CEDH · CASELAW;JUDGMENTS;COMMITTEE;ENG — 10 février 2015

.s800EAC49 { font-size:12pt } .sFE10DC93 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center } .sBB9EE52A { font-family:Arial } .s29100277 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold } .sA36B60A1 { font-family:Arial; font-style:italic } .s9793A85B { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:14.2pt } .s598389F8 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; font-size:11pt } .s4ACA9207 { page-break-before:always; clear:both; mso-break-type:section-break } .sCB9E0544 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:left } .sB9D5CABB { width:28.35pt; display:inline-block } .sD3B63DAD { margin-top:36pt; margin-bottom:12pt; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .s79DE5897 { margin-top:18pt; margin-left:17.85pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-indent:-17.85pt; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .sF7A86111 { margin-top:6pt; margin-left:21.25pt; margin-bottom:6pt; text-indent:7.1pt; font-size:10pt } .sA8776625 { margin-top:18pt; margin-left:29.2pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-indent:-17.6pt; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .sBB355983 { margin-top:6pt; margin-left:21.25pt; margin-bottom:6pt; text-indent:7.1pt; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:10pt } .s583D00FA { margin-top:0pt; margin-left:17pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:-17pt } .s32563E28 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt } .s4B243ECC { margin-top:12pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:14.2pt; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .sF7A4323 { margin-top:36pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:left } .sF3B96856 { width:11.87pt; display:inline-block } .s6667B4BF { width:213.78pt; display:inline-block } .sA2E62387 { width:204.97pt; display:inline-block } .s5E1364CA { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .s8229ABDD { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:center } .s75A32C27 { border-collapse:collapse } .s3695F815 { border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top; background-color:#dfdfdf } .sDF237D91 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; font-size:8pt } .sEECE831 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold; color:#474747 } .sE8934522 { border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s6B505E72 { margin:0pt; padding-left:0pt } .s4F2ADFDB { text-align:center; font-family:Arial; font-size:8pt; list-style-position:inside } .sBB6163A7 { width:2.48pt; font:7pt 'Times New Roman'; display:inline-block } .s5FFF0A7E { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:8pt } .s1106A579 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:12pt; font-size:8pt } .sAC160DAD { width:15.43pt; font:7pt 'Times New Roman'; display:inline-block } .s532FE222 { width:10.98pt; font:7pt 'Times New Roman'; display:inline-block }     FOURTH SECTION               CASE OF McHUGH AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM   (Application no. 51987/08 and 1,014 others - see list appended)                 JUDGMENT     STRASBOURG   10 February 2015             This judgment is final but it may be subject to editorial revision. In the case of McHugh and Others v. the United Kingdom, The European Court of Human Rights (Fourth Section), sitting as a Committee composed of:   Päivi Hirvelä, President,   Nona Tsotsoria,   Faris Vehabović, judges, and Fatoş Aracı, Deputy Section Registrar, Having deliberated in private on 20 January 2015, Delivers the following judgment, which was adopted on that date: PROCEDURE 1.     The case originated in 1,015 applications against the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland lodged with the Court under Article   34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”). A full list of the applicants and their legal representatives, if applicable, is set out in the appendix. 2.     The United Kingdom Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Ms A. Sornarajah, of the Foreign and Commonwealth Office. 3.     On 22 September 2014 the applications were communicated to the respondent Government. 4.     Written observations were received from the Government and just satisfaction claims were received from a number of the applicants. THE FACTS I.     THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE 5 .     The applicants were all incarcerated at the relevant time following criminal convictions for a variety of offences. They were automatically prevented from voting, pursuant to primary legislation, in one or more of the following elections: elections to the European Parliament on 4   June 2009; the parliamentary election on 6 May 2010; and elections to the Scottish Parliament, the Welsh Assembly or the Northern Irish Assembly on 5 May 2011 (for further details see the appended table). II.     RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE 6. The relevant domestic law and practice is set out in Hirst v. the United Kingdom (no. 2) [GC], no. 74025/01, ECHR 2005 ‑ IX; Greens and M.T. v.   the United Kingdom , nos.   60041/08 and 60054/08, ECHR 2010 (extracts); McLean and Cole v. the United Kingdom (dec.), nos. 12626/13 and 2522/12, 11 June 2013; and Firth and Others v. the United Kingdom , nos. 47784/09, 47806/09, 47812/09, 47818/09, 47829/09, 49001/09, 49007/09, 49018/09, 49033/09 and 49036/09, 12   August 2014. THE LAW I.     JOINDER 7.     Given their similar factual and legal background, the Court decides that the applications should be joined pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court. II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 3 OF PROTOCOL No. 1 TO THE CONVENTION 8.     The applicants complained that they were prevented from voting in elections (see paragraph 5 above). They relied on Article 3 of Protocol   No.   1 to the Convention, which reads as follows: “The High Contracting Parties undertake to hold free elections at reasonable intervals by secret ballot, under conditions which will ensure the free expression of the opinion of the people in the choice of the legislature.” A.     Admissibility 9.     The Court notes that the applications are not manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) of the Convention. It further notes that they are not inadmissible on any other grounds. They must therefore be declared admissible. B.     Merits 10.     The Court has found that the statutory ban on prisoners voting in elections was, by reason of its blanket character, incompatible with Article 3 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention (see Hirst (No. 2) , cited above, § 82; and Greens and M.T. , cited above, §§   78-79). In Greens and M.T. it indicated that some legislative amendment would be required in order to render the electoral law compatible with the requirements of the Convention (see §   112 of the Court’s judgment). The Government subsequently published a draft bill which underwent parliamentary scrutiny by a joint committee of both Houses of Parliament. The committee’s report, published in December 2013, made recommendations as to suitable legislative amendments to be enacted and the appropriate timetable for enactment (see Firth and Others , cited above, § 14). 11.     Given that the impugned legislation remains unamended, the Court cannot but conclude that, as in Hirst (no. 2) , Greens and M.T. and Firth and Others , and for the same reasons, there has been a violation of Article 3 of Protocol No. 1 in the applicants’ case. III.     APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 41 OF THE CONVENTION 12.     Article 41 of the Convention provides: “If the Court finds that there has been a violation of the Convention or the Protocols thereto, and if the internal law of the High Contracting Party concerned allows only partial reparation to be made, the Court shall, if necessary, afford just satisfaction to the injured party.” 13.     Some of the applicants claimed non-pecuniary damage and costs and expenses. As regards legal costs, they argued, variously, that since their cases were lodged before the Court’s judgment in Greens and M.T. , it was unfair to refuse legal costs; that costs incurred in domestic proceedings should be awarded; that postage costs should be awarded; and that legal assistance was required to lodge the cases and consider the appropriate response to the communication of the cases, and in particular the implications of Firth and Others . 14.     The Court does not consider that applicants who lodged their applications before its judgment in Greens and M.T. should be entitled to legal costs. It has already explained in its judgment in Firth and Others (cited above, § 21) why it does not agree that legal assistance was required to lodge an application. Further, in its Greens and M.T. judgment, the Court explained that the award made in respect of costs in that case was limited to the proceedings before it and reflected the fact that extensive written submissions had been lodged in the context of the written proceedings in the case. By contrast, the present cases were processed by the Court under a simplified procedure and, following the Firth and Others judgment, the Court’s approach to such follow-up cases was clear. In particular, the Court does not accept that there was any need for legal assistance to consider the implications of the Firth and Others judgment, since that judgment was both concise and unambiguous. 15.     In so far as some applicants claimed the costs of domestic court proceedings, adequate vouching has not been provided showing that court fees or legal costs were charged or paid. The claims are accordingly unsubstantiated. 16.     Finally, while the Court accepts that some minor costs must have been incurred in purchasing envelopes and postage stamps, it does not consider it “necessary”, within the meaning of Article 41, to make any award in respect of these costs in the present applications. 