CEDH · CASELAW;COMMUNICATEDCASES;ENG — 15 mai 2020

.s800EAC49 { font-size:12pt } .s379BC09C { margin-top:36pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:right } .sBB9EE52A { font-family:Arial } .s10950C61 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:14.2pt; text-align:justify } .s5E1364CA { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .s339D85E6 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:14pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s665E407E { margin-top:66pt; margin-bottom:14pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s29100277 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold } .sA36B60A1 { font-family:Arial; font-style:italic } .s76CF415B { page-break-before:always; clear:both } .sA5FC2E32 { width:98.84%; border-collapse:collapse } .s8298E78A { height:14.1pt } .sF10CA44C { width:9.48%; border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top; background-color:#dfdfdf } .s2EF62ED2 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:12pt } .sEECE831 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold; color:#474747 } .s3ADD95CA { width:36.18%; border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top; background-color:#dfdfdf } .sCA00D3FC { width:18.38%; border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top; background-color:#dfdfdf } .sF7C73DAB { width:35.96%; border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top; background-color:#dfdfdf } .s82B9E78A { height:14.6pt } .sD4D262D2 { width:9.48%; border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s1259D3CC { width:36.18%; border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s5237B90A { width:18.38%; border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .sA2FB41C1 { width:35.96%; border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .sