.1998 No. 42787/98           1. Raşit BİRGÜL     26.08.1991 19.06.1995    4.090.361.854 09.01.1998 2. Arif BİRGÜL 26.08.1991 19.06.1995    4.090.361.854 12.01.1998 3. Mehmet BİRGÜL 26.08.1991 19.06.1995    4.090.361.854 12.01.1998 4. Halil BİRGÜL 26.08.1991 19.06.1995    4.090.361.854 09.01.1998 5. Zeki BİRGÜL 26.08.1991 19.06.1995    4.090.361.854 12.01.1998 No. 42790/98           1. Hatice KAMALI 21.07.1994 12.06.1995       431.400.000 13.02.1998 2. Ali GÖKNUR 01.07.1992 27.09.1993         21.700.000 18.02.1998 3. Mehmet GÖKNUR 01.07.1992 24.05.1993        22.593.180 18.02.1998 4. Ali GÖKNUR 05.04.1993 14.04.1994         73.380.000 18.02.1998 5. Şükrü DEMİR   Mehmet Hanifi   DEMİR 22.10.1992   08.11.1993           46.668.725         18.02.1998   6. Şükrü DEMİR   Mehmet Hanifi   DEMİR 22.10.1992   08.11.1993           96.250.000   18.02.1998   9. Medine GÖKNUR 03.11.1992 19.06.1995         19.141.000 18.02.1998 No. 42794/98           1. Ali Naci KARA 14.09.1995 03.02.1997       484.550.000 18.02.1998 2. Mehmet Ali PAN 16.12.1992 27.01.1994         48.932.300 18.02.1998 3. Mahmut KOCA 25.08.1993 24.11.1994         76.738.785 18.02.1998   APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 4. Aysel AKDENİZLİ     Emine AKDENİZLİ     Betül AKDENİZLİ     Aytül AKDENİZLİ   15.10.1992     24.11.1994                   35.696.496           18.02.1998   5. Ahmet ÇELİK     Emine ERKILIÇ     Düriye UYAN   11.09.1993     02.02.1995             15.371.000     18.02.1998   6. Ahmet ÇELİK     Emine ERKILIÇ     Düriye UYAN   03.03.1993   20.06.1994            51.982.175   18.02.1998   7. Fatma GÜVEN    Salih YÖRÜK    Emsal YÖRÜK    Ali YÖRÜK    Fatma YÖRÜK   Şife YÖRÜK (KOŞAR)   Mustafa YÖRÜK   Eşe YÖRÜK   Şerife YÖRÜK   Muhteber YÖRÜK   Ahmet YÖRÜK   Mehmet YÖRÜK   Emine KARA   Nazmiye TEZEL   (DEMİR)   Ömer ŞİMŞEK   Mahmut ŞİMŞEK   Abdurrahman ŞİMŞEK   Nazmiye YEŞİLYAPRAK                   11.09.1993                     04.12.1995                           204.105.528                     12.02.1998   No. 42820/98           1. Ahmet GÖKNUR     Mehmet GÖKNUR     Ayşe ÖZAR     Ali ÖZAR     Teslime AKKUŞ 16.10.1992   12.09.1994           40.000.000         06.02.1998   2. Celal OĞUZ 08.09.1993 20.10.1994         15.000.000 06.02.1998 3. Mustafa ÖZGÖKMEN 27.01.1992 27.05.1993         38.496.376 06.02.1998 4. Hasan Hüseyin TAŞKIN 11.09.1993 02.02.1995         65.435.000 11.02.1998 5. Yusuf SARI 27.01.1993 02.05.1994         45.381.000 11.02.1998   APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT No. 42822/98           1. Ali OKSAL     Mehmet OKSAL     Bülent OKSAL     Emine OKSAL     Tülin OKSAL     24.01.1992       25.05.1993                  131.563.000       06.02.1998   2. Yusuf KÜRKÇÜ 30.05.1994 29.05.1995        266.000.000 10.02.1998 3. Mustafa BİRTEKİN     Döne AKGÜL     Hasan BAŞ     Fadıma SALDÜZ     Mevlüt BİRTEKİN     13.09.1995       27.01.1997        11.098.864.000        06.02.1998   4. Mehmet KAPLAN     Abdil KAPLAN     Mahmut KAPLAN     Süleyman KAPLAN     Mustafa KAPLAN     15.10.1992       31.03.1994               506.575.000       06.02.1998   17. Hasan KÜRKÇÜ 06.06.1994 10.07.1995         266.000.000 05.02.1998 No. 42825/98           1. Ali KAPLAN     D. Mehmet