17.     In conclusion, as in Firth and Others (cited above, § 18) and for the same reasons, in the present case the Court concludes that the finding of a violation constitutes sufficient just satisfaction for any non-pecuniary damage sustained by the applicants. Further, for the reasons set out in paragraphs 14-16 above and in Firth and Others (cited above, § 20-22), the Court declines to make any award in respect of costs and expenses. FOR THESE REASONS, THE COURT, UNANIMOUSLY, 1.     Decides to join the applications;   2.     Declares the applications admissible;   3.     Holds that there has been a violation of Article 3 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention;   4. Holds that the finding of a violation constitutes in itself sufficient just satisfaction for any non-pecuniary damage sustained by the applicants;   5. Dismisses the remainder of the applicants’ claim for just satisfaction. Done in English, and notified in writing on 10 February 2015, pursuant to Rule 77 §§ 2 and 3 of the Rules of Court.   Fatoş Aracı   Päivi Hirvelä Deputy Registrar   President   APPENDIX LIST OF APPLICANTS No. Application no. and date of introduction Applicant name date of birth place of residence nationality Prisoner no. where known & Name of Prison Represented by Election missed Detention details where known     51987/08 07/06/2010   James Stevens MC HUGH 16/01/1926 Hull British   A1238AC HMP Hull     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Hull     49043/09 28/08/2009   James DOW 16/06/1984 Tullibody British   HMP Glenochil     TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009   Detained at relevant time at HMP Glenochil     49065/09 28/08/2009   James BROWN 05/03/1974 Tullibody British   HMP Glenochil     TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009   Detained at relevant time at HMP Glenochil     49077/09 19/08/2009   Michael QUINN 24/09/1971 Peterhead British   HMP Peterhead     TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009   Detained at relevant time at HMP Peterhead.     49083/09 28/08/2009   Kevin GIBSON 09/01/1980 Shotts British   HMP Shotts     TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009   Detained at relevant time at HMP Shotts.     58077/09 20/10/2009   Alan MAIR 27/11/1958 Tullibody British   HMP Glenochil     TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009     Detained at relevant time at HMP Glenochil     58452/09 20/10/2009   James CUNNINGHAM 28/12/1976 Kilmarnock British   HMP Kilmarnock   TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009     Detained at the relevant time at HMP Kilmarnock     58485/09 20/10/2009   Joseph BLEAKLEY 05/06/1960 Forfar British   HMP Noranside     TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009         Detained at relevant time in HMP Noranside     58492/09 22/10/2009   John DONALDSON 27/01/1948 Tullibody British   HMP Glenochil     TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009       Detained at relevant time at HMP Peterhead   60710/09 09/11/2009   Christopher LEARY 23/07/1980 Addiewell British   HMP Addiewell     TAYLOR & KELLY EU election 4 June 2009       Detained at relevant time at HMP Addiewell   60716/09 09/11/2009   Brian DOCHERTY 30/01/1968 Edinburgh British   HMP Edinburgh     TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009     Detained at relevant time at HMP Edinburgh   62146/09 17/11/2009   William MOUNT 09/11/1944 Peterhead British   HMP Peterhead     TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009     Detained at relevant time at HMP Peterhead   67026/09 26/11/2009   Sean MC KAY 20/08/1967 Peterhead British   HMP Peterhead     TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009     Detained at relevant time at HMP Peterhead   67036/09 26/11/2009   Jon MAC INTOSH 17/11/1967 Peterhead British   HMP Peterhead     TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009     Detained at relevant time at HMP Peterhead   67045/09 26/11/2009   Kevin HENDRY 23/05/1975 Shotts British   HMP Shotts     TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009     Detained at relevant time at HMP Shotts   67052/09 26/11/2009   Daniel HAMILTON 27/07/1982 Kilmarnock British   HMP Kilmarnock     TAYLOR & KELLY EU elections 4 June 2009       Detained at relevant time at HMP Kilmarnock   154/10 10/05/2010   Howard WOODIN 25/04/1959 Devizes British   (A9946AF/KJ4609/A4224AA) HMP Erlestoke     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   22599/10 21/04/2010   Leon Martin PUNCHARD 21/03/1991 Norwich British   A5057AK HMP Norwich     LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Norwich   29309/10 14/05/2010   Lee FLAHERTY 23/11/1956 Stockton on Tees British   A8780AD HMP Holme House     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   29316/10 06/05/2010   Mark Anthony HOOK 01/09/1976 Gloucester British       General election 6 May 2010   Not known   31679/10 24/05/2010   Kenneth REGAN   