CEDHCASELAW;DECISIONS;ADMISSIBILITYCOM;ENG25
CEDH · CASELAW;DECISIONS;ADMISSIBILITYCOM;ENG — 5 décembre 2023
- ECLI
- ECLI:CE:ECHR:2023:1205DEC000303021
- Date
- 5 décembre 2023
- Publication
- 5 décembre 2023
droits fondamentauxCEDH
Source : DILA / Judilibre · open data
Mes notes
privées · visibles par vous seulRésumé structuré
version préliminaireFaits
Non déterminable à partir du texte fourni.
Procédure
Non déterminable à partir du texte fourni.
Question juridique
Non déterminable à partir du texte fourni.
Solution
source officielleInadmissible
Résumé généré automatiquement — à vérifier avec la décision originale.
Analyse IA non disponible
Générez un résumé intelligent de cette décision
Texte intégral
.s800EAC49 { font-size:12pt } .sFE10DC93 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center } .sBB9EE52A { font-family:Arial } .s2EF17D91 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; font-size:2pt } .s5E1364CA { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .s339D85E6 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:14pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s5FFF0A77 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:1pt } .s10950C61 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:14.2pt; text-align:justify } .s32563E28 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt } .sB9D5CABB { width:28.35pt; display:inline-block } .sA36B60A1 { font-family:Arial; font-style:italic } .s29100277 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold } .s3AAE10DF { margin-top:14pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:justify; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .s3CA22BA { font-family:Arial; text-transform:uppercase } .s6B505E72 { margin:0pt; padding-left:0pt } .s5E8F5A28 { margin-top:14pt; margin-left:25.5pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:justify; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold } .s434D37A9 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:14.2pt; text-align:justify; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s46DB5BA6 { margin-top:14pt; margin-left:14.2pt; margin-bottom:3pt; text-align:justify; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s2D9C6089 { margin-top:12pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-indent:14.2pt; text-align:justify; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s69DCC830 { margin-top:36pt; margin-bottom:0pt } .s4B08A3BC { width:27.19pt; display:inline-block } .sC986E16F { font-family:Arial; color:#ffffff } .s9D419EF6 { width:141.06pt; display:inline-block } .s68D1564D { width:34.89pt; display:inline-block } .sEEEC397 { width:146.09pt; display:inline-block } .s5D826FD4 { width:25.88pt; display:inline-block } .s1B61D60 { width:156.43pt; display:inline-block } .s4ACA9207 { page-break-before:always; clear:both; mso-break-type:section-break } .sD00444C6 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:14pt } .s6DB91820 { text-align:center } .s8BB62139 { margin-right:auto; margin-left:auto; border-collapse:collapse } .s2F3EB0E4 { border:0.75pt solid #838383; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top; background-color:#dfdfdf } .s2EF62ED2 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:12pt } .sE1A7A04C { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold; color:#424242 } .sBAADFE8C { border:0.75pt solid #838383; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top }     FIRST SECTION DECISION Application no. 3030/21 M.B. against Poland and 926 other applications (see list appended)   The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 5   December 2023 as a Committee composed of:   Alena Poláčková , President ,   Gilberto Felici,   Raffaele Sabato , judges , and Liv Tigerstedt, Deputy Section Registrar, Having regard to: the applications against the Republic of Poland lodged with the Court under Article   34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) by the applicants listed in the appended table (“the applicants”), on the various dates indicated therein; the decision not to have the applicants’ names disclosed; Having deliberated, decides as follows: SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE 1.     The case concerns restrictions on abortion on the grounds of foetal abnormalities which were introduced by the Constitutional Court’s judgment of 22 October 2020. The applicants submitted that as women of child ‑ bearing age, living in Poland they were affected by these changes to the legislative framework. Background to the case 2.     Conditions of access to legal abortion in Poland are set out in the Law of 7   January 1993 on family planning, protection of the human foetus and conditions permitting the termination of pregnancy ( Ustawa o planowaniu rodziny, ochronie płodu ludzkiego i warunkach dopuszczalności przerywania ciąży – “the 1993 Act”). 3.     Initially, the 1993 Act provided that legal abortion was possible until the twelfth week of pregnancy where the pregnancy endangered the mother’s life or health; or prenatal tests or other medical findings indicated a high risk that the foetus would be severely and irreversibly damaged or suffering from an incurable life-threatening disease; or there were strong grounds for believing that the pregnancy was a result of rape or incest. 4.     On 22 June 2017 a group of 104 members of parliament lodged an application with the Constitutional Court to have sections 4a(1)2 and 4a(2) of the 1993 Act, relating to legal abortion on the ground of foetal abnormalities, declared incompatible with the Constitution (case no.   K   13/17). On 21   July   2020 the Constitutional Court discontinued the proceedings on the ground that the application had been lodged during the previous term of the Sejm . 5.     On 19 November 2019 a group of 118 members of parliament lodged a new application with the Constitutional Court to have sections 4a(1)2 and 4a(2)   (first sentence) of the 1993 Act declared incompatible with the Constitution (case no. K 1/20). 6.     On 22 October 2020 the Constitutional Court, sitting in a plenary formation (thirteen judges), held by a majority of eleven votes to two that sections 4a(1)2 and 4a(2) (the first sentence of that provision) of the 1993   Act were incompatible with the Constitution. Publication of the judgment in the Journal of Laws was postponed. 7.     On 27 January 2021 the Constitutional Court published the reasoning of its judgment of 22 October 2020. On the same date, the judgment was published in the Journal of Laws. The judgment took effect on the date of its publication. 8.     Consequently, section 4a of the 1993 Act, as it stands at present, allows legal abortion until the twelfth week of pregnancy where the pregnancy endangers the mother’s life or health or there are strong grounds for believing that the pregnancy is a result of rape or incest. 9.     The Constitutional Court’s ruling prompted large street protests and demonstrations involving thousands of participants. Applications to the Court 10.     In January 2021 the Federation for Women and Family Planning (“FEDERA”), a Polish non-governmental organisation campaigning on sexual and reproductive rights, posted online a pre ‑ filled form for applications to the Court, together with attachments. FEDERA further encouraged women of child-bearing age living in Poland to lodge applications with the Court.   Potential applicants were invited to print out the pre ‑ filled application form, add information about their personal circumstances, sign it and send it to the Court. 11.     The applicants in the present case lodged their applications using the pre-filled application forms and attached copies of documents prepared by FEDERA (namely copies of the Constitutional Court’s judgment, legal opinions prepared by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Republic of Poland, the Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights and the Polish Bar Council, and press articles). At the beginning of the application forms some of the applicants also added a few phrases describing their personal circumstances. However, most of the applicants merely signed the pre ‑ filled application forms without adding any additional arguments and information about their individual situation. None of the applicants attached any documents or medical certificates relating to their personal circumstances. 