KAPLAN     Hanife KURTOĞLU     Mehmet KAPLAN     Mümin KAPLAN     Sultan KAPLAN     15.10.1992       27.11.1995            7.912.500.000       06.02.1998   2. Hasan ÇINAR 27.05.1992 15.11.1993           83.490.000 11.02.1998 3. Yusuf UMAY     İsa UMAY     İbrahim UMAY     Musa UMAY     Ali Nadir UMAY     İsmail UMAY     Temim UMAY     Asaf UMAY         31.07.1989           01.03.1995                4.767.929.237              28.01.1998   4. Ali YILMAZ 27.01.1993 27.05.1996         541.999.150 26.01.1998 5. Düldane KARA 18.03.1992 24.06.1993           79.119.000 11.02.1998   APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT No. 42826/98           1. Mustafa ÖZGÖKMEN 15.10.1992 17.01.1994          66.082.961 11.02.1998 2. İsa TOPAL     Şemsettin TOPAL     Ali TOPAL   03.06.1992     12.11.1993              59.852.000     11.02.1998   3. Veli ERGEÇ 05.04.1993 17.01.1994          81.898.568 11.02.1998 4. Zöhre ÇAKIR (ZEBUN)     Muzaffer ÇAKIR     Fatma ÇAKIR (BASTIK)     Emine ÇAKIR (GÜLLÜ)     İhsan ÇAKIR     Emiş ÇAKIR   (KAHRAMAN)    Tahsin ÇAKIR    Sultan ÇAKIR (KESİK)    Hatice ÇAKIR (DİKE)    Neriman KILAVUZ    İbrahim ZEBUN    Sultan KÜÇÜK    Teslime ÇAKIR    Türkan ZEBUN    (ANTEP)    Dudu ZEBUN               21.06.1994                 09.10.1995                     1.365.000.000                 28.01.1998   5. İsa TOPAL    Şemsettin TOPAL    Ali TOPAL    Ayşe YILDIRIM    Hüsne TOPAL    Asiye TOPAL    Mustafa TOPAL    Hayriddin TOPAL    Meryem TOPAL    Cüneyt TOPAL         24.06.1992           15.11.1993                   25.050.000                  11.02.1998   No. 42827/98           1. Nurettin BALAMUT     Ali KAZAN 22.06.1993   12.03.1996      1.207.760.750   06.02.1998     APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 2. İzzettin SARI 13.04.1993 20.02.1997       278.974.600 06.02.1998 3. Fethiye KARA 18.03.1992 09.05.1994         63.099.000 11.02.1998 4. İsa KAYA     Havva KAYA 15.10.1992   25.04.1994         165.000.000       02.02.1998   5. Hadice KILINÇ     Bekir KILINÇ     Yakup KILINÇ     Nazmi KILINÇ     Zekerriya KILINÇ     Fatma KILINÇ     Sıtkı KILINÇ       20.07.1993         29.11.1994                   697.110.572         06.02.1998   No. 42830/98           1. Fadime YÜKSEL 26.02.1992 30.03.1995         15.023.960 06.02.1998 2. Hafize GÖCÜK     Hasan ÇÖL     Osman ÇÖL     Fazlı ÇÖL     Hacer ÇÖL (BORA)     Abdullah ÇÖL     Raziye ÇÖL (TOP)       23.06.1992         14.02.1994                       73.088.500               11.02.1998   3. Meliha OKSAL     Erdoğan OKSAL     Kerime OKSAL     Nevin MAĞARACI     Hasan OKSAL     Vildan ÖZÖKSÜZ (OKSAL)     Erol OKSAL     Semriz ERKAYA         16.03.1992             28.11.1994                         36.824.600                 11.02.1998   4. Kıymet AKSAY (OĞUZ) 11.08.1993 06.06.1994         85.000.000 11.02.1998 5. Saniye KARCI 15.10.1992 02.02.1995        29.606.882 11.02.1998 No. 42831/98           1. Dürdane DOĞAN 25.03.1992 01.12.1993      133.168.750 11.02.1998 2. Hasan AKDAĞ 15.11.1992 24.11.1994        82.159.110 11.02.1998 3. Duran SARI 18.08.1993 10.11.1994        89.075.000 11.02.1998 4. Sadık OĞUZ 18.08.1993 18.05.1994       40.000.000 11.02.1998 5. Mehmet ERDOĞAN 15.10.1992 25.04.1994       