Evesham British   A4838AE HMP Long Lartin     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Frankland   31888/10 25/05/2010   Paul BLACK 11/04/1959 Preston British   A0321AG HMP Wymott     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   31914/10 19/05/2010   Peter William LONGSTAFF 30/12/1974 Middlesbrough British       General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Frankland   31950/10 03/06/2010   John DOUGHTY 28/06/1973 Norwich British   A5575AM HMP Bure     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   32163/10 07/06/2010   Kevin BUNBY 13/05/1957 Durham British   HMP Frankland     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   33293/10 01/06/2010   Jamie CHESHER 09/11/1976 Eastchurch British   A9310AM HMP Swaleside     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   33416/10 14/09/2010   Richard MUSKER   Ashbourne British   A8314AF HMP Sudbury     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known   33417/10 24/08/2010   Stuart PEARSON 26/08/1978 Everthorpe British   HMP Wolds     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Sudbury   33521/10 09/06/2010   John SMITH 22/02/1984 Whatton British   A5875AA HMP Whatton     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle of Wight   33599/10 10/06/2010   George Robert GALLOWAY 24/01/1964 Stockton on Tees British   A3923AE HMP Holme House     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Frankland   33876/10 15/06/2010   Gareth WHEATLEY 29/10/1979 Hull British   VT5872 HMP Wolds     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Wolds   33888/10 14/06/2010   John Stanley CAUGHEY 11/09/1953 Tullibody British   HMP Glenochil     TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Dumfries   33906/10 14/06/2010   Lee James POTTER 15/12/1983 Woking British   A7663AL HMP Coldingley     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Coldingley   33912/10 14/06/2010   John BRADY 10/05/1948 Wakefield British   A9977AA HMP Wakefield     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Wakefield   33919/10 12/06/2010   Philip MC HUGH 14/09/1955 Bedford British       General election 6 May 2010   Released on 23/07/2010 Detained at relevant time at HMP North Sea Camp   34032/10 11/06/2010   Mohammad IBRAHIM 27/12/1978 Nottingham British   A7081AN HMP Whatton     General elections 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Shepton Mallet   34212/10 08/06/2010   Keri ROMANS 22/05/1969 Goudhurst British   A8597AN HMP Blantyre House     General elections 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Shepton Mallet   34376/10 16/06/2010   Patrick John CHAMBERS-CLARKE 30/07/1960 Durham British   A3931AE HMP Frankland     General elections 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Frankland   34385/10 15/06/2010   Simon Onemena KOGORO 05/07/1969 London British   A9794AD   General election 6 May 2010   Not known     34433/10 10/06/2010   Raymond Eric Gaylord COATES 23/06/1954 Hull British   A0920AC HMP Hull     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   34457/10 08/06/2010   Raymond Stuart MINNS 23/11/1978 Norwich British   A5375AA HMP Bure     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle of Wight   34561/10 09/06/2010   James MC KERRELL 29/01/1943 Edinburgh British       TAYLOR & KELLY General elections 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Peterhead   34576/10 09/06/2010   Stephen MC GOVANEY 30/05/1958 Peterhead British   HMP Peterhead     TAYLOR & KELLY General elections 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Peterhead   34672/10 16/06/2010   Brian KELSO 14/07/1969 Paignton British       General election 6 May 2010   Not known   34674/10 13/06/2010   Kevin Andrew DOWNING 18/06/1963 Boston British   A2797AN HMP North Sea Camp     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Dartmoor   34899/10 18/06/2010   Jermaine TAYLOR 16/01/1980 Beckenham British       General elections 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Coldingley   34933/10 21/06/2010   Gordon ALEE 20/06/1951 Lowdham British   GT9030 HMP Lowdham Grange     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Lowdham Grange     34939/10 21/06/2010   Andrew Sean FOX 29/06/1967 Nuneaton British       General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Hewell   34953/10 17/06/2010   Wayne SHAW 17/12/1980 Woking British   A2670AK HMP Coldingley     BINDMANS LLP General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Coldingley   34957/10 14/06/2010   Gary Peter PUTLAND 15/10/1978 Arundel British   A3728AD HMP Ford     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Coldingley   37002/10 23/06/2010   Michael Elias SAMUELS 05/10/1969 Hemel Hempstead British   A2411AM HMP The Mount     General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Swaleside     37099/10 25/06/2010   Brendon OXENDALE 16/11/1983 Bristol British   A8565AG HMP Ashfield     General election 6 May 2010     Not known   37113/10 23/06/2010   Winston