12.     The applicants complained that they were potential victims of a breach of Articles 3 and   8 of the Convention since the Constitutional Court’s judgment of 22 October 2020 had forced them to adapt their conduct and caused them anguish and distress. They further complained under Article   8 that the restriction had not been “prescribed by law” given the incorrect composition of the Constitutional Court sitting in the case (compare Xero Flor w Polsce sp. z o.o. v. Poland, no. 4907/18, §§ 4-63, 7 May 2021). THE COURT’S ASSESSMENT 13.     Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision. 14.     The Court refers to its general principles concerning situations when an individual may claim to be a “victim” within the meaning of Article   34, (see, in particular, S.A.S. v. France [GC], no. 43835/11, §§   57 and 110, ECHR   2014 (extracts), and the references cited therein, and A.M. and Others v.   Poland (dec.), no. 4188/21, §§ 72-74, 16 May 2023). 15.     The Court observes that in the   leading case of A.M. and Others v.   Poland (cited above) , which concerned changes to the legislative framework introduced by the Constitutional Court’s judgment of 22   October 2020 (see paragraph 6 above) it reiterated that it was only in highly exceptional circumstances that an applicant might claim to be a victim of a   violation of the Convention owing to the risk of a future violation (ibid, §   77, and also see Tauira and 18   Others v.   France , no.   28204/95, Commission decision of 4 December 1995, Decisions and Reports 83 ‑ B, p.   112 at pp. 130-31). The Court further found in that case that the applicants had failed to advance any convincing evidence that they were at real risk of being directly affected by the amendments in question and noted that the complete absence of detailed individual particulars or any documentary evidence relating to the applicants’ personal circumstances, made it impossible to assess their situation (ibid, §   86). In view of those considerations, the Court concluded that the applicants could not claim to be victims within the meaning of Article 34 of the Convention and declared the applications inadmissible. 16.     The applicants in the present case, like the applicants in A.M.   and Others v.   Poland (cited above), complained that as women of child ‑ bearing age they had been affected by the changes to the legislative framework introduced by the Constitutional Court’s judgment of 22   October 2020. They did not claim that they had been denied access to legal abortion but complained of the risk of a future violation of Articles 3 and 8 of the Convention since the national law had obliged them to adjust their conduct because they were confronted with a legal obligation to carry pregnancies to term, even if the foetus was damaged or sick. 17.     In that context the Court has already held that while women of child ‑ bearing age in Poland, being exposed to the risk of pregnancy with foetal abnormalities, might be affected by the impugned restrictions on access to therapeutic abortion, in order for an applicant to be able to claim to be a victim in such a situation, she had to produce reasonable and convincing evidence of the likelihood that a violation affecting her personally would occur (ibid, §   78). 18.     Nevertheless, in the present case, just as in A.M. and Others v.   Poland (cited above) the applicants used the pre-filled application forms prepared by FEDERA without attaching any documents or medical certificates substantiating their claims. They also did not adduce any evidence as to their state of health or of potentially running a higher risk of foetal malformation. Most of the applicants did not even add any arguments relating to their individual situation and simply signed the pre-filled application forms (see paragraph   11 above). 19.     Given the material submitted in the present case and the conclusion in A.M. and Others v. Poland (ibid, § 86), the Court finds that the applicants failed to produce any reasonable and convincing evidence that they were at real risk of being directly affected by the amendments introduced by the Constitutional Court’s judgment. 20.     It follows that the applicants cannot claim to be victims within the meaning of Article 34 of the Convention and that the applications must be declared inadmissible in their entirety, pursuant to Article 35 §§   1,3 and 4 of the Convention.   For these reasons, the Court, unanimously, Decides to join the applications; Declares the applications inadmissible. Done in English and notified in writing on 14 December 2023.   {signature_p_1}   {signature_p_2}   Liv Tigerstedt   Alena Poláčková   Deputy Registrar   President Appendix List of cases: No. Application no. Case name Lodged on Applicant’s Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality 1. 3030/21 M.B. v. Poland 06/01/2021 1986 Słubice Polish 2. 3040/21 J.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Warszawa Polish 3. 3046/21 N.C. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1996 Katowice Polish 4. 3210/21 A.T. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1975 Kamień Pomorski Polish 5. 3218/21 J.R. v. Poland 03/01/2021 1992 Warszawa Polish 6. 3233/21 A.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1972 Toruń Polish 7. 3281/21 M.W. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1985 Warszawa Polish 8. 3285/21 M.R. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1995 Świętochłowice Polish 9. 3288/21 K.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1981 Dywity Polish 10. 3292/21 W.W. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1995 Warszawa Polish 11. 3293/21 M.R. v. Poland 06/01/2021 1986 Katowice Polish 12. 3295/21 E.W. v. Poland 03/01/2021 1995 Łódź Polish 13. 3319/21 U.T. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1975 Kraków Polish 14. 3347/21 N. J-G. v. Poland 23/12/2020 1990 Warszawa Polish 15. 3357/21 R.R. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1977 Poznań Polish 16. 3361/21 A.W. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1987 Toruń Polish 17. 3370/21 A.J. v. Poland 06/01/2021 1996 Katowice Polish 18. 3373/21 J.R. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Kraków Polish 19. 3377/21 M.O. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1987 Szczecin Polish 20. 3387/21 M.Z. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1975 Wrocław Polish 21. 3401/21 M.W. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1981 Jabłonna Polish 22. 3414/21 J.W. v. Poland 07/01/2021 2000 Warszawa Polish 23. 3418/21 A.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1979 Warszawa Polish 24. 3518/21 D.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1985 Ruda Śląska Polish 25. 3539/21 J.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1990 Pińczów Polish 26. 3607/21 P.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1995 Wojkowice Polish 27. 3610/21 M.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1981 Warszawa Polish 28. 3616/21 M.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Łódź Polish 29. 3620/21 J.B. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1976 Warszawa Polish 30. 3621/21 B.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1971 Białystok Polish 31. 3622/21 K.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1992 Lubin Polish 32. 3623/21 K.C. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1996 Zielona Góra Polish 33. 3634/21 W.J. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1973 Pajęczno Polish 34. 3635/21 A.J. v. Poland 08/01/2021 2003 Pajęczno Polish 35. 3642/21 A.C. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1994 Warszawa Polish 36. 3644/21 J.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1990 Elbląg Polish 37. 3646/21 N.C. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1992 Katowice Polish 38. 3649/21 D.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1989 Knurów Polish 39. 3653/21 I.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1994 Grodzisk Mazowiecki Polish 40. 3655/21 M.J. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Poznań Polish 41. 3656/21 A.J. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1973 Warszawa Polish 42. 3658/21 J.B.R. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1981 Oborniki Polish 43. 3662/21 E.C. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1991 Poznań Polish 44. 