30.000.000 11.02.1998   APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT No. 42834/98           1. Ayşe GÖK 28.07.1993 30.05.1994       43.208.512 06.02.1998 2. Emine ÇALIŞKAN     Meryem ŞİMŞEK     Reşit AYDEMİR     Muzaffer AYDEMİR     İsmet AYDEMİR     İbrahim AYDEMİR     26.08.1993       21.12.1995           729.686.000         06.02.1998   3. Ömer Nazmi KARA 09.01.1993 02.02.1995       89.362.400 11.02.1998 4. Mehmet KAPLAN     Abdil KAPLAN     Mahmut KAPLAN     Süleyman KAPLAN     Mustafa KAPLAN     22.01.1992         14.04.1994                37.321.225           11.02.1998   5. Ramazan CİVELEK     Elife CİVELEK 27.01.1993   27.05.1996       479.123.440     18.02.1998   No. 42842/98           1. Ahmet Hilmi YER     İshak GÜMÜŞ 29.06.1993   05.05.1994       442.534.000   06.02.1998   2. Naim GÜN     Giyasittin GÜN 12.07.1993   05.05.1994       395.980.562     06.02.1998   3. Hadika TEKİN 01.07.1992 28.06.1993       45.105.440 18.02.1998 4. Salih USLU 05.07.1993 05.05.1994     106.870.000 06.02.1998 5. Hüseyin YILDIRIM 13.01.1994 04.10.1994     320.000.000 26.01.1998 No. 42872/98           1. Aişe YILDIRIM     Melek AYTEKİN     Ahmet YILDIRIM     İsharettin YILDIRIM     Zübeyde ÇELEBİ     Salime YILDIRIM     Adnan YILDIRIM     15.08.1991     02.10.1995        390.000.000     20.01.1998 2. Hasan TÜRKMEN 06.07.1993 05.05.1994      984.373.000 21.01.1998   APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 3. Hüseyin Fikri ÇOPUR     Müslüm ÇOPUR     Emine ÇOPUR     İbrahim ÇOPUR     Mustafa ÇOPUR     23.02.1993     27.06.1994          339.042.000       21.01.1998 4. Hasan TÜRKMEN 01.07.1992 24.05.1993          52.760.280 18.02.1998 5. Aişe YILDIRIM     Melek AYTEKİN     Ahmet YILDIRIM     İsharettin YILDIRIM     Zübeyde ÇELEBİ     Salime YILDIRIM     Adnan YILDIRIM     01.02.1994       25.09.1995               200.500.000          20.01.1998   No. 42875/98           1. Ayşe DARTAR 13.10.1992 12.09.1994      110.000.000 18.02.1998 2. Ayşe DARTAR 26.01.1993 25.04.1994      208.800.000 21.01.1998 3. Şavkı GÜZAY 15.10.1993 26.09.1994      276.155.400 22.01.1998 4. Ali YÜKSEL     İsmail YÜKSEL 05.07.1992   30.05.1994        167.570.250      23.01.1998   6. Ali YÜKSEL 20.05.1992 08.11.1993      340.519.500 21.01.1998 No. 42878/98           1. Duran SOY 29.06.1993 05.05.1994      968.867.000 21.01.1998 2. Duran SOY 21.07.1992 24.05.1993        49.184.866 18.02.1998 3. Hasan Hüseyin TAŞKIN 08.02.1993 26.09.1994        68.722.000 21.01.1998 4. Teslime ÖZDEMİR     Mahmut ÖZDEMİR     Dursel YILMAZ (ÖZDEMİR)     Nadir ÖZDEMİR    Fatma ÖZDEMİR    Mecit ÖZDEMİR    Yonis ÖZDEMİR     Mehmet Ali ÖZDEMİR       17.02.1993         18.04.1994                    40.000.000              21.01.1998     APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 5. Mahmut VURAL     Emine AKKUŞ     Esvet VURAL     Hatice HOCAOĞLU     Ganimet TEL     Şaziment YANPAR     Hürriyet KIR     Osman VURAL       20.10.1992         22.11.1993              200.000.000            21.01.1998   No. 42894/98             1.Mehmet YÖRÜK   Nazmiye TEZEL   Emsal YÖRÜK   Ali YÖRÜK   Salih YÖRÜK   Fatma GÜVEN   Emine KARA   Fatma YÖRÜK   Şife YÖRÜK (KOŞAR)   Mustafa YÖRÜK   Eşe YÖRÜK   Şerife YÖRÜK   Muhteber