TAYLOR 03/01/1961 Bristol British       General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Leyhill   37197/10 21/06/2010   Geoffrey Alfred ALEXANDER 27/08/1962 Bridgend British   AD6469 HMP Parc     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Parc   37522/10 28/06/2010   Mark WILSHIRE 22/01/1965 Monmouthshire British   A6132AM HMP Usk     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   37525/10 28/06/2010   Lee Anthony OSBORNE 24/12/1978 Whatton British   A6372AM HMP Whatton     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   37541/10 28/06/2010   Paul Thomas GOLDSMITH 15/07/1967 Maidstone British   A1504AA HMP Maidstone     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known   37655/10 28/06/2010   David Charles Richard FROOMS 22/04/1947 Norwich British   A5838AM HMP Bure     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   37682/10 28/06/2010   Paul WOODWARD 25/07/1960 Badersfield British   A1989AMD HMP Bure     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   37698/10 28/06/2010   Anthony John CHANDLER 21/11/1957 Boston British   A1522AA HMP North Sea Camp     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   37796/10 24/06/2010   James Marvin JONES 20/06/1971 Denbigh British       General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Wymott   37828/10 18/06/2010   Christopher James ANDREWS 22/04/1972 Willoughby British   A9082AH HMP Onley     General election 6 May 2010   10/01/2008 to unknown date; Detained at relevant time at HMP Onley   37918/10 24/06/2010   Brian Wayne RICHARDS 23/05/1972 Pontypool British       General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Parc; Released on 30/11/2011   37961/10 23/06/2010   Keith PORTCH 10/12/1962 Minster British   A6289AM   General election 6 May 2010   Not known Prisoner no. A6289AM   38089/10 28/06/2010   John LAMBE 16/08/1943 Nottingham British   A5697AM HMP Whatton     General election 6 May 2010     Not known   38093/10 28/06/2010   Paul BURES 24/03/1954 Whotton British   A5883AM HMP Whotton     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   38148/10 27/06/2010   Steve COPELAND 02/04/1961 Retford British   AJ2045AJ HMP Ranby     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known   38160/10 25/06/2010   Simon Peter CRAWFORD 10/04/1950 Scottow British   A1435AA HMP Bure     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Isle of Wight, Albany Site   38189/10 28/06/2010   Alan Michael SWINDON-ADAIR 19/07/1966 Durham British   A7674AG HMP Frankland     General election 6 May 2010     Not known   38305/10 22/06/2010   Ben REDFERN-EDWARDS 25/08/1984 York British   HMP Full Sutton     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   38313/10 22/06/2010   Wayne Michael GLANCY 21/02/1977 Newmarket British   A4724AD HMP Highpoint     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   38331/10 25/06/2010   Mark MILLEN 14/06/1980 London British   A2214AC HMP Pentonville     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Coldingley   38424/10 02/07/2010   Liam Matthew CUNLIFFE 31/10/1975 Cheshire British       General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Sudbury   38441/10 04/11/2010   Darren WOODFORD 31/05/1987 Bisley British   A5813AF HMP Coldingley     BINDMANS LLP General election 6 May 2010   13/11/2009 to 14/03/2012; Detained at relevant time at HMP Coldingley   38496/10 28/06/2010   Lou NAPOLITANO 22/04/1966 Doncaster Italian,British   A2376AJ HMP Moorland     General election 6 May 2010     Not known   38538/10 06/07/2010   Gary RICHARDSON   Brasside British Anthony SHAW Brasside     A4553AE HMP Frankland   A4691AE HMP Frankland     General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Frankland     38657/10 18/10/2010   Ian KENDRA 11/09/1969 Featherstone British   A6016AF HMP Oakwood     General election 6 May 2010     Not known   38680/10 05/07/2010   Adam Terence BELTON 01/04/1967 Newport British   A2680AA HMP Parkhurst     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known   38732/10 01/07/2010   Barrie Sean William HEWLETT 09/05/1966 Somerset British       General election 6 May 2010     Not known   38764/10 28/06/2010   Michael TULLY 28/10/1949 Bristol British   A6111AM HMP Ashfield     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   38772/10 15/06/2010   Stephen CASEY 09/01/1968 Leyland British   A7731AF HMP Wymott     General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Wymott     38774/10 05/07/2010   David CANNON 02/03/1972 Brasside British   A5548AE HMP Frankland     General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Frankland   38782/10 22/06/2010   Anthony HAYES 07/05/1964 Bridgend British   A5596CM) HMP Parc     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Parc   38822/10 06/07/2010   David NEWTON 27/09/1953 Wakefield British   A9472AA HMP Wakefield     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   38823/10 07/07/2010   Richard Robert ANGEL 16/05/1965 Bournemouth British       