CEDH · CASELAW;DECISIONS;ADMISSIBILITY;ENG — 8 avril 2014

.s800EAC49 { font-size:12pt } .s2EF17D91 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; font-size:2pt } .sBB9EE52A { font-family:Arial } .s5E1364CA { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .s598389F8 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; font-size:11pt } .sA36B60A1 { font-family:Arial; font-style:italic } .s8229ABDD { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:center } .s9793A85B { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:14.2pt } .sCB9E0544 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:left } .sB9D5CABB { width:28.35pt; display:inline-block } .sD3B63DAD { margin-top:36pt; margin-bottom:12pt; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .sA8776625 { margin-top:18pt; margin-left:29.2pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-indent:-17.6pt; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s29100277 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold } .s8DF6C4 { font-family:Arial; color:#333333 } .s79DE5897 { margin-top:18pt; margin-left:17.85pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-indent:-17.85pt; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .sF7A86111 { margin-top:6pt; margin-left:21.25pt; margin-bottom:6pt; text-indent:7.1pt; font-size:10pt } .s4B243ECC { margin-top:12pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:14.2pt; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s5F897A7E { margin-top:12pt; margin-left:14.2pt; margin-bottom:0pt } .sF7A4323 { margin-top:36pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:left } .s216DBE45 { width:187.29pt; display:inline-block } .s7602FED2 { width:18.21pt; display:inline-block } .sC1AC44A4 { width:228.11pt; display:inline-block } .s32563E28 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt } .s76CF415B { page-break-before:always; clear:both } .s4ACA9207 { page-break-before:always; clear:both; mso-break-type:section-break } .s68C46B95 { margin-top:36pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:center } .s3F59B822 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold; text-transform:uppercase } .s5FFF0A75 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:7pt } .s3F717125 { font-family:Arial; color:#339966; display:none } .s75A32C27 { border-collapse:collapse } .sB5A00431 { height:7.1pt } .s3695F815 { border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top; background-color:#dfdfdf } .s85646119 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:justify; font-size:12pt } .sEECE831 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold; color:#474747 } .s2EF62ED2 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:12pt } .sE8934522 { border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s6B505E72 { margin:0pt; padding-left:0pt } .s8F670191 { font-family:Arial; font-size:12pt; list-style-position:inside } .s598389F9 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; font-size:12pt } .s4EFEAD { width:14.32pt; font:7pt 'Times New Roman'; display:inline-block } .s529BF6EF { page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-family:Arial; font-size:12pt; list-style-position:inside } .sF2CE8B01 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:12pt } .sCBC20640 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:justify; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:12pt } .sEDC5336B { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:12pt } .sC4575BE4 { width:7.64pt; font:7pt 'Times New Roman'; display:inline-block } .s2E932ED2 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:11pt } .s23A41E03 { width:36pt; display:inline-block } .s7ED160F0 { text-decoration:none } .s33165EBA { font-family:Arial; font-size:8pt; vertical-align:super; color:#0069d6 } .sA59EE089 { height:71.35pt } .sF6A12959 { width:33%; height:1px; text-align:left }   FORMER SECOND SECTION DECISION This version was rectified on16 June 2015 under Rule 81 of the Rules of Court.   Application no. 21786/04 Murat HAÇİKOĞLU against Turkey and 830 other applications (see list appended) The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 8   April 2014 as a Chamber composed of:   Guido Raimondi, President,   Işıl Karakaş,   András Sajó,   Nebojša Vučinić,   Paul Lemmens,   Egidijus Kūris,   Robert Spano, judges, and Stanley Naismith, Section Registrar, Having regard to the above applications, listed in the appendix, Having deliberated, decides as follows: THE FACTS 1.     A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix. A.     The circumstances of the case 2.     The facts of the case, as submitted by the applicants, may be summarised as follows. 3.     On various dates, the applicants initiated actions before various civil courts or civil proceedings were brought against them before the civil courts. Certain procedures lasted several years, and some are still pending before the domestic courts. B.     