3668/21 E.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1990 Łódź Polish 45. 3671/21 A.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1997 Granowo Polish 46. 3674/21 M.K.I. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1992 Puszcza Mariańska Polish 47. 3678/21 K.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1983 Warszawa Polish 48. 3688/21 K.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1987 Kraków Polish 49. 3694/21 A.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1977 Kraków Polish 50. 3702/21 M.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1983 Warszawa Polish 51. 3705/21 A.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1990 Kraków Polish 52. 3711/21 A.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1997 Rzeszów Polish 53. 3723/21 K.N. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1985 Warszawa Polish 54. 3738/21 B.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Warszawa Polish 55. 3739/21 O.Z. v. Poland 06/01/2021 1996 Adamowizna Polish 56. 3741/21 A.N. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Bydgoszcz Polish 57. 3743/21 P.C. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1989 Pruszków Polish 58. 3749/21 M.B. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1988 Szczecin Polish 59. 3751/21 A.P. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1978 Warszawa Polish 60. 3760/21 M.J. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1981 Pruszcz Gdański Polish 61. 3763/21 R.B. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1982 Kraków Polish 62. 3767/21 A.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1983 Zielonki Polish 63. 3771/21 E.K. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1980 Warszawa Polish 64. 3772/21 M.P. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1980 Zielona Góra Polish 65. 3775/21 A.H. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1995 Warszawa Polish 66. 3779/21 K.Ł. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1998 Dąbrowa Górnicza Polish 67. 3781/21 L.H. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1989 Dzierzgoń Polish 68. 3787/21 A.P. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1977 Gdynia Polish 69. 3788/21 C.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1973 Warszawa Polish 70. 3789/21 A.A. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1975 Warszawa Polish 71. 3792/21 A.P. v. Poland 07/01/2021 2002 Wisła Polish 72. 3796/21 E.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Kraków Polish 73. 3798/21 J.Z. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1977 Pruszków Polish 74. 3804/21 K.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1988 Gdańsk Polish 75. 3805/21 J.A. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1975 Chojnów Polish 76. 3810/21 K.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1981 Warszawa Polish 77. 3813/21 K.N. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Kraków Polish 78. 3816/21 K.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1999 Gdynia Polish 79. 3817/21 M.L. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1989 Bolesławiec Polish 80. 3821/21 A.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1987 Warszawa Polish 81. 3825/21 M.M. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1986 Warszawa Polish 82. 3827/21 O.L. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Alwernia Polish 83. 3828/21 J.M. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1979 Bytom Polish 84. 3831/21 M.M. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1974 Nowa Sól Polish 85. 3850/21 A.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1983 Warszawa Polish 86. 3851/21 A.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1984 Piaseczno Polish 87. 3856/21 P.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1980 Zielona Góra Polish 88. 3858/21 J.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1996 Warszawa Polish 89. 3860/21 A.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Warszawa Polish 90. 3864/21 K.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 2001 Bydgoszcz Polish 91. 3868/21 A.K. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1992 Kraków Polish 92. 3872/21 J.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1982 Wrocław Polish 93. 3885/21 M.U. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1983 Olsztyn Polish 94. 3896/21 D.L. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1971 Balice Polish 95. 3897/21 E.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1994 Warszawa Polish 96. 3898/21 J.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1976 Katowice Polish 97. 3903/21 K.L. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1978 Warszawa Polish 98. 3908/21 K.N. v. Poland 06/01/2021 2000 Błędów Polish 99. 3909/21 M.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1974 Zduńska Wola Polish 100. 3912/21 K.N. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1970 Łódź Polish 101. 3915/21 M.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1984 Szczecin Polish 102. 3916/21 S.O.P.R. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1979 Warszawa Polish 103. 3920/21 I.L. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1993 Warszawa Polish 104. 3923/21 L.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1976 Sulejówek Polish 105. 3927/21 A.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1986 Warszawa Polish 106. 3929/21 M.N. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Belsk Duży Polish 107. 3930/21 E.F. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1990 Choszczno Polish 108. 3932/21 D.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1978 Kościerzyna Polish 109. 3937/21 J.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1998 Warszawa Polish 110. 3967/21 A.H. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1983 Wrocław Polish 111. 3999/21 E.H. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1996 Przemyśl Polish 112. 4008/21 O.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1992 Poznań Polish 113. 4015/21 K.J.P. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1977 Andrychów Polish 114. 4025/21 T.A.P.C. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Będzin Polish 115. 4031/21 I.N. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1977 Rybnik Polish 116. 4047/21 A.K. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1990 Warszawa Polish 117. 4093/21 N.J.P. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1997 Chosna Polish 118. 4099/21 Z.C.L. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1991 Warszawa Polish 119. 4100/21 A.K. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1986 Warszawa Polish 120. 4107/21 K.L. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1994 Gdańsk Polish 121. 4109/21 O.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1997 Warszawa Polish 122. 4117/21 M.K. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1996 Warszawa Polish 123. 4122/21 E.P. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1990 Dobrzeń Wielki Polish 124. 4124/21 K.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1977 Zabrze Polish 125. 4163/21 M.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Warszaw Polish 126. 4172/21 B.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Małkinia Górna Polish 127. 4179/21 D.B. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1984 Warszawa Polish 128. 4185/21 H.F. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1966 Skórzewo Polish 129. 4196/21 O.Ć. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1980 Bobrowiec Polish 130. 4202/21 M.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1973 Trzebnica Polish 131. 4207/21 A.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 2000 Rzeszów Polish 132. 4209/21 A.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1965 Warszawa Polish 133. 4210/21 B.B. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1989 Września Polish 134. 4212/21 Z.B. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1997 Warszawa Polish 135. 4217/21 K.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Warszawa Polish 136. 4226/21 A.D. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1980 Poznań Polish 137. 4232/21 M.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1983 Lublin Polish 138. 4246/21 G.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1979 Rzeszow Polish 139. 