General election 6 May 2010   From 08/07/2009 to unknown date; detained at relevant time at HMP Dorchester   38832/10 05/07/2010   Obiagwu IKEDIONU 02/09/1970 Newport British   A3871AA HMP Isle of Wight     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   38833/10 30/06/2010   Adam George WILLMOTT 24/04/1965 March British   A5610AL HMP Whitemoor     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Whitemoor   38843/10 05/07/2010   Andrew MORRIS 01/08/1977 London British   A2457AP HMP Wormwood Scrubs     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Erlestoke   38880/10 07/07/2010   Derek Royd GATES 04/05/1975 Hull British   A9879DA HMP Hull     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   38887/10 07/07/2010   Darren GLEAVES 10/11/1974 Ashbourne British   A3320AK HMP Sudbury     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Sudbury   38916/10 05/07/2010   William Matthew Clifford WRIGHT 11/06/1969 Retford British   A2060AJ HMP Ranby     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known   38978/10 05/07/2010   Neville FOSTER 11/03/1966 Bovingdon British   A2931AL HMP The Mount     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   39048/10 12/07/2010   Michael DOYLE 30/03/1983 Hatfield Woodhouse - Doncaster British   A2481AJ HMP Lindholme     General election 6 May 2010   Not known   39072/10 07/07/2010   Casper SMITH 24/08/1983 London British       General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Coldingley   39087/10 22/06/2010   Jarod YUSUF 03/11/1974 Wolverhampton British   A0974AJ HMP Featherstone     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010; EU election 4 June 2009   From 11/03/2008 to unknown date   39090/10 22/06/2010   Christopher Raymond TRAVERSE 19/01/1942 Rugby British   A8869AP HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010; EU election 4 June 2009   From March 2010 to unknown date   39096/10 22/06/2010   Warren ELLIS 25/03/1970 Rugby British   A0796AH HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010;   From 20/11/2009 to unknown date   39106/10 22/06/2010   Simon Paul SWAIN 10/12/1975 Rugby British   A8514AH HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   From 29/10/2008 to unknown date   39109/10 22/06/2010   Andrew NELSON 07/10/1981 Rugby British   A9763AH HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   From 18/05/2009 to unknown date              39150/10 22/06/2010   Steven Barry HOLMES 27/03/1981 Rugby British   A8743AC HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   From 27/04/2009 to unknown date              39152/10 22/06/2010   Lee Andrew GIDDINGS 04/03/1979 Rugby British   A9655AH HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   From 05/08/2009 to unknown date              39153/10 22/06/2010   Lewis NOCITO 28/03/1988 Rugby British   A9796AH HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   11/09/2009 to unknown date              39156/10 22/06/2010   Ryan BURNS 14/05/1985 Rugby British   A0415AQ HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   From 07/05/2009 to unknown date              39160/10 22/06/2010   Benjamin BENN 22/08/1987 Rugby British   A7791AH HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   From 02/06/2009 to unknown date              39162/10 22/06/2010   Daniel BRICE 20/07/1987 Rugby British   A8787AH HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   From 12/08/2009 to unknown date              39165/10 22/06/2010   Michael John DOMICAN 30/10/1979 Rugby British   A8730AH HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   From 23/11/2006 to unknown date              39171/10 22/06/2010   Peter James CROFTS 09/05/1978 Rugby British   PD6695/A7730AH HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010     13/07/2005 to unknown date              39175/10 18/06/2010   Sean James REILLY 05/05/1982 Rugby British   A8147AH HMP Onley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010     16/12/2006 to unknown date              39251/10 30/06/2010   John James Dean FERN 26/03/1968 Newport British   A8147AH HMP Isle of Wight     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010     Not known              39272/10 29/10/2010   James CURTIN 12/01/1982 Maidstone British   A1491AA HMP Maidstone     LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010     04/01/2004 to unknown date              39319/10 08/07/2010   Peter O’BRIEN 03/07/1963 Worsley British       General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Wymott              39354/10 28/06/2010   Sheraz Ateeque BHATTI 21/01/1981 Burnley British   A6298AF   General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Wymott prisoner no. A6298AF              39385/10 01/07/2010   Garry MEE 17/10/1955 South Littleton British   A8519AG HMP Long Lartin     General election 6 May 2010     Not known              39738/10 12/07/2010   Mark Anthony MORRIS 20/08/1963 Leyland British   A2276AF HMP Garth     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Garth              