Relevant domestic law A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Müdür   Turgut and Others ((dec.), no.   4860/09, §§   19-26, 26   March 2013 ). COMPLAINTS The applicants complained under Article   6 §   1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time. Some of the applicants alleged that there had been a violation of Article   13 of the Convention in that there was no effective remedy under Turkish law. All the applicants raised additional complaints with reference to various Articles of the Convention and its Protocols. THE LAW I.     ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION The applicants complained that the length of the proceedings had been incompatible with the “reasonable time” requirement, laid down in Article   6   §   1 of the Convention, which reads as follows: “In the determination of his civil rights and obligations ... everyone is entitled to a ... hearing within a reasonable time by a ... tribunal...” The Court observes that the applicants asserted that the length of the proceedings had been incompatible with the principle of the “reasonable time” requirement in accordance with Article   6 §   1 of the Convention. The Court found in Müdür Turgut and   Others (§§   58 and   60, (dec.), no.   4860/09, §§   19-26, 26   March 2013 ) that the Compensation Commission established by Law   no.   6384, insofar as it is a priori accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 §   1 of the Convention. Accordingly, the applicants should avail themselves of the new remedy offered by Law   no.   6384. It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§   1 and   4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies. II.     ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 13 OF THE CONVENTION Some of the applicants complained that there was no effective remedy under Turkish law. They relied, in this regard, on Article 13 of the Convention, which provides:   “Everyone whose rights and freedoms as set forth in this Convention are violated shall have an effective remedy before a national authority notwithstanding that the violation has been committed by persons acting in an official capacity.” The Court recalls that the Compensation Commission established by Law No. 6384 provides for a remedy to the applicants within the meaning of Article 13 of the Convention to complain about the length of proceedings for the purposes of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention relating to all applications pending before the Court submitted before 23 September 2012 ( Müdür Turgut and Others (cited above, § 59)). It follows that this part of the application is manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention. III.     OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATION OF VARIOUS ARTICLES OF THE CONVENTION AND ITS PROTOCOLS The applicants invoked various articles of the Convention and its Protocols. The Court considers that it is not at this stage able to determine whether these complaints should be communicated to the Government in accordance with Rule 54 § 2 (b) of the Rules of Court, and adjourns their examination. For these reasons, the Court unanimously Declares the complaints concerning the length of the proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy for undue length of proceedings inadmissible; Decides to adjourn the examination of the remainder of the application. Stanley Naismith   Guido Raimondi   Registrar   President Appendix   No Application No Lodged on Applicant Date of birth Place of residence Represented by Notes   21786/04 10/05/2004 Murat HAÇİKOĞLU 01/02/1959 İstanbul     Court of Cassation E:2003/5569, K:2003/1912   45102/04 20/09/2004 Doğan BİLGİNOĞLU 29/07/1934 İstanbul     Court of Cassation E:2006/10245, K:2006/11780   2508/05 08/12/2004 Aydın GÜZEL 12/06/1974 İstanbul   Kıymet KARAMAN 21/12/1976 İstanbul   Tahir LAÇİN 01/03/1961 Ankara   Faruk Nafiz ERTEKİN Court of Cassation E:2004/449, K:2004/2158   21323/05 28/05/2005 Nihat BALLI 12/03/1962   Hülya SARSAM     26123/05 21/06/2005 Ökkeş ERDEM 16/08/1955 Osmaniye   Mehmet ÜNLÜ Court of Cassation E:2005/387, K:2005/1553     35112/05 16/09/2005 Ergin İŞSEVER 05/05/1952 İstanbul     Court of Cassation E:2004/18121, K:2005/7262   37379/05 27/09/2005 İsa SİRKECİ 01/01/1933 İzmir         Emine ÇOLAK YAVUZ Supreme Administrative Court E: 2005/651, K: 2006/1905     37431/05 22/09/2005 Şevket EKİN 01/01/1933 Diyarbakır   Ahmet EKİN Kocaköy   Abdullah EKİN Kocaköy   Mahmut EKİN Kocaköy   Ramazan EKİN Kocaköy   Hasan EKİN Kocaköy   Hakkı EKİN Kocaköy     Emine EKİN ( YILDIZ ) Mehmet EKİN 10/04/1953 Diyarbakır   Arzu PAMUKÇU YÖRDEM Diyarbakır Cadastral Court E: 2004/11   41067/05 24/10/2005 Şevki AKHUY Tekirdağ H. Şahin KOÇER Supreme Military Administrative Court E: 2007/301, K: 2007/369               2583/06 14/12/2005 Mehmet Erdoğan DİNÇER Rize   Keziban YILMAZ Diyarbakır 6. Assize Court E:2005/62, K:2006/596               33206/06 14/08/2006 Ömer Barbaros BOYAR 16/06/1964 Mersin   Tekin AKILLIOĞLU Court of Cassation E:2005/13816, K:2006/1410             33700/06 28/06/2006 Zeynel Abidin TÜRKDOĞAN 01/01/1983 İstanbul Metin FİLORİNALI               37416/06 22/08/2006 