4252/21 M.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1990 Gdańsk Polish 140. 4254/21 A.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1979 Sosnowiec Polish 141. 4258/21 K.K. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1992 Stary Kraszew Polish 142. 4262/21 A.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1988 Szczecin Polish 143. 4271/21 P.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1995 Warszawa Polish 144. 4278/21 K.G. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Granica Polish 145. 4283/21 A.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1967 Węgorzewo Polish 146. 4285/21 M.G. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1994 Szczecin Polish 147. 4292/21 K.C. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1992 Ruda Śląska Polish 148. 4296/21 A.D.Z. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1975 Warszawa Polish 149. 4303/21 M.G. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Kraków Polish 150. 4304/21 M.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1983 Katowice Polish 151. 4309/21 K.D. v. Poland 07/01/2021 2001 Zielona Góra Polish 152. 4311/21 M.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1979 Trzebinia Polish 153. 4314/21 A.K.G. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1992 Łódź Polish 154. 4347/21 M.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Tychy Polish 155. 4353/21 J.F. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1995 Wołomin Polish 156. 4356/21 E.M.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1983 Bytom Polish 157. 4364/21 J.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1997 Szamotuły Polish 158. 4366/21 M.H. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1979 Kraków Polish 159. 4422/21 K.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1985 Lublin Polish 160. 4436/21 A.L. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1981 Warszawa Polish 161. 4442/21 M.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1978 Poznań Polish 162. 4453/21 A.P. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1977 Puszczykowo Polish 163. 4462/21 D.H. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1992 Warszawa Polish 164. 4464/21 J.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1990 Zamość Polish 165. 4569/21 E.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1974 Warszawa Polish 166. 4573/21 W.K.N. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Pruszków Polish 167. 4578/21 M.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1997 Warszawa Polish 168. 4584/21 E.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1989 Gdańsk Polish 169. 4607/21 N.M. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1989 Kraków Polish 170. 4611/21 E.F. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Kielce Polish 171. 4612/21 P.L.H.S. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1975 Bydgoszcz Polish 172. 4630/21 M.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1985 Kraków Polish 173. 4636/21 P.H. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1998 Kielce Polish 174. 4659/21 E.M. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1987 Katowice Polish 175. 4670/21 E.I. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1986 Bydgoszcz Polish 176. 4676/21 J.U. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1995 Poznań Polish 177. 4681/21 M.U. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1998 Poznań Polish 178. 4700/21 A.M. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1985 Warszawa Polish 179. 4702/21 A.N. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1990 Kraków Polish 180. 4704/21 K.F. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1995 Lubartów Polish 181. 4709/21 A.F. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1980 Gliwice Polish 182. 4715/21 A.P. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1982 Kraków Polish 183. 4718/21 M.N.U. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1987 Łódź Polish 184. 4723/21 A.A.F.G. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1988 Grodzewo Polish 185. 4724/21 M.M. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1969 Warszawa Polish 186. 4725/21 A.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1986 Zebrzydowice Polish 187. 4726/21 B.M. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1991 Kielce Polish 188. 4728/21 P.C. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1991 Szczecin Polish 189. 4731/21 M.M. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1975 Kraków Polish 190. 4733/21 J.C. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1986 Kraków Polish 191. 4735/21 A.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1995 Warszawa Polish 192. 4736/21 A.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1988 Kraków Polish 193. 4738/21 A.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1984 Kraków Polish 194. 4739/21 A.B. v. Poland 10/01/2021 2000 Warszawa Polish 195. 4741/21 K.C. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1978 Warszawa Polish 196. 4742/21 A.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1986 Szczecin Polish 197. 4744/21 M.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1989 Warszawa Polish 198. 4746/21 M.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Warszawa Polish 199. 4747/21 M.B. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1994 Poznań Polish 200. 4749/21 J.C. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1986 Warszawa Polish 201. 4753/21 K.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 2000 Kiełczówek Polish 202. 4756/21 M.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1994 Pińczów Polish 203. 4757/21 M.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1968 Warszawa Polish 204. 4761/21 I.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1973 Warszawa Polish 205. 4820/21 J.N. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1982 Kraków Polish 206. 4824/21 A.L. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1986 Kołobrzeg Polish 207. 4827/21 J.L. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Rokietnica Polish 208. 4828/21 M.D. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1980 Józefosław Polish 209. 4831/21 A.Ł. v. Poland 09/01/2021 2002 Warszawa Polish 210. 4832/21 K.C. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1972 Kraków Polish 211. 4838/21 A.P. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1978 Świnoujście Polish 212. 4853/21 R.M.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1965 Warszawa Polish 213. 4856/21 P.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1984 Pogwizdów Polish 214. 4857/21 M.B.S. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1985 Warszawa Polish 215. 4859/21 E.N. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1971 Gdynia Polish 216. 4864/21 M.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1989 Wieliczka Polish 217. 4867/21 S.A.N. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1993 Warszawa Polish 218. 4870/21 D.C. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1986 Katowice Polish 219. 4874/21 M.K.N. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1992 Częstochowa Swedish 220. 4876/21 O.B. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1990 Toruń Polish 221. 4878/21 O.P. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1999 Warszawa Polish 222. 4880/21 M.K. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1991 Warszawa Polish 223. 4881/21 M.K.P. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1979 Warszawa Polish 224. 4882/21 A.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1990 Warszawa Polish 225. 4884/21 M.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1987 Kłomnice Polish 226. 4885/21 A.Ł. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1997 Płock Polish 227. 4889/21 K.K. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1993 Warszawa Polish 228. 4891/21 M.M.D. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1989 Mściwojów Polish 229. 4894/21 M.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1978 Domaszczyn Polish 230. 4895/21 N.G. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1989 Bydgoszcz Polish 231. 4898/21 M.D. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1981 Warszawa Polish 232. 4907/21 B.N. v. Poland 08/01/2021 2001 Lanckorona Polish 233. 4910/21 D.N. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1981 Kraków Polish 234. 