39781/10 09/07/2010   Derek John KENNY 28/02/1965 Haverrig British   A4869AF HMP Haverigg     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Released on 29/03/2011              39792/10 15/07/2010   Michael DINSDALE 26/07/1972 Wealstun British   A2607AC HMP Wealstun     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   20/12/2007 to unknown date              40254/10 08/07/2010   Alan LORD 30/05/1961 Currington British   A8521AE HMP Risley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              40301/10 15/07/2010   Shaun MC PHERSON 08/01/1985 Wakefield British   A5543AE HMP Wakefield     General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Frankland              40305/10 15/07/2010   Anthony Joseph GLEESON 12/07/1954 Birmingham British       General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Whatton              40390/10 14/07/2010   Guy Peter TASKER 14/10/1977 South Littleton British   (A8589AF) HMP Long Lartin     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Long Lartin              40415/10 14/07/2010   Michael DIXON 10/07/1961 London British       General election 6 May 2010     Not known              40578/10 01/07/2010   Richard MATTHEWS 12/11/1987 Inverness British   HMP Portefield   TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Edinburgh                40596/10 30/06/2010   Raymond William JUDE 15/04/1967 Dunbar British       TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010       Detained at relevant time at HMP Edinburgh                40885/10 16/07/2010   Nangyal GAUHAR 14/07/1983 Bovingdon British   A5602AL HMP The Mount     General election 6 May 2010     Not known              40889/10 15/07/2010   James William SIBLEY 06/11/1965 Woolavington British       General election 6 May 2010     30/08/2008 to unknown date; Detained at relevant time at HMP Dartmoor                40935/10 13/07/2010   Roderic Barrie CHAFFIN-LAIRD 20/11/1944 Monks Gate British       General election 6 May 2010   Not known              40943/10 13/07/2010   Gary Stuart WARD 06/12/1973 Warrington British   A0710AK HMP Risley     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Gartree              41145/10 13/07/2010   Karl HOLDSTOCK 13/04/1974 Hull British       General election 6 May 2010   Not known              41247/10 14/07/2010   James BRENNAN 17/02/1982 Normanton British       General election 6 May 2010     03/11/2008 to 19/11/2010              41272/10 14/07/2010   Leslie Richard BERRY 14/08/1932 PERRY British   A2696AL HMP Littlehey     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Littlehey              41290/10 23/06/2010   Mark LEICESTER 17/01/1962 Brasside British   A5451AE HMP Frankland     General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Frankland              41295/10 23/06/2010   Andrew Nicholas MALKINSON 23/01/1966 Brasside British   A5519AE HMP Frankland     General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Frankland              41528/10 20/07/2010   William HORNEY 05/05/1952 South Littleton British   A9357AS HMP Long Lartin     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Parc                41544/10 20/07/2010   Desmond BAZIL 31/07/1958 Scottow British   A6674AP HMP Bure     General election 6 May 2010   Not known              41579/10 19/07/2010   Ian GEORGE 18/09/1969 Princetown British   A4196AN HMP Dartmoor     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              41592/10 29/10/2010   Michelle SAUNDERS 29/07/1967 Maidstone British   A5737AM HMP Maidstone     LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010   Not known              41663/10 27/06/2010   Shaun Paul WALLACE 09/06/1953 Kersly British       General election 6 May 2010     Not known              41861/10 20/07/2010   Terence John LOCKHART 16/09/1963 Oakham British   A1752AK HMP Ashwell     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010       Not known              42172/10 26/07/2010   Marcus WINGFIELD 28/01/1975 Griston British   A2362AE HMP Wayland     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Wayland              42189/10 27/07/2010   Shane RATCLIFFE 14/03/1961 Princetown British   A3576AN HMP Dartmoor     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Dartmour              42202/10 22/07/2010   Moussin BOUJJETTIF 13/06/1979 Gartree British   A1411AK HMP Gartree     LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010   From 13 December 2003 pursuant to life sentence              42225/10 22/07/2010   Stuart Alistair MORRIS 01/04/1959   Rugby British   A7972AG HMP Rye Hill     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Long Lartin              42420/10 15/07/2010   David Samuel BROWN 17/03/1970 Peterhead British   HMP Peterhead   TAYLOR & KELLY General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Peterhead              42648/10 28/07/2010   Sarah Jane BAKER 26/07/1969 Kettering British   A1801AF (formerly Alan BAKER)   