Turan ABALIOĞLU 08/08/1934 Denizli     Supreme Administrative Court E:2000/2712, K:001/4194               41479/06 14/09/2006 Güllü EKREM 01/03/1960 Tunceli   Mehmet EKREM 01/01/1931 Tunceli   Dilek EKREM 25/10/1980 Tunceli       Oktay EKREM 08/04/1983 Tunceli   Nuray EKREM 01/05/1987 Tunceli   Nurhak EKREM 11/03/1984 Tunceli   Ali EKREM   Delali EKREM   İpek EKREM   Çiçek EKREM   Yeter EKREM   Feride EKREM Yıldız İMREK Supreme Administrative Court E:2003/1139, K:2006/691             42019/06 10/10/2006 Yaşar ALALOĞLU 25/03/1926 Ankara   Süleyman ALTAY 07/02/1926 Ankara   Makbule ALTAY (EKŞİOĞLU) 30/08/1945 Ankara   Mefharet ALTAY (KARADENİZ) 08/02/1950 Ankara   Perihan ALTAY (AKYOL) 08/02/1956 Ankara   Süreyya ALTAY (KARADAVUT) 11/02/1963 Ankara   Tahsine ALALOĞLU Egirdir Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E:1981/103, K:2006/56             42507/06 17/10/2006 Mikail TÜZÜN 01/08/1960 İstanbul     İstanbul 4. Administrative Court E:1998             9161/07 15/02/2007 Ali DEMİR 03/02/1955 Adana   Adil AKTAY Court of Cassation E:2006/8186, K:2006/10499               9802/07 16/02/2007 Asya Öznur BOZDUMAN 13/01/1979 Konak / İzmir   Suat ÇETİNKAYA Cour d’assises İzmir E:2006/136             10945/07 23/02/2007 Mehmet Şefik YOLUK 01/03/1962 İzmir   Bülent İNCİ Court of Cassation E: 2006/9848, K:2006/10643             10959/07 06/02/2007 Yalçın KAZAN 21/09/1954 Aydın     Supreme Administrative Court E: 2003/901, K:2006/135               11703/07 05/03/2007 Elif Nihan KAFES 20/07/1972 Ankara     Supreme Administrative Court E: 2005/1146, K:2006/5006               11882/07 26/02/2007 Veli BİLGE 19/06/1957 Ankara     Supreme Administrative Court E:2003/2868, K:2006/6866               11985/07 15/03/2007 Oğuz ODABAŞIOĞLU Gaziantep     Kilis Assize Court E:2000/164             12936/07 08/03/2007 Aziz DOĞAN 06/05/1979 İstanbul   Orhan YILDIRIM Supreme Military Administrative Court E:2006/1207, K:2006/1201             14525/07 22/03/2007 Gürkan ÖZTÜRK 02/05/1980 Gümüşhane       Court of Cassation E:2006/6406               15855/07 05/04/2007 DEKOPEN DEKORASYON İNŞAAT SANAYİ TİCARET LTD ŞTİ İzmir   Hafize ÇOBANOĞLU Court of Cassation E:2006/3840, K:2006/88247             19240/07 02/05/2007 Tamer AYDIN 06/01/1961 İstanbul   Celal ÜLGEN Court of Cassation E:2006/3235, K:2006/9239               19258/07 17/04/2007 Arif DÖNMEZ 01/01/1947 İstanbul   Miyesser DÖNMEZ 01/01/1927 İstanbul Şeref DÖNMEZ 01/01/1949 İstanbul   Şevki DÖNMEZ 01/01/1952 İstanbul   Şehnaz DÖNMEZ 01/01/1956 İstanbul   Mustafa DÖNMEZ 01/01/1964 İstanbul   Fatma DÖNMEZ 01/01/1951 İstanbul   Ahmet DÖNMEZ 01/01/1956 İstanbul Fahriye DÖNMEZ 01/01/1963 İstanbul   Neriman GÜNAR 01/01/1935 İstanbul   Nizami SERİN 01/01/1945 İstanbul   Gülserin SARISOY 01/01/1951 İstanbul   Arif DÖNMEZ Court of Cassation E:2006/554, K:2006/7200             20039/07 01/05/2007 Ömer CANAL 06/02/1950 Adana     Court of Cassation E:2006/3691, K:2006/58647               20524/07 02/05/2007 Ümit DÖNMEZ 10/11/1958 İstanbul Ali DÖNMEZ 01/01/1956   Hüseyin DÖNMEZ 01/01/1958 İstanbul     Tuzla Cadastral Court E:1998/1, K:2004/1               22388/07 03/05/2007 Zeki KAYA 20/11/1960 Bursa   Mustafa YAĞCI Supreme Administrative Court E:2007-1697             22438/07 22/05/2007 Tacettin TURAN 03/02/1974 Erzurum   Rehşan BATARAY SAMAN Court of Cassation E:2007/9401, K:2008/1363             24833/07 05/06/2007 Veysi MERAL 01/08/1986 İstanbul   İnan AKMEŞE Bakirkoy 5. Assize Court, E:2006/150, K:2007/77               25148/07 05/06/2007 Mehmet Emin EKİNCİ 20/04/1986 Tekirdağ İnan AKMEŞE Court of Cassation E:2009/4103, K:2011/2421               25457/07 30/05/2007 Abdurrahman ACAR 01/01/1938 Mardin   Felemez ACAR 24/01/1949 Mardin   Nimettullah ALAS 02/04/1974 Mardin   Heybettullah ALAS 05/02/1970 Mardin     Cadastral Court E:1993/10, K:2003/11             26179/07 18/06/2007 Necip Mümtaz ŞEREFLİ 15/05/1926 Muğla   Firuzan TOPALOĞLU 01/01/1921 Muğla   Habibe RONA İstanbul   Nevcihan ERTUĞLU 18/01/1928 İstanbul   Firdevs Hepgül SELÇİK 14/06/1968 İzmir   Meltem ÖZKAYA 01/01/1964 İzmir   Zümrüt ONAY 10/02/1937 Muğla   Gülümser ERTAN 18/05/1933 İzmir   Engin ONAY 04/09/1964 İzmir   Adviye ONAY 17/04/1963 İzmir   Oktay UĞURAL Cadastral Court E:1991/311, K:2003/364               27582/07 21/06/2007 Mehmet Zeki ÇELEBİ 18/04/1973 Van Mehmet ERBİL Court of Cassation E:2009/18793, K:2010/4435               27720/07 21/06/2007 Merih ŞUĞLE 01/06/1942 Zonguldak   Zuhal YILMAZ 01/01/1951 Zonguldak   Hikmet YILMAZ 01/03/1926 Ankara   Nevire TANYERİ 26/05/1940 Zonguldak   H. Mehlika SUGLE Court of Cassation E: 2010/1058, K: 2010/6331               28708/07 03/07/2007 Figen YALIM 01/09/1965 Ankara   Mustafa Tuncer ÖZVEREN Court of Cassation E:2006/9843, K:2006/15035             29231/07 12/07/2007 Necip Mümtaz ŞEREFLİ 15/05/1926 Muğla   Firuzan TOPALOĞLU 01/01/1921 Muğla     Habibe RONA İstanbul   Nevcihan ERTUĞLU 18/01/1928 İstanbul   Firdevs Hepgül SELÇİK 14/06/1968 İzmir   Meltem ÖZKAYA 01/01/1964 İzmir   Zümrüt ONAY 10/02/1937 Muğla   Gülümser ERTAN 18/05/1933 İzmir   Engin ONAY 