YÖRÜK   Ahmet YÖRÜK   Şeref ŞİMŞEK   Bekir ŞİMŞEK   Ömer ŞİMŞEK   Mehmut ŞİMŞEK   Cemil Kadir ŞİMŞEK   Öner ŞİMŞEK   Rabia ŞİMŞEK   Abdurrahman ŞİMŞEK   Nazmiye YEŞİLYAPRAK   Hicret KILIÇ                         16.03.1993                           11.12.1995                                    900.000.000                         21.01.1998 2. Halil ŞAHİN 22.10.1992 22.11.1993      340.000.000 21.01.1998 3. Celil KAYA      Fazlı ÇÖL     Abdullah ÇÖL     Hacer BORA     Raziye TOP     13.05.1992       31.01.1994              133.697.326          21.01.1998     APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 4. Bestami SONKAYA     Mevlüt SONKAYA     Habibe SONKAYA     Güler UYANIK     Hatice İZGİ     Sultan YILDIRIM     Raziye ÖZEL       01.02.1994         25.09.1995            188.122.212         20.01.1998   5. Melek SIĞMAK     Firdevs OĞUZ     Durdu KESİKBAŞ     Ahmet ERCAN     Bilal GÖK     16.09.1992       08.11.1993              93.764.916       21.01.1998   No. 42899/98           1. Hikmet AYSEN 25.11.1991 27.05.1993        28.927.470 20.01.1998 2. Hikmet AYSEN 15.10.1992 10.11.1994      139.657.591 20.01.1998 3. Ali Rıza YILDIRIM    Aişe YILDIRIM    Emine ÖZEROĞLU    Fadıma ÇELEBİ    Mevlüt YILDIRIM    Hasan YILDIRIM    C. Tayyar YILDIRIM    Celal YILDIRIM    Cengizhan YILDIRIM    Hacı Yusuf YILDIRIM    Ayşegül ÖZKUL         15.08.1991           25.09.1995                  799.625.000              20.01.1998   4. Ali Rıza YILDIRIM     Aişe YILDIRIM     Emine ÖZEROĞLU     Fadıma ÇELEBİ     Mevlüt YILDIRIM     Hasan YILDIRIM     C. Tayyar YILDIRIM    Celal YILDIRIM    Cengizhan YILDIRIM    Hacı Yusuf YILDIRIM    Ayşegül ÖZKUL           15.08.1991             26.04.1994                    210.950.000                20.01.1998     APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 5. Ali Rıza YILDIRIM    Aişe YILDIRIM    Emine ÖZEROĞLU    Fadıma ÇELEBİ    Mevlüt YILDIRIM    C. Tayyar YILDIRIM    Celal YILDIRIM    Cengizhan YILDIRIM    Hacı Yusuf YILDIRIM    Ayşegül ÖZKUL           15.11.1991             26.04.1994                   316.650.000                20.01.1998   No. 42904/98           1. Hasip TOKSOY 04.10.1994 05.12.1996      856.340.825 21.01.1998 2. Veli ERGEÇ 15.10.1993 29.09.1994      250.000.000 23.01.1998 3. Ali PAN 09.09.1992 03.10.1994        66.429.132 21.01.1998 4. M. Ramiz YÜKSEL 26.02.1992 02.02.1995      113.045.805 21.01.1998 5. Hatice SOY     İlyas SOY     Selam SOY     Duran SOY     Fatma SOY (YER)     Ali SOY     İlhami SOY     İbrahim SOY     Veli SOY     Mustafa SOY         06.07.1993           05.05.1994                    670.000.000              21.01.1998   No. 42905/98           1. Gülsüm SARKIN 14.07.1992 18.10.1993       38.649.800 18.02.1998 2. Hadika TEKİN 20.07.1993 05.05.1994      133.571.612 06.02.1998 3. Zeynep ERGEN 14.09.1994 28.11.1996      777.565.091 28.01.1998 4. Duran Mehmet KAPLAN     Hanife KURTOĞLU 15.10.1992   17.01.1994        158.070.944   26.01.1998   5. Gülsüm SARKIN 13.07.1993 05.05.1994      137.696.000 06.02.1998   APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT   No. 42907/98           1. İrfan KUNT    Havana BOZDOĞAN    Ahmet KUNT    Mehmet KUNT    Havana KUNT    Sami KUNT    Ali KUNT    