4939/21 G.B. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1986 Poznań Polish 235. 4944/21 A.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1998 Łowicz Polish 236. 4945/21 O.C. v. Poland 08/01/2021 2000 Łódź Polish 237. 4948/21 I.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1986 Kraków Polish 238. 4951/21 M.C. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1982 Kraków Polish 239. 4962/21 M.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1985 Kraków Polish 240. 4963/21 M.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1987 Warszawa Polish 241. 4964/21 P.F. v. Poland 30/12/2020 1993 Warszawa Polish 242. 4966/21 K.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1975 Warszawa Polish 243. 4968/21 B.G. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1990 Gdańsk Polish 244. 4971/21 M.C. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1981 Poznań Polish 245. 4975/21 J.B. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1982 Warszawa Polish 246. 4979/21 K.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1994 Piotrków Trybunalski Polish 247. 4981/21 I.C.W. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1990 Słubice Polish 248. 4982/21 E.P. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1983 Kraków Polish 249. 4984/21 H.G. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1985 Ostrołęka Polish 250. 4986/21 A.K.G. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1981 Poznań Polish 251. 4988/21 A.A.P. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1994 Warszawa Polish 252. 4989/21 A.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1993 Szczytno Polish 253. 4991/21 K.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1996 Warszawa Polish 254. 4992/21 K.G. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1989 Kraków Polish 255. 4993/21 K.P. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1999 Działoszyce Polish 256. 4995/21 A.C. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1990 Gliwice Polish 257. 4997/21 I.L. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1974 Zawiercie Polish 258. 4998/21 M.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1979 Podkowa Leśna Polish 259. 4999/21 H.D. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1990 Łódź Polish 260. 5003/21 M.B. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1999 Gliwice Polish 261. 5007/21 M.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1992 Jelenia Góra Polish 262. 5008/21 M.R. v. Poland 08/01/2021 2001 Dąbrowa Górnicza Polish 263. 5009/21 J.E.Ł. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1975 Stalowa Wola Polish 264. 5011/21 E.P.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1985 Kołobrzeg Polish 265. 5012/21 A.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Lublin Polish 266. 5015/21 M.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1996 Poznań Polish 267. 5016/21 A.Ł. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1978 Kraków Polish 268. 5018/21 A.C. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1974 Stary Dzierzgoń Polish 269. 5023/21 E.L. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1979 Gubin Polish 270. 5027/21 B.P. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1954 Pruszków Polish 271. 5091/21 M.K. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1989 Bydgoszcz Polish 272. 5092/21 D.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1982 Gliwice Polish 273. 5094/21 K.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1985 Kołobrzeg Polish 274. 5096/21 M.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1975 Podkowa Leśna Polish 275. 5098/21 K.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1975 Marki Polish 276. 5102/21 A.K. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1996 Piekary Śląskie Polish 277. 5104/21 J.Ł. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1992 Ruda Śląska Polish 278. 5105/21 A.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1977 Gliwice Polish 279. 5106/21 A.L. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1995 Koszalin Polish 280. 5109/21 H.P. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1990 Warszawa Polish 281. 5115/21 K.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 2002 Lublin Polish 282. 5117/21 A.K.G. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1984 Łódź Polish 283. 5118/21 M.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1993 Sochaczew Polish 284. 5120/21 A.P. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1998 Katowice Polish 285. 5122/21 M.K. v. Poland 07/01/2021 2001 Iłża Polish 286. 5127/21 K.K. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1996 Sosonowiec Polish 287. 5129/21 A.N. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1989 Warszawa Polish 288. 5130/21 D.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1983 Mysłowice Polish 289. 5131/21 A.K. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1983 Poznań Polish 290. 5132/21 M.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1979 Warszawa Polish 291. 5134/21 A.P. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1997 Białystok Polish 292. 5136/21 J.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1998 Białystok Polish 293. 5137/21 Z.K. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1997 Warszawa Polish 294. 5139/21 N.L. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1986 Szczecin Polish 295. 5141/21 J.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1990 Białystok Polish 296. 5144/21 M.K. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1973 Warszawa Polish 297. 5145/21 J.H. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1978 Warszawa Polish 298. 5146/21 Z.P. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1998 Elbląg Polish 299. 5147/21 M.F. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1983 Czarny Las Polish 300. 5150/21 I.P. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1977 Wrocław Polish 301. 5151/21 M.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1979 Bielsko-Biała Polish 302. 5152/21 K.M. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1977 Międzyrzecz Polish 303. 5153/21 A.P.P.R. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1985 Przęsocin Polish 304. 5154/21 M.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1986 Kraków Polish 305. 5155/21 A.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1980 Kraków Polish 306. 5156/21 J.P. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1995 Warszawa Polish 307. 5157/21 W.G. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1997 Chynów Polish 308. 5162/21 M.M. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1982 Warszawa Polish 309. 5164/21 S.M. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1995 Międzyzdroje Polish 310. 5166/21 M.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1993 Gdańsk Polish 311. 5186/21 G.W.G. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1997 Łódź Polish 312. 5190/21 B.G.G. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1987 Katowice Polish 313. 5192/21 B.G. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1999 Toruń Polish 314. 5197/21 R.G. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1994 Ruda Śląska Polish 315. 5199/21 K.G. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1985 Zielona Góra Polish 316. 5202/21 J.D. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1998 Piła Polish 317. 5205/21 K.D. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1983 Bielsko-Biała Polish 318. 5218/21 J.K. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1983 Warszawa Polish 319. 5222/21 Z.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1991 Warszawa Polish 320. 5225/21 A.K. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1996 Krapkowice Polish 321. 5229/21 K.K. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1992 Kraków Polish 322. 5230/21 J.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1988 Lublin Polish 323. 5232/21 M.K. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1987 Cegłów Polish 324. 5234/21 U.K. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1983 Warszawa Polish 325. 5237/21 J.K. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1970 Warszawa Polish 326. 5292/21 O.B. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1992 Warszawa Polish 327. 5294/21 B.B. v. Poland 14/01/2021 2003 Sośnicowice Polish 328. 5298/21 I.B. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1981 Lublin Polish 329. 5307/21 N.Ł. v. Poland 09/01/2021 2003 Łódź Polish 330. 5313/21 J.Ł. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1970 Łódź Polish 331. 5316/21 O.Ł. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1997 Łódź Polish 332. 5319/21 A.I.D. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1998 Warszawa Polish 333. 5320/21 W.G. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1993 Warszawa Polish 334. 5323/21 I.G. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1956 Piaseczno Polish 335. 5325/21 A.M.G. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1987 Warszawa Polish 336. 5331/21 M.G. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1984 Warszawa Polish 337. 5332/21 A.C. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1982 Gliwice Polish 338. 5336/21 P.A.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1978 Świdnik Polish 339. 5338/21 A.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1986 Baranów Polish 340. 5339/21 M.B. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1990 Olsztyn Polish 341. 5340/21 E.M. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1973 Poznań Polish 342. 5342/21 W.M. v. Poland 09/01/2021 2006 Gliwice Polish 343. 5343/21 E.G. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1983 Koszalin Polish 344. 5345/21 J.B. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1976 Bielsko Biała Polish 345. 5346/21 B.M.F. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1984 Lublin Polish 346. 5347/21 N.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1987 Kraków Polish 347. 5352/21 K.B.W. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1976 Łódź Polish 348. 5357/21 K.M. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1996 Turek Polish 349. 5358/21 A.B. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1984 Pilawa Polish 350. 5360/21 A.K. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1998 Warszawa Polish 351. 5362/21 M.M. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1989 Warszawa Polish 352. 5365/21 M.K. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1982 Łódź Polish 353. 5366/21 E.G. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1988 Wrocław Polish 354. 5368/21 M.K. v. Poland 29/12/2020 2001 Warszawa Polish 355. 5369/21 N.G. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1987 Gdynia Polish 356. 5370/21 M.K. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1979 Wieliczka Polish 357. 5371/21 M.D. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1975 Kołobrzeg Polish 358. 5372/21 E.G. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1982 Alwernia Polish 359. 5373/21 M.K. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1998 Milicz Polish 360. 5374/21 K.D. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1977 Sztum Polish 361. 5376/21 M.D. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1986 Czechowice-Dziedzice Polish 362. 5378/21 D.G. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1994 Tarnów Polish 363. 5379/21 M.G. v. Poland 08/01/2021 2003 Łódź Polish 364. 5381/21 J.G. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1989 Izabelin Polish 365. 5382/21 P.G. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1992 Krzęcin Polish 366. 5384/21 A.G. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1985 Opole Polish 367. 5385/21 A.K. v. Poland 13/01/2021 2003 Bielsko Biała Polish 368. 5386/21 S.B. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1977 Krosinko Polish 369. 5387/21 B.D. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1995 Borówiec Polish 370. 5389/21 E.G. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1986 Warszawa Polish 371. 5393/21 W.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1998 Lubartόw Polish 372. 5395/21 M.Z.G. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1988 Warszawa Polish 373. 5400/21 M.A.G. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1993 Poznań Polish 374. 5401/21 A.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1989 Piaseczno Polish 375. 5402/21 M.D. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1963 Daleszyce Polish 376. 5403/21 K.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1983 Wrocław Polish 377. 5404/21 L.S.D. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1979 Zalesie Górne Polish 378. 5405/21 L.K. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1993 Warszawa Polish 379. 5406/21 M.B. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1989 Warszawa Polish 380. 5407/21 B.G. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1989 Ostrowiec Świętokrzyski Polish 381. 5409/21 H.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1982 Gdańsk Polish 382. 5412/21 J.B. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1985 Gdańsk Polish 383. 5414/21 A.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1996 Błonie Polish 384. 5415/21 A.D. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1990 Słupca Polish 385. 5418/21 M.C. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1974 Warszawa Polish 386. 5419/21 P.H. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1984 Jaworzno Polish 387. 5423/21 K.D. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1976 Kraków Polish 388. 5424/21 M.M. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1980 Warszawa Polish 389. 5425/21 K.K. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1994 Błonie Polish 390. 5426/21 M.B. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1979 Warszawa Polish 391. 5429/21 E.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1973 Łódź Polish 392. 5431/21 N.C. v. Poland 09/01/2021 2001 Skierniewice Polish 393. 5433/21 K.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1981 Warszawa Polish 394. 5435/21 J.D. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1988 Gliwice Polish 395. 5436/21 E.K. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1984 Warszawa Polish 396. 5439/21 M.K. v. Poland 04/01/2021 1993 Wrocław Polish 397. 5440/21 P.W.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1999 Tuchom Polish 398. 5446/21 G.B.M. v. Poland 09/01/2021 2002 Zabrze Polish 399. 5448/21 P.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1991 Wrocław Polish 400. 5449/21 A.M. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1994 Radzanowo Polish 401. 5450/21 L.G. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1982 Brzyska Wola Polish 402. 5452/21 M.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1979 Rawicz Polish 403. 5454/21 A.W.F. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1992 Swarzędz Polish 404. 5460/21 O.F. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1994 Jordanów Śląski Polish 405. 5461/21 K.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1985 Kołobrzeg Polish 406. 5464/21 K.M. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1984 Bielsko-Biała Polish 407. 5467/21 A.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1992 Bielany Wrocławskie Polish 408. 5470/21 M.F. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1993 Wrocław Polish 409. 5474/21 B.A.I. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1977 Warszawa Polish 410. 5476/21 G.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1971 Czechowice Polish 411. 5478/21 M.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1992 Tczew Polish 412. 5483/21 O.B. v. Poland 14/01/2021 2003 Rzeszów Polish 413. 5484/21 J.W. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1972 Bielsko-Biała Polish 414. 5486/21 O.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1980 Poznań Polish 415. 5489/21 J.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1989 Kraków Polish 416. 5491/21 M.M.R. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1988 Poznań Polish 417. 5497/21 M.R. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1977 Wrocław Polish 418. 5498/21 K.N. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1984 Gardeja Polish 419. 5500/21 M.J. v. Poland 03/01/2021 1981 Białystok Polish 420. 5501/21 L.M. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1971 Gdańsk Polish 421. 5504/21 J.T. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1982 Góra Kalwaria Polish 422. 5506/21 E.Z.H. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1997 Bielany Wrocławskie Polish 423. 5507/21 A.L. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1966 Łódź Polish 424. 5510/21 M.A.R. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1998 Gdańsk Polish 425. 5511/21 M.D.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1993 Leszno Polish 426. 5513/21 K.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1993 Warszawa Polish 427. 5515/21 M.A.W. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1973 Warszawa Polish 428. 5516/21 L.R.F. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1992 Warszawa Polish 429. 5518/21 K.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1971 Gdańsk Polish 430. 5519/21 A.Z.R. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1995 Świętajno Polish 431. 5521/21 A.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1981 Warszawa Polish 432. 5522/21 N.T. v. Poland 09/01/2021 2000 Łódź Polish 433. 5526/21 M.P. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1993 Katowice Polish 434. 5527/21 J.W. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1995 Warszawa Polish 435. 5528/21 A.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1971 Stargard Polish 436. 5529/21 K.G. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1990 Warszawa Polish 437. 5530/21 A.J.N. v. Poland 14/01/2021 2001 Częstochowa Polish 438. 5531/21 M.M. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1985 Warszawa Polish 439. 5532/21 A.J. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1979 Konary Polish 440. 5533/21 M.E.R. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1997 Świętajno Polish 441. 5534/21 J.G. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1984 Jedlice Polish 442. 5535/21 M.P. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1986 Ryjewo Polish 443. 5536/21 A.M. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1991 Wrocław Polish 444. 5537/21 K.W. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1982 Kielce Polish 445. 5539/21 L.Z. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1988 Warszawa Polish 446. 5540/21 K.N. v. Poland 11/01/2021 2000 Mińsk Mazowiecki Polish 447. 5542/21 A.T. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1980 Oleśnica Polish 448. 5543/21 J.J. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1989 Latchorzew Polish 449. 5545/21 M.R. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1994 Kraków Polish 450. 5548/21 M.N. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1987 Kraków Polish 451. 5551/21 M.L. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1977 Gdańsk Polish 452. 5552/21 A.T. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1995 Łąck Polish 453. 5553/21 J.Ł. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1979 Gdańsk Polish 454. 5554/21 M.D. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1980 Chynów Polish 455. 5557/21 J.L. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1984 Koronowo Polish 456. 5559/21 M.O. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1972 Warszawa Polish 457. 5561/21 J.O.T. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1979 Warszawa Polish 458. 5563/21 L.R. v. Poland 08/01/2021 2000 Wałbrzych Polish 459. 5566/21 D.L. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1981 Warszawa Polish 460. 5568/21 Z.L. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1995 Kraków Polish 461. 5570/21 U.S. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1985 Księginice Polish 462. 5571/21 O.A.N. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1995 Szczecin Polish 463. 5575/21 M.S. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1995 Warszawa Polish 464. 5577/21 K.S. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1994 Warszawa Polish 465. 5640/21 A.K. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1981 Kraków Polish 466. 5641/21 M.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1987 Łódź Polish 467. 5643/21 K.K. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1987 Kiełczów Polish 468. 5646/21 M.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1994 Częstochowa Polish 469. 5647/21 M.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 2001 Wrocław Polish 470. 5655/21 B.J.J. v. Poland 12/01/2020 1963 Milicz Polish 471. 5657/21 O.R. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1984 Kwidzyń Polish 472. 5661/21 M.R. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1987 Bełchatów Polish 473. 5662/21 A.Z. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1977 Chybie Polish 474. 5663/21 M.J. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1978 Olkusz Polish 475. 5665/21 M.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1995 Swarzędz Polish 476. 5666/21 J.D. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1977 Warszawa Polish 477. 5667/21 M.W. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1980 Warszawa Polish 478. 5668/21 A.G. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1978 Chorzów Polish 479. 5670/21 M.J.G.O. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1981 Kraków Polish 480. 5671/21 A.K.J. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1993 Pobiedziska Polish 481. 5672/21 M.W.R. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1978 Warszawa Polish 482. 5674/21 B.D. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1992 Warszawa Polish 483. 5677/21 M.Z. v. Poland 10/01/2021 2000 Łódź Polish 484. 5678/21 A.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1991 Warszawa Polish 485. 5679/21 M.G. v. Poland 03/01/2021 1984 Poznań Polish 486. 5680/21 M.Z. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1989 Malbork Polish 487. 5682/21 A.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1982 Kraków Polish 488. 5684/21 A.G. v. Poland 14/01/2021 2002 Sosnowiec Polish 489. 5686/21 K.Z. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1990 Warszawa Polish 490. 5688/21 Z.G. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1996 Pszczyna Polish 491. 5690/21 A.K.J. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1982 Warszawa Polish 492. 5691/21 J.G. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1989 Warszawa Polish 493. 5694/21 M.M. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1988 Nowy Sącz Polish 494. 5695/21 A.J. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1986 Warszawa Polish 495. 5698/21 K.Z. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1989 Warszawa Polish 496. 5700/21 J.S. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1981 Warszawa Polish 497. 5701/21 N.Z. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1992 Warszawa Polish 498. 5703/21 J.S. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1979 Warszawa Polish 499. 5705/21 A.Z. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1982 Warszawa Polish 500. 5706/21 A.S. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1981 Bydgoszcz Polish 501. 5708/21 M.S. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1985 Warszawa Polish 502. 5712/21 M.S. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1980 Kamień Pomorski Polish 503. 5720/21 P.J. v. Poland 03/01/2021 1989 Szczecin Polish 504. 5721/21 K.O. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1997 Gdańsk Polish 505. 5723/21 O.Z. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1990 Poznań Polish 506. 5727/21 K.D. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1987 Wrocław Polish 507. 5728/21 O.Z. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1990 Poznań Polish 508. 5731/21 J.G. v. Poland 13/01/2021 2002 Brzeziny Polish 509. 5732/21 N.J.B. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1974 Sośnicowice Polish 510. 5733/21 K.G. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1993 Gdynia Polish 511. 5734/21 M.J. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1985 Kraków Polish 512. 5740/21 P.J. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1991 Warszawa Polish 513. 5741/21 I.O. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1975 Tczew Polish 514. 5743/21 A.Z. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1981 Poznań Polish 515. 5746/21 K.Z. v. Poland 05/01/1954 1980 Poznań Polish 516. 5750/21 M.J. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1989 Elbląg Polish 517. 5752/21 J.J. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1980 Kraków Polish 518. 5756/21 Z.O. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1999 Kraków Polish 519. 5758/21 S.J. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1986 Elbląg Polish 520. 5762/21 K.Z. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1988 Łódź Polish 521. 