04/09/1964 İzmir   Adviye ONAY 17/04/1963 İzmir   Oktay UĞURAL Cadastral Court E:1978/49, K:2004/36               34157/07 25/07/2007 Tacettin GÜVEN 07/06/1980 İzmir   Türkan ASLAN Assize Court E:2005/44; K:2005/435               34486/07 04/08/2007 Musa İSLAMOĞLU 01/02/1938   Halil İbrahim ÖZDEMİR Court of Cassation E:2006/12064, K:2007/634               36675/07 15/08/2007 Tokay TOZKOPARAN 29/12/1940 İzmir Tamay ARSLANÇERİ Court of Cassation E.2006/17436, K.2006/1862               36897/07 19/08/2007 Bilal AKYILDIZ 06/08/1972 İstanbul     Mehmet YAVUZ Court of Cassation E:2011/6843; K:2011/4625               38077/07 17/08/2007 Mehmet AKSOY 01/01/1932 Şanlıurfa   Hikmet TEPE Court of Cassation E.2006/8819, K.2006/10882               38549/07 28/08/2007 Ali ÖZDEMİR 15/09/1965 İstanbul   Doğan GÜR Assize Court K:2007/84             41884/07 12/09/2007 Mehmet İdris YAMAN 01/09/1965 Diyarbakır   Ahmet AY Supreme Military Administrative Court E:2006/8819, K:2006/10882               43196/07 03/10/2007 Ali YILDIRIM 01/01/1921 İzmir Hasan PİLAVCI Court of Cassation E:2006/14473, K:2007/2427               43978/07 08/10/2007 MİM MERMER MADENCİLİK SAN. VE TİC. A.Ş. Amasya   Rumi POLAT Supreme Administrative Court E:2006/4529, K:2007/1238             44982/07 28/09/2007 Ahmet ÖNAL 05/04/1956 İstanbul   Erhan ASLANER Court of Cassation E.2007/1421, K.2007/2779             45940/07 08/10/2007 Recep KUKUL Samsun   Remziye KUKUL Samsun   Osman KUKUL Samsun   Senem KUKUL Samsun   Ayse KUKUL Samsun   Ahmet KUKUL Samsun     Mevlüt BURSALI Court of Cassation E:2006/18204, K:2007/7582             48586/07 22/10/2007 Hampar MİROĞLU 23/05/1934 İstanbul   Heriknaz ASLANYAN 01/01/1924 İstanbul   Zaruk MEYDAN İstanbul   Livon ARSLANYAN 10/01/1943 İstanbul   Heriknaz MİROĞLU 20/10/1928 İstanbul   Mircan MİROĞLU 13/08/1956 İstanbul   Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK Assize Court E:2000/378             49468/07 01/11/2007 Aydın ÖZDEMİR 01/01/1975 Diyarbakır   Şehmus ÖZDEMİR 05/01/1956 Diyarbakır   Mehmet ÖZDEMİR 01/02/1953 Diyarbakır   Halis AYÇİÇEK Ergani Cadastral Court E:1979/65, K:2003/2             50909/07 07/11/2007 Mahzar ZÜMRÜT 01/01/1953 Diyarbakır   Süleyman BEYSULEN Ankara Administrative Court E:1997/174               51088/07 13/11/2007 Ali Ahmet ÇANDAR 20/02/1967 Balıkesir   Hasan ŞAFAK Court of Cassation E:2006/32279, K:2007/18322             51587/07 23/11/2007 Ahmet Şevki PÜRSELİM 26/09/1947 Trabzon   Hasibe Gülşah PÜRSELİM Trabzon Administrative Court E:2000/669             52718/07 29/11/2007 Yakup KAÇAR 29/07/1959 Amasya     Supreme Administrative Court K:2007/784               53863/07 22/11/2007 Abdurrahman KILIÇ 04/02/1951 İstanbul     Catalca Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E:2003/414             53898/07 01/12/2007 Recep AYDIN 28/06/1960 İstanbul     Hamiyet AYDIN 15/01/1965 İstanbul     Ali ÖNCEL               54136/07 24/10/2007 Şükrü AYDOĞDU 01/01/1963 Malatya   Fazıl Ahmet TAMER İstanbul Assize Court K:2005/64             55000/07 22/11/2007 Şükran KESİN 01/01/1960 Ordu   Enes KESİN 26/01/1988 Ordu   Hava KESİN KEZER 17/03/1985 Ordu       Nurcan KESIN KABULU 12/05/1984 Ordu   Ali TÜRKMEN Samsun 1. Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E:1989/413, K:1997/419             55050/07 07/12/2007 Ömer ZAMBAK 02/08/1979 Denizli   Magistrates’ Court (in criminal matters) E:2004/160, K:2007/595               56373/07 11/12/2007 Asiye GÜZEL (ZEYBEK) 20/09/1970 İstanbul   Ercan KANAR İstanbul 11. Assize Court K:2008/260             56473/07 18/12/2007 Ahmet KEMENÇE 14/06/1935 Çanakkale   Hatice KEMENÇE Çanakkale   Osman KEMENÇE 24/07/1964 Çanakkale   Mehmet KEMENÇE 02/10/1959 Çanakkale   Muharrem KEMENÇE 09/01/1956 Çanakkale   Sevgi GEZER 05/12/1962 Çanakkale   Şenol ÖZKAN 24/07/1964 Çanakkale   Mustafa ÖZTOK Court of Cassation K:2006/6123             67/08 12/12/2007 Mustafa SAYIN 06/08/1948 Ankara   Necla ÖZCAN 04/03/1945 Ankara   Kaan ÖZCAN 22/11/1968 İstanbul   Banu ÖZCAN BRORSEN 30/03/1971 İstanbul   Olcayto ERTUĞRUL Court of Cassation E:2007/4304, K:2007/5144             550/08 25/12/2007 Bülent ÇUBUKÇUOĞLU 23/05/1952 Balıkesir   Akif KARAPINAR Court of Cassation E;2007/8477, K:2007/9009               699/08 26/12/2007 Yasin SUVEREN 01/01/1970 Şanlıurfa   Mehmet Sait POLAT 01/01/1974 Adana   Mehmet SUVEREN 01/01/1957 İstanbul   Mehmet Nuri POLAT 01/01/1976 Adana   Ali SUVEREN 01/01/1957 Şanlıurfa   Mehmet SUVEREN 01/01/1933 Şanlıurfa   Şengül BİRLEŞTİRİCİ Court of Cassation E:2007/5269             1621/08 31/12/2007 Mehmet LÜTOĞLU 01/01/1952 Çanakkale     Özlem YILMAZ Ayvalık Magistrates’ Court (in civil matters) E:1999/330, K:2007/273               1766/08 03/01/2008 Nebahat SUCU 01/09/1935 Ankara   Zeynep AŞÇIOĞLU İstanbul Administrative Court E:1996/267             4911/08 16/01/2008 Mustafa YAYLAMAZ 04/03/1963 Kahramanmaraş Hüseyin GÜRSOY Court of Cassation E:2009/1908, K:2009/14735               4999/08 27/01/2008 Ayşe Lütfiye KOMİLİ 03/07/1944 İstanbul   Kazım BERZEG Court of Cassation E:2010/401, K:2010/2207             6310/08 18/12/2007 