General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Grendon Prisoner no. A1801AF              42650/10 23/07/2010   Tony Paul WILKINSON 26/08/1980 South Littleton British   A6034AD HMP Long Lartin     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General elections 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Long Lartin              42654/10 23/07/2010   Nadeem KHAN 06/05/1978 Coventry British   A7720AG   General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Long Lartin Prisoner no. A7720AG              42768/10 26/07/2010   Jaswant KAJLA 19/01/1980 Featherstone British   A1644AH HMP Featherstone     General election 6 May 2010   Not known              42791/10 26/07/2010   Jason Anthony COX 08/03/1976 Griston British   A8824AP HMP Wayland     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              43003/10 29/07/2010   Michael Peter JALLAND 15/10/1953 Bournemouth British       General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Usk              43012/10 12/07/2010   Anthony WOODBINE 19/08/1966 Wakefield British   A9520AA HMP Wakefield     General election 6 May 2010   Not known              43030/10 23/07/2010   Michael Edward HANN 26/11/1981 Bisley British   A5686AK HMP Coldingley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              43046/10 05/07/2010   Gary Stephen NASH 30/09/1970 Exeter British   A7190AQ HMP Exeter     General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Dartmoor                43323/10 12/07/2010   Gareth GARSIDE 07/06/1986 Huddersfield British       General election 6 May 2010     09/03/2010 to unknown date              43332/10 07/07/2010   Colin Edward MANGAN 09/07/1974 Manchester British   A3807AK HMP Manchester     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Manchester              43374/10 27/07/2010   Russell Mark HEPWORTH 16/12/1978 Hull British   A2984AP HMP Hull     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Hull                43418/10 27/07/2010   Gary HINDS 20/03/1964 Whatton British   A8253AK HMP Whatton     General election 6 May 2010     Not known              43425/10 27/07/2010   Michael John SMITH 11/01/1939 Shepton Mallet British       General election 6 May 2010     06/11/2009 to 16/09/2010              43453/10 02/08/2010   Ross RYAN 05/10/1988 Brasside British   A0137AF HMP Frankland     LEIGH DAY & CO General election 6 May 2010   From 19 February 2008 pursuant to nineteen year sentence              43455/10 29/07/2010   Norman FISHER 06/03/1969 Risley British   A9953AH HMP Risley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010     Not known              43462/10 27/07/2010   Keith Brian TAYLOR 05/10/1964 Risley British   A0092AF HMP Risley     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Risley              43469/10 27/07/2010   Nigel STORY 26/09/1969 Huntington British   A3593AL HMP Littlehey     General election 6 May 2010     Detained at relevant time at HMP Littlehey              45238/10 02/08/2010   Stuart MOIR 12/11/1966 Portland British   A7606AN HMP The Verne     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              45241/10 03/08/2010   Bernard HOPKINS 29/04/1947 South Wales British   A5494AH HMP-YOI Parc     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              45246/10 02/08/2010   Robert WILLGOSS 14/04/1989 Griston British   A6061AK HMP Wayland     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              45299/10 02/08/2010   Paul STEVENSON 29/09/1986 Thetford British   A5004AK HMP Wayland     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              45302/10 05/08/2010   James Daniel GILLIGAN 07/07/1977 Featherstone British   A9369AG HMP Oakwood     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Long Lartin              45305/10 02/08/2010   Alan WILLIAMS 22/03/1961 London British       BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              45311/10 28/07/2010   David IRWIN 21/01/1974 Durham British   A3452AP HMP Durham     ROBERTSON & ROSS General election 6 May 2010   Not known              45317/10 24/10/2010   Alan Joseph CURRY 23/09/1965 Liverpool British   A6796AF HMP Kennet     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              45321/10 04/08/2010   Robert Christopher HODGEON 08/05/1953 Leyland British   A0378AG HMP Wymott     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at relevant time at HMP Wymott              45324/10 29/07/2010   James John MC DAID 06/12/1965 Bedford British   A3411AL HMP Bedford     BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Not known              45410/10 30/07/2010   Colin David EVANS 30/08/1981 Devizes British   A3733AH HMP Erlestoke     General election 6 May 2010   Detained at the relevant time at HMP Garth              45423/10 04/07/2010   Shahram AGHAJANPOOR 21/01/1975 MANCHESTER British       BROUDIE JACKSON CANTER General election 6 May 2010   Detained at the relevant time              45428/10 02/07/2010   Daniel STEPHENSON 22/12/1987 HULL British   A8