5765/21 M.J. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1996 Żabno Polish 522. 5768/21 J.J. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1970 Brzeźnica Polish 523. 5772/21 K.A.K. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1978 Zbrosławice Polish 524. 5775/21 D.G. v. Poland 12/01/2021 2002 Warszawa Polish 525. 5776/21 S.J. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1992 Warszawa Polish 526. 5779/21 Z.D. v. Poland 10/01/2021 2003 Biadacz Polish 527. 5780/21 E.J. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1978 Łódź Polish 528. 5781/21 A.G. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1972 Wrocław Polish 529. 5783/21 M.G. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1990 Bodzechów Polish 530. 5785/21 J.G. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1992 Kraków Polish 531. 5786/21 A.A. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1977 Kielce Polish 532. 5787/21 M.D. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1992 Rybna Polish 533. 5789/21 D.G. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1994 Pszczółki Polish 534. 5794/21 J.G. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1992 Tczew Polish 535. 5801/21 A.O. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1975 Pruszków Polish 536. 5806/21 A.J. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1982 Warszawa Polish 537. 5808/21 A.B.J. v. Poland 03/01/2021 1984 Kraków Polish 538. 5810/21 K.O. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1992 Warszawa Polish 539. 5812/21 M.Z. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1980 Tczew Polish 540. 5814/21 D.A. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1977 Warszawa Polish 541. 5816/21 B.K. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1983 Warszawa-Białołęka Polish 542. 5817/21 M.J. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1993 Warszawa Polish 543. 5818/21 A.Z. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1978 Wrocław Polish 544. 5821/21 N.J. v. Poland 08/01/2021 2000 Brwinów Polish 545. 5822/21 A.D. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1991 Gdańsk Polish 546. 5824/21 K.A. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1971 Biadacz Polish 547. 5826/21 N.K. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1978 Warszawa Polish 548. 5827/21 M.Z. v. Poland 17/01/2021 1978 Warszawa Polish 549. 5829/21 A.Z. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1984 Poznań Polish 550. 5833/21 I.K. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1980 Chodzież Polish 551. 5837/21 K.G. v. Poland 13/01/2021 2000 Ślęża Polish 552. 5838/21 K.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1980 Wrocław Polish 553. 5840/21 D.G. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1982 Warszawa Polish 554. 5841/21 D.K.J. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1997 Lublin Polish 555. 5843/21 A.D. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1972 Dąbrowa Górnicza Polish 556. 5844/21 M.R. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1975 Warszawa Polish 557. 5847/21 D.D. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1988 Złotoria Polish 558. 5848/21 U.A. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1991 Wrocław Polish 559. 5849/21 A.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1978 Bolesław Polish 560. 5850/21 J.K. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1993 Kraków Polish 561. 5854/21 M.R. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1977 Krapkowice Polish 562. 5858/21 P.A.R. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1993 Malbork Polish 563. 5863/21 J.K. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1981 Święta Katarzyna Polish 564. 5864/21 M.W. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1978 Kielce Polish 565. 5865/21 A.Z. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1990 Kraków Polish 566. 5869/21 D.F. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1977 Warszawa Polish 567. 5870/21 E.T. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1973 Gorzów Wielkopolski Polish 568. 5878/21 J.M.R. v. Poland 09/01/2021 1975 Gdańsk Polish 569. 5879/21 M.H. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1989 Wrocław Polish 570. 5882/21 D.W. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1970 Bydgoszcz Polish 571. 5884/21 D.H. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1989 Kraków Polish 572. 5885/21 A.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1997 Piotrków Trybunalski Polish 573. 5887/21 M.B. v. Poland 18/01/2021 1992 Gdańsk Polish 574. 5888/21 M.W. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1977 Warszawa Polish 575. 5890/21 D.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1983 Wrocław Polish 576. 5893/21 M.K. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1984 Szubin Polish 577. 5896/21 K.B.S. v. Poland 16/01/2021 1981 Kraków Polish 578. 5897/21 E.B. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1985 Kraków Polish 579. 5898/21 M.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1975 Gdańsk Polish 580. 5901/21 E.M. v. Poland 14/01/2021 1977 Międzyzdroje Polish 581. 5903/21 K.K. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1985 Wrocław Polish 582. 5906/21 U.M. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1977 Dębowiec Polish 583. 5908/21 A.B. v. Poland 19/01/2021 1979 Warszawa Polish 584. 5911/21 K.C. v. Poland 18/01/2021 1967 Warszawa Polish 585. 5914/21 M.B. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1987 Warszawa Polish 586. 5917/21 A.K. v. Poland 10/01/2021 1987 Łódź Polish 587. 5918/21 A.B. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1990 Białystok Polish 588. 5922/21 K.B. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1981 Węgrzce Wielkie Polish 589. 5925/21 S.K. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1996 Gdańsk Polish 590. 5928/21 Z.C. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1996 Giżycko Polish 591. 5930/21 A.K. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1981 Warszawa Polish 592. 5931/21 A.B. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1996 Przeźmierowo Polish 593. 5936/21 A.K. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1991 Słupsk Polish 594. 5937/21 K.B. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1972 Rogoźnik Polish 595. 6008/21 M.T. v. Poland 18/01/2021 1994 Poznań Polish 596. 6010/21 M.W. v. Poland 22/01/2021 1984 Łódź Polish 597. 6011/21 A.R. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1991 Lublin Polish 598. 6013/21 J.Z.W. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1986 Warszawa Polish 599. 6015/21 M.T. v. Poland 18/01/2021 2003 Kraków Polish 600. 6016/21 D.M. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1988 Warszawa Polish 601. 6017/21 A.R. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1988 Wrocław Polish 602. 6019/21 M.F. v. Poland 07/01/2021 1995 Kraków Polish 603. 6020/21 A.A.R. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1987 Nakło Śląskie Polish 604. 6022/21 A.W. v. Poland 08/01/2021 1986 Kaźmierz Polish 605. 6025/21 M.W. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1991 Warszawa Polish 606. 6028/21 M.T. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1992 Pszczyna Polish 607. 6034/21 K.T. v. Poland 12/01/2021 2000 Gorzów Wielkopolski Polish 608. 6035/21 K.W. v. Poland 12/01/2021 1991 Stary Dzierzgoń Polish 609. 6038/21 A.A. v. Poland 18/01/2021 2001 Porszewice Polish 610. 6040/21 A.K. v. Poland 15/01/2021 1997 Kraków Polish 611. 6046/21 K.K. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1985 Kraków Polish 612. 6050/21 P.K. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1986 Warszawa Polish 613. 6058/21 J.K. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1981 Warszawa Polish 614. 6067/21 Z.K.G. v. Poland 13/01/2021 1989 Warszawa Polish 615. 6075/21 A.K. v. Poland 11/01/2021 1990 Bielsko Biała Polish 616. 6076/21 I.S. v. Poland 05/01/2021 1984 Lędziny Polish 617. 6081/21 D.S. v. Poland 06/01/2021 1Citations
Aucune citation répertoriée pour cette décision.
Décisions connexes
Aucune décision similaire identifiée pour le moment.
Synthèse
- Juridiction
- CEDH
- Chambre
- CASELAW;DECISIONS;ADMISSIBILITYCOM;ENG
- Formation
- 25
- Date
- 5 décembre 2023
- Matière
- droits fondamentaux
Référence
ECLI:CE:ECHR:2023:1205DEC000303021
Données disponibles
- Texte intégral