Ekrem ELMAS 15/05/1953 Bandırma     Supreme Administrative Court E:2006/4004, K:2007/584               6602/08 04/02/2008 Yusuf SUVEREN 01/01/1950 Şanlıurfa   Yılmaz AKMAN 01/01/1974 Şanlıurfa   Ahmet SUVEREN 01/01/1940 Şanlıurfa   Şengül BİRLEŞTİRİCİ Bozova Cadastral Court E:1992/94             6786/08 04/02/2008 Defne Tanyeli ÖZENBAŞ 04/01/1969 Muğla     Court of Cassation E:2006/3480, K:2006/4347             8104/08 04/02/2008 Ahmet SUVEREN 08/09/1940 Şanlıurfa   Şengül BİRLEŞTİRİCİ Court of Cassation E:2007/5269             8190/08 04/02/2008 Yılmaz AKMAN 01/01/1974 Şanlıurfa   Şengül BİRLEŞTİRİCİ Court of Cassation E:2007/5269             9048/08 19/02/2008 Remezan AKMAN 11/04/1971 Adana   Müyesser ALTUN 01/02/1954 Adana   Şengül BİRLEŞTİRİCİ Court of Cassation E:2007/5269               9986/08 22/02/2008 Yakup ARAT İstanbul   Mustafa KESKİN Court of Cassation E:2006/18198, K:2007/869               10796/08 24/12/2007 Mehmet KESKİN 22/12/1960 Kocaeli     Supreme Administrative Court E:2005/2647, K:2007/5016               10799/08 18/02/2008 Vural SOYTEKİN 13/05/1945 İstanbul     Ayhan SARIHAN Court of Cassation E:2007/7505, K:2007/10518             11383/08 29/02/2008 S.S. HASATKENT KONUT YAPI KOOPERATIFI Ankara   Hüseyin ERDAYANDI Court of Cassation E:2006/382, K:2006/783                 11519/08 15/02/2008 Hassan EL SAHEB 30/05/1962 Langenargen Jülide ERTÜRK Supreme Administrative Court E:2004/8038, K:2004/7170               11524/08 23/02/2008 Barış GÖDEKOĞLU 14/06/1998 İstanbul   Ali GÖDEKOĞLU Supreme Administrative Court E:2005/8163, K:2007/42               12056/08 10/03/2008 Hacı ALTUN 01/11/1970 Adana   Şengül BİRLEŞTİRİCİ Bozova Cadastral Court E:1992/94, K:2007/1               14407/08 19/03/2008 Ramazan CANHİLAL 17/03/1963 Kayseri   Oğuz KEÇEBAŞ Supreme Administrative Court E:2004/4003, K:2005/3203               16579/08 03/04/2008 ÇINAR TURİZM İNŞAAT TİCARET LTD ŞTİ İzmir   Doğan EVRİM Court of Cassation E:2007/3389, K:2007/6015             20364/08 14/04/2008 Lütfiye DEVELİOĞLU 01/07/1925 Kadıköy / İstanbul   Fevziye ERGÜN 23/02/1949 Cihangir / İstanbul   Hatice DEVELİOĞLU 14/03/1958 Cihangir / İstanbul   Nurhan DEVELİOĞLU 16/02/1938 Kadiköy / İstanbul   Beyhan APAYDIN 15/01/1940 Kadıköy / İstanbul   Nihat DEVELİOĞLU 28/07/1957 İstanbul   Feyzullah Cihat DEVELİOĞLU 11/08/1947 Siteler / İstanbul       Şemsi Hatun DEVELİOĞLU 01/01/1932 Kadıköy / İstanbul   Dilara YEGANİ 18/10/1953 Edmonton   Önder DEVELİOĞLU 02/01/1978 Kadıköy / İstanbul   Yayha Özgür DEVELİOĞLU 30/04/1989 İstanbul   İbrahim KANLIÖZ Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E:958/17             21392/08 21/04/2008 Şükrü KARAHASANOĞLU 01/02/1947 İstanbul   Eyüp ERASLAN Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E:2001/1200, K:2006/132               22941/08 08/05/2008 Emine Esmehan KAFALI 19/01/1940 İstanbul     Court of Cassation E:2005/4556, K:2006/3840             23063/08 13/05/2008 Fatma KIZILTEPE 01/07/1939 İstanbul   Semra KALYONCU Court of Cassation E:2006/8999, K:2006/11528             23621/08 05/05/2008 Ahmet TİĞİZ 01/06/1948 Batman   Şakir TOĞLUK Court of Cassation E:2005/507, K:2005/28701               25604/08 07/05/2008 Ayten DURMUŞ 04/01/1966 Ankara     Supreme Administrative Court K:2007/3837             25875/08 11/05/2008 Özer KARADAĞ 29/05/1963 Kars     Onur GÜNDOĞDU Court of Cassation E:2006/10285, K:2007/7511             26937/08 05/06/2008 Hazal KINACI 01/02/1942 İzmir   Cahit KINACI 01/04/1989 İzmir   Şadiye BALCI 01/10/1974 İzmir   Reis KINACI 01/10/1975 İzmir   Nahit KINACI 01/10/1983 Bayburt   Türkan GÜNDÜZ 01/10/1985 İzmir   Nihat KINACI 01/10/1980 İzmir   Hediye KINACI 01/10/1972 İzmir   Bülent KINACI 01/10/1978 İzmir   Bülent İNCİ Court of Cassation E:2002/5357, K:2002/6039               27006/08 16/05/2008 Necip Mümtaz ŞEREFLİ 15/05/1926 Muğla   Firuzan TOPALOĞLU 01/01/1921 Muğla   Habibe RONA İstanbul   Nevcihan ERTUĞLU 18/01/1928 İstanbul   Firdevs Hepgül SELÇİK 14/06/1968 İzmir   Meltem ÖZKAYA 01/01/1964 İzmir   Zümrüt ONAY 10/02/1937 Muğla   Gülümser ERTAN 18/05/1933 İzmir       Engin ONAY 04/09/1964 İzmir   Adviye ONAY 17/04/1963 İzmir   Oktay UĞURAL Court of Cassation E:1994/4609, K:1994/6801             30369/08 10/06/2008 Fatma KARBEYAZ 01/03/1933 Osmaniye   Hava BESNEK 01/01/1929 Osmaniye   Lütfi ÖZKAN Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E:2003/458, K:2007/515             30912/08 13/06/2008 Ali Fuat HACIBEBEKOĞLU 01/01/1956 Kahramanmaraş   İsmet HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Sevim HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Nurhayat HACIBEBEKOĞLU     Döndü HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Perihan ALTUN 01/01/1944   Hacı Bebek HACIBEBEKOGLU   Bünyamin HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Yusuf Selami HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Abdulkadir HACIBEBEKOGLU   Cevdet HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Hacı HACIBEBEKOĞLU Fetiye KARKMAZ   Nail HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Ali ŞEREFOĞLU   Hatice SARIFAKİOĞLU   