Ersen KUNT    Hasibe KUNT         20.07.1993           05.05.1994                 306.214.000               21.01.1998   2. Ali Rıza YILDIRIM     Emine ÖZEROĞLU     Mevlüt YILDIRIM     Hasan YILDIRIM     Celal YILDIRIM     Cengizhan YILDIRIM     Hacı Yusuf YILDIRIM     Ayşegül ÖZKUL       02.02.1994         04.03.1996           2.995.094.900         20.01.1998   3. Fatma GÜVEN     Salih YÖRÜK     Emsal YÖRÜK     Ali YÖRÜK     Fatma YÖRÜK     Şife YÖRÜK     (KOŞAR)     Mustafa YÖRÜK     Eşe YÖRÜK     Şerife YÖRÜK     Muhteber YÖRÜK     Ahmet YÖRÜK           14.02.1993             09.06.1994                     304.696.522                21.01.1998     APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 4. Fatma GÜVEN     Salih YÖRÜK     Emsal YÖRÜK     Ali YÖRÜK     Fatma YÖRÜK     Şife YÖRÜK     (KOŞAR)     Mustafa YÖRÜK     Eşe YÖRÜK     Şerife YÖRÜK     Muhteber YÖRÜK     Ahmet YÖRÜK     Mehmet YÖRÜK     Emine KARA     Nazmiye TEZEL     (DEMİR)     Hamit CİVELEK     Yeter CİVELEK     Cemile ŞEKER     Emine ÖZŞİRECİ               10.02.1993                 21.04.1994                        900.000.000                 21.01.1998   5. Fatma GÜVEN     Salih YÖRÜK     Emsal YÖRÜK     Ali YÖRÜK     Fatma YÖRÜK     Şife YÖRÜK     (KOŞAR)     Mustafa YÖRÜK     Eşe YÖRÜK     Şerife YÖRÜK     Muhteber YÖRÜK     Ahmet YÖRÜK     Mehmet YÖRÜK     Emine KARA     Nazmiye TEZEL     (DEMİR)       16.03.1993 (for Emsal YÖRÜK)   10.02.1993 (for the remainder of the applicants)             16.05.1995                2.516.954.550               21.01.1998   No. 43342/98           1. Recep UYANIK 10.03.1994 04.10.1994        607.200.053 16.01.1998 2. Armağan DEMİRKOL 16.01.1994 15.05.1995        500.000.000 20.01.1998   APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE DEED TO THE LAND DATE OF FINAL DECISION BY COURT OF CASSATION AS REGARDS ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION AMOUNT OF ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION (interests and legal costs are not included) (in turkish liras)         DATE OF PAYMENT 3. Hatice ŞEKER (ŞİMŞEK)     Huri ÇELEN     Semiha OKTAR     Elif KOCA     Musa ÇELEN     20.07.1993       04.10.1994           1.227.374.270         16.01.1998   4. Hasan MUTLU    Ahmet MUTLU    Yusuf SARI    Ömer ÖKSÜZ    Dursun YILMAZ    Nizamettin SOLAKLI    Sami ŞEKER    Hasan ARSLAN    Asiye SEVİNÇ    Fatma ÇOLAK    Mehmet SEVİNÇ    Emine YILMAZ    Havva SEVİNÇ    (DERELİ)    Mustafa SEVİNÇ    Behiye İZGİ    Keriman DAĞLI    Mehmet YILDIRIM    Perihan AKSEL    Ummuhani ALKAN    Muhibe ÖZER    Metin YILDIRIM                   06.10.1995                 27.01.1997                 14.611.795.000                 16.01.1998 No. 43345/98           1. Mustafa DEMİR 01.07.1992 27.09.1993          34.703.100 18.02.1998 2. Münevver DEMİR (İSLAMLAR) 13.10.1992 08.11.1993          54.896.000 18.02.1998 3. Celal DEMİR 01.07.1992 27.09.1993          25.645.580 18.02.1998 4. Celal DEMİR 12.05.1993 22.11.1993          50.000.000 18.02.1998 5. Duran Ali SARI 27.01.1993 17.04.1995        273.121.431 26.01.1998 6. Fatma AÇAR 20.09.1993 04.10.1994        159.981.000 26.01.1998   APPLICATION NUMBERS AND NAMES OF THE APPLICANTS     DATE OF TRANSFER OF TITLE D