Ferahnaz CİĞER   Semra BOZKURT   Mediha FINDIK   Fatih HACIBEBEKOĞLU Elife ÇETİN   Gürsel HACIBEBEKOĞLU     Cahit HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Gönül HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Fetiye HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Emin HACIBEBEKOGLU   Şehnaz KARAMAN     Zeynep SARIFAKİOĞLU   Hediye HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Şih İbrahim HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Elife HACIBEBEKOĞLU 11/08/1964   Osman HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Süleyman HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Elife HACIBEBEKOĞLU 01/01/1961   Eşeli İYİBİÇER   Müberra ARABACI   Hatice ARAS   Zerrin ARAS   Nevin HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Eşeli ALTUN   Nurlu AYDIN   Fatma HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Pama HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Bilal HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Ali HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Muammer HACIBEBEKOĞLU   Yusuf ALATAŞ Court of Cassation E:989/402, K:990/362             31619/08 26/06/2008 Abdullah CAVLI 06/02/1968 Elazığ   Burhan ŞENER Supreme Administrative Court E:2005/4444, K:2007/4980               32623/08 27/06/2008 Sezen DÜZKAYA 02/02/1950 Ankara   Haluk AVCI Court of Cassation E:2006/4573, K:2007/7032        33331/08 26/06/2008 Abdulcelil KAÇMAZ 01/03/1967 İzmit   Fatma KARAKAŞ DOĞAN Court of Cassation E:2007/12593, K:2008/2885        34226/08 03/07/2008 Hüseyin KÖSEOĞLU 01/06/1948 Tekirdağ   Court of Cassation E:2007/14516, K:2007/16293        35215/08 11/07/2008 Ali Timurtaş ÖZMEN 21/01/1966 Ankara       Court of Cassation E:2007/10074, K:2008/5268        35765/08 04/07/2008 H.A. 02/03/1950 İdil / Şırnak   Meral DANIŞ BEŞTAŞ Court of Cassation E:2007/9368, K:2007/9278        36446/08 24/06/2008 Nurettin CEYHUN 28/01/1955 Polatlı / Ankara   Mehmet CEYHUN 16/12/1964 Ankara   Halit CEYHUN 15/07/1959 Ankara       Saffet SEYİRT 06/02/1954 Polatlı / Ankara   Cemal CEYHUN 01/01/1957 Polatlı / Ankara   Hüseyin Hayrettin ERDOĞAN Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E:1993/161          36567/08 17/07/2008 Nurettin CILI 01/01/1956 Manavgat Ümit UYSAL Court of Cassation K:2004/960        37758/08 25/07/2008 Ayse TİMURLENK 01/01/1948 Ankara   Nuran ÖZDEMİR Administrative Court E:2010/334, K:2010/512          37759/08 04/08/2008 SERTAÇ DERİ İNŞAAT VE TURİZM SAN. VE TİC. LTD. ŞTİ. Manisa       Olcay ÖZTÜRK          37793/08 29/07/2008 Jak ARDİTİ 16/06/1964 İzmir   Rebeka ARDİTİ 18/09/1930 İzmir   Grasyela BARKİ 21/02/1959 İzmir   İstreya ÇAVEZ 17/12/1927 İstanbul   Aline FRIEND 03/07/1948 Johannesburg   Abraham CUNIO 20/07/1945 Cape Town Gülnur ERDOĞAN Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E:1976/5, K:1987/229        37873/08 28/07/2008 Seyfettin ANT 15/10/1971 İstanbul   Seyit Ali KOÇ Admistrative Court E:2008/1214, K:2008/526        37874/08 25/07/2008 Çetin YAŞ 20/12/1969 Erbaa   Mehmet KÖKSAL Court of Cassation E:2007/2613, K:2007/9899        38121/08 30/07/2008 İbrahim BACACI 06/11/1969 İstanbul   Mine KOCAOĞLU Court of Cassation E:2007/14402, K:2008/6664        39425/08 01/08/2008 Salih YILDIRIM 10/03/1976 Osmaniye     State Security Court E:2000/94        40281/08 12/08/2008 Akın SÖNMEZ 19/11/1968 Sivas Kadriye ÇAPAN Supreme Administrative Court E:2006/3121, K:2008/186            41091/08 19/08/2008 Nevzat AYIRKAN 21/09/1981 İstanbul   Court of Cassation E:2008/8494, K:2008/8882          41199/08 01/08/2008 M. Ali AKAR 01/01/1946 Ordu   F. Esin AKINCIOĞLU 01/01/1949 Ankara   Saime AKKUŞ 16/08/1945 İstanbul   Zennure AKMAN 01/01/1952 Adana   Hüseyin AKSU 15/02/1948 Kırklareli   Ali AKTOLUN 03/04/1940 İstanbul   Hüseyin Cahit ALICI 19/09/1940 İstanbul   Hasan ARĞIÇ 01/03/1953 İstanbul   Münevver ARIKAN 02/11/1945 Adana   Özden ARIKAN 21/02/1954 Antalya       Ayla ARKUN 01/12/1941 Adana   Mahmure ARSLAN 18/05/1945 Ordu   Satiye Yaşar ATAMAN 28/06/1947 İstanbul   Halil İbrahim AVAN 01/01/1950 Mersin   Metin AYDIN 27/04/1941 Antalya   Fatma AYKUT 01/01/1950 Yalova   Malik AYTAÇ 10/01/1947 Antalya   Münevver AYTEKİN 09/04/1953 Ankara   Dede BADEM 04/01/1950 Antalya   Hacer BAĞLAN 01/01/1955 Antalya   H. Şirin BALA 01/01/1940 Ankara       Ali BALCI 19/03/1945 Antalya   Gülten BANAZ 01/02/1942 Eskişehir   Cevdet BAYHAN 02/04/1936 Erzurum   Ayhan BAYKAL 01/01/1945 Eskişehir   Mecit BAYRAKTAR 06/06/1943 Bursa         Serap Feride BAYRAKTAROĞLU 07/03/1953 İstanbul   Sema BEŞİBİRLİK 01/06/1950 Ankara   Fadile BİÇER 01/09/1954 İstanbul   Nuran BİNGÖL 12/01/1951 İstanbul   Çiçek BOĞATUR 19/02/1946 Bursa       Fahri ÇAĞLAR 18/02/1962 Bursa   Ümmügülsüm ÇALDAĞI 13/12/1952 Antalya   Hayri ÇETİN 01/06/1952 Antalya   Nadir ÇIRAK 23/06/1944 Antalya   Yaşiye DEMİRBAŞ 01/01/1943 Ankara       Cengiz DEMİREL 12/02/1936 Ankara   Fadime DERİNEL 02/03/1952 İstanbul   Gülay DOĞUÇ 01/04/1948 İstanbul   Aziz ELÇİN 05/09/1943 Antalya   Hüsniye ERALP 08/06/1949 Kırklareli   Salih ERBİL 01/01/1937 Kırklareli   Selma ERDAL 04/06/1954 Adana   Ali ERDEM 01/01/1942 Mersin   Gülçin ERDEM 21/09/1952 Kırklareli   Altan ERDOĞAN 16/08/1949 İstanbul   Mustafa ERDOĞAN 06/12/1951 İstanbul       Mehmet ERENLERÇAYI 01/01/1949 Tekirdağ   Saniye ERSOY 01/03/1949 İstanbul   Duran ERTEM 01/01/1941 Hatay   Halil ESKİCİ 01/01/1936 Edremit   Arslan FAKIOĞLU 18/09/1942 Antalya       Aytan FAKIOĞLU 22/06/1939 Antalya   Necmiye GEZİCİ 01/01/1951 Ankara   Süleyman GÖK 01/05/1942 Mersin   Hasan GÖKÇEOĞLU 04/10/1945 Antalya   Ertan GÖKSEL 06/11/1935 İstanbul   Sunay GÖYNÜŞEN 22/11/1953 İstanbul   Ayten GÜÇYETMEZ 24/10/1948 İstanbul   Mazlume GÜL 01/01/1938 Ankara   Osman GÜL 01/01/1953 Ankara   Nebahat GÜLÇİN 27/11/1948 Bursa   Mehmet GÜLDİKER 10/08/1950 Antalya       Bilge GÜMÜŞ 01/01/1951 Ordu   Rabia GÜNDEŞ 01/01/1938 Ankara   Cemal GÜVEN Bursa   Ferit Tan HİSAR 11/07/1938 Ankara   Mete ILGAR 12/10/1946 İstanbul   Ülkü IŞIKURAN 12/06/1945 Bursa   Hatice İLBARS 06/04/1948 Ankara   Ahmet İLKSOY 23/06/1944 Kırklareli   Aynur İLTER 05/12/1949 Antalya Pınar KANDİL 15/05/1945 Mersin   Melek KARGI 01/01/1944 Ordu   Fatma Nuran KASAROĞLU 06/07/1950 Antalya   Semra G. KETECİ 01/01/1953 Yalova   Taliye KILIÇKAYA 15/02/1945 Ordu   İnciser KOCABIÇAK 01/12/1941 İstanbul   Mehmet Erdoğan KÖKSAL 02/04/1937 İstanbul   Susamber KÖKSALAN 01/02/1950 Adana     Mehmet Turgut KUMBASAR 07/01/1948 Bursa   Şefika KÜÇÜKKAHRAMAN 06/04/1945 İstanbul   Nurhan LEBLEBİCİ 13/07/1947 İzmit   Selahattin MADEN 09/01/1941 Mersin   Yaşar MUTLU 18/01/1941 Fethiye     Şükran OBUZ 01/01/1940 Ankara   Yıldız OĞUZKAN 10/07/1947 İstanbul   Hülya OKTAYER 19/10/1945 Eskişehir   Gülsüm OKVURAN 01/01/1946 Yalova   Orhan OLCAYTU 01/01/1919 Ankara   Sevgi OTMAN 30/01/1951 İstanbul   Abbas Kemal OZAN 20/07/1935 Ankara   İhsan ÖZ 09/01/1953 İstanbul   Zehra ÖZAKTAŞ 04/04/1951 Bursa   Ülviye ÖZCAN 01/01/1945 Ankara   Özkan ÖZER 01/04/1937 Ankara       Gülşen ÖZGENÇ 09/03/1944 Ankara   Perihan ÖZKAN 02/06/1949 Ankara   Nail PALA 20/01/1936 Ankara   Okan PALA 27/08/1982 Ankara   Sabriye PARLAR 01/01/1948 Bursa   Zeliha POJODACU 01/08/1945 Adana   Gönül POSTOĞLU 05/03/1952 Bursa   Hacer Nalan SARAÇOĞLU 12/10/1948 İstanbul   Seyithan SAVAŞÇI 24/03/1941 Ankara   Suna SAYĞAN 25/04/1948 İstanbul   Celal SEZER 10/01/1941 Ankara     Yüksel SIRAY 10/01/1943 Düzce   Türkan SOMUNCU 15/12/1941 İstanbul   F. Deniz SOMUNKIRAN 01/01/1940 Ankara   Ziynet ŞİMŞEK 25/12/1949 İstanbul   Alaeddin SÖYLEMEZOĞLU 01/01/1934 Mersin       Ergül ŞAMİLOĞLU 26/10/1948 İstanbul   Ali Riza ŞAN 05/01/1944 Antalya   Naime Nuran ŞEN 14/11/1952 Antalya   Fikriye TARAKÇI 01/01/1953 Bursa   Necdet TARTAR 25/07/1943 Edremit   Sudiye TAŞTEKİN 05/07/1952 Eskişehir   Yunus TATLICAN 09/04/1946 Ordu   Ali Tekmen TEK 04/07/1944 Adana   Fatma TEK 10/01/1952 Adana   Cevat TEKELİ 01/01/1944 Antalya   Ayşe Dudu TOKSÖZ 22/06/1949 Antalya       Etem TOPÇU 06/01/1942 Antalya   Nedime TÖZEREN 15/02/1949 İstanbul   Sevgi TUNADOR 28/05/1948 Antalya   Atay TUNCER 23/05/1941 İstanbul   Berna TUNCER 15/03/1942 İstanbul   Turhan TUNÇKIRAN 02/07/1936 Mersin   İlhan TURAN 17/06/1947 İstanbul   Şahin TÜRK 15/01/1941 İstanbul   Şeref UÇKAN 01/01/1939 Antalya   Nermin ULA 04/06/1948 İstanbul   Mehmet ULUKAN 10/08/1953 Antalya       Nuriye URÇEK 01/01/1947 Ankara   Regaip UYSAL 23/05/1947 İstanbul   İsmet UZ 16/04/1947 Vize   Aytaç UZEL 01/01/1942 Ankara   Selma UZEL 22/02/1949 Ankara   Mustafa ÜNVER 01/01/1941 Maraş Sezai YALÇIN 01/01/1944 İstanbul   Mualla YARLI 31/07/1949 İstanbul   Ayten YEŞİLYURT 01/01/1948 Ankara   Nahide YILDIRIM 11/06/1948 Antalya   Müberra YILDIZ 25/03/1948 İstanbul   Güner YILMAZ 11/07/1940 İstanbul Sebahat YILMAZ 01/07/1942 Ankara   Sibel YİĞENOĞLU 02/06/1952 Adana   İlhami AYAZ 01/01/1960 İstanbul   İlhami AYAZ          43033/08 01/09/2008 Mehmet Remzi KAYA 04/04/1969 Adana     Adana Assize Court E:2005/123, K:2007/112        43085/08 02/09/2008 Mehmet ÇETİN 10/11/1959 Berlin         Court of Cassation E:2008/6947, K:2008/7640        43809/08 03/09/2008 Hayri ÇEVİK 10/09/1955 Tekirdağ   Ürfet ÇEVİK 12/01/1960 Tekirdağ   Aytekin ÇEVİK 02/04/1979 Tekirdağ   Bilge ÇEVİK 20/02/1987 Tekirdağ   İlkay SEZER Supreme Military Administrative Court E:2007/830, K:2008/284          44485/08 12/09/2008 Şerife Fatma Beylün SEZERAR 16/09/1921 İstanbul       Şerife Fatma Rain ÇELIK 21/11/1953 İstanbul   Durmuş KALAY Court of Cassation E: 2006/4422, K:2007/863        45008/08 10/09/2008 Naşit TUTAR 01/02/1971 Bayburt              47370/08 26/09/2008 Bahar ÖZBAŞ 11/05/1991   Sabri ÖZBAŞ 01/06/1960   Serkan CENGİZ          50384/08 06/10/2008 Cemalettin TURHAN 01/01/1973 İstanbul   Nazif YAVUZ Beyoğlu Assize Court E: 2008/622            51460/08 13/10/2008 Nevzat BAYRAK 01/03/1962 Kırklareli            52438/08 15/10/2008 Necmettin KARAKUŞ 01/01/1960 Ankara              52497/08 22/09/2008 Ali GÜRBÜZ 01/01/1971 Köln   İnan AKMEŞE Court of Cassation E:2009/7334, K:2011/1823          57104/08 18/11/2008 Leyla ŞENYER 04/06/1957 İzmir   Duran ŞENYER          57301/08 14/11/2008 Ayten YALÇINKAYA ÖZDEMİR 01/01/1961 Malatya              61718/08 05/12/2008 Zekeriya ŞENGÖZ 02/04/1952 Malatya     Haşim CENGİL          2050/09 12/12/2008 Mehtap SÖNMEZ 21/07/1952 Ankara   Hamdi KARADUMAN 24/07/1960 Ankara   Ahmet BAKÜLÜER 23/04/1952 Ankara   Hatice Canan YOSULÇAY 01/06/1950 Ankara   ERYAMAN TOPLU YAPI YÖNETİMİ Ankara       Emel ALTINTAŞ YALÇINKAYA          4346/09 17/12/2008 Yıldıray SOYSAL Manyas   Ayşe YILDIRIM Supreme Military Administrative Court E:2008/427, K:2008/353          5917/09 22/01/2009 Doğu Cem GÜMÜŞ 17/05/1985 İstanbul   Metin FİLORİNALI İstanbul Assize Court E:1996/286, K:2008/203        5983/09 23/01/2009 Abdullah PİŞKİN 01/01/1946 İstanbul   Mualla ÖZYAPRAK          8095/09 02/02/2009 Safet DENİZ 04/12/1955 Kocaeli   Burhan DİLEK          9888/09 02/02/2009 Emin AYDIN 01/01/1944 Ankara     Medeni AYHAN          9914/09 04/02/2009 Gülseren SORGUN 06/11/1957 İstanbul   Handan YAVAŞCAN MARHAN          10534/09 03/02/2009 Önder ŞAHİN 01/03/1962 İstanbul   Gökhan CANDOĞAN              11728/09 13/02/2009 HAYDARPAŞA PETROL LTD. ŞTİ İstanbul   Serap ULUSOY Court of Cassation E:2008/10953, K:2008/12520          13839/09 16/02/2009 Recep MUCUR 22/05/1954 Antalya   Buğra YEGÜL          13859/09 16/02/2009 Nuri Sait SUCU 15/03/1964 Kayseri       Buğra YEGÜL            13876/09 16/02/2009 Ayşegül YORULMAZLAR 20/07/1976 Tahran   Buğra YEGÜL          13884/09 16/02/2009 Turgut ÇELİK 01/01/1933 Ankara   Buğra YEGÜL          14916/09 23/02/2009 Okan ÖRENCİ 01/01/1975 İstanbul   Fırat Aydın KAYA          15374/09 26/02/2009 Veysi ALAVCI 03/04/1960 İzmir   Mehmet Emin KELEŞ          17011/09 16/03/2009 İbrahim AVŞAROĞLU 30/04/1962 Şanlıurfa     Ayşe AVŞAROĞLU 01/01/1940 Şanlıurfa   Hüseyin AVŞAROĞLU 14/11/1964 Şanlıurfa   Hacer AVŞAROĞLU 12/02/1973 Şanlıurfa   Hatice ÇADIRCI 08/08/1960 Şanlıurfa   Zekeriya AVŞAROĞLU 09/12/1974 Şanlıurfa   Osman AVŞAROĞLU 18/01/1967 Şanlıurfa   Mehmet AVŞAROĞLU 20/02/1957 Şanlıurfa   Ismail AVŞAROĞLU 10/02/1968 Şanlıurfa   Abdullah AVŞAROĞLU 28/01/1970 Şanlıurfa   Mustafa DOLAP          17995/09 27/02/2009 Gül KARAKAYA 22/03/1966 Eskişehir   Nihat GÜNAYDIN Supreme Administrative Court E:2006/3731, K:2008/4123          18335/09 17/03/2009 Kamuran KAPLAN 15/09/1983 Manisa     Court of Cassation E:2009/95016          18357/09 24/03/2009 Kemal BOZKURT 01/01/1976 İzmir   Özgür SOLAK Assize Court E:2008/350, K:2008/7366        18385/09 23/02/2009 Sadettin KESKİN 18/09/1959 İstanbul   Court of Cassation E:2008/8389, K:2009/125          19734/09 31/03/2009 Taner UZUN 01/02/1968 Kozan   Murat ALPASLAN Court of Cassation E:2006/10628, K:2008/14670          23161/09 09/04/2009 Akın GÜL 07/05/1978 İzmir   Sezai AYDIN Court of Cassation E:2008/8097, K:2008/8245          23189/09 09/04/2009 Bahri SARAÇ 10/03/1964 Yalova       Gülnaz KOCA 02/10/1955 Kocaeli   Ahmet SARAÇ 23/07/1957 Yalova   Nuriye ÖZKAN 14/06/1960 Yalova   Salih GÜNAY 02/11/1961 Yalova   Hasan Kemal ELBAN Court of Cassation E:2008/8922, K:2008/12061          23522/09 03/04/2009 Bülent ÇELEBİ 24/06/1978 Bolu   A. Güçlü SEVİMLİ Court of Cassation E:2008/9408, K:2008/10621          24054/09 04/04/2009 Sabri DEMİRDÖĞEN 19/02/1942 İstanbul Serpil DALKILIÇ          24520/09 28/04/2009 GÜLBEN MEDİKAL SAN. VE TIC. LTD. STI. Manisa     Court of Cassation E:2008/6862, K:2008/10646          24541/09 30/04/2009 Ali Cihan DUMAN 23/03/1983 Gaziantep   H. Mehmet BALCI          24740/09 25/03/2009 Hasim KARAHAN 16/08/1966 Ankara   Nazan KARAHAN 01/03/1968 Ankara   Beyza Ceren KARAHAN 16/11/1999 Ankara       Zülal ERDOĞAN Court of Cassation E:2005/2252, K:2005/1199          25718/09 22/04/2009 Bayram HARMAN 01/07/1984 İstanbul   Murat DİKAN          26710/09 28/04/2009 Abdülhakim SAĞLAM 20/03/1974 İzmir   Adnan TERECE Court of Cassation E:2008/4046, K:2008/7536          27135/09 24/04/2009 Şemsettin İNCE 02/05/1989 İstanbul   İnan AKMEŞE Gaziosmanpasa Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E.2012/293          27277/09 15/05/2009 Şükran ÇANKAYA 14/09/1951 Ankara   Emriye Esra POYRAZ Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E:2008/3426, K:2008/10165          27434/09 27/04/2009 Tahir POLAT 01/10/1978 Diyarbakır     Court of Cassation E:2008/3426, K:2008/10165          27439/09 11/05/2009 Ümit ŞAHİN 22/09/1979 Edirne              27530/09 10/05/2009 YÜKSELLER GIDA TİCARET VE SANAYİ LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ Mersin   Kenan COŞAR Court of Cassation E:2008/13714, K:2008/15037        27845/09 22/04/2009 Yalçın Hüseyin SOLAT Girne   Boysan BOYRA          28852/09 13/05/2009 Veli AK 27/01/1961 İzmir   Nilgün DAĞGEÇEN          29074/09 10/05/2009 Hasan HACIOĞLU İstanbul   Fikret BABAOĞLU          29346/09 08/05/2009 Şükrü ÇÖRDÜK 10/11/1949 Ankara Emriye Esra POYRAZ Court of Cassation E:2008/5375, K:2008/10680        29406/09 13/04/2009 Kadir SEKER 04/04/1948 İzmir   Doğan EVRİM Court of Cassation E:2007/3311, K:2007/6014        29731/09 25/05/2009 Tekin ÖZOĞLU 26/07/1960 İstanbul   Roland MEISTER Supreme Administrative Court E:2008/3902, K:2008/8351          30517/09 05/06/2009 Oğuz YAVUZ 29/01/1943 Ankara   Ruhsar YAVUZ 12/11/1947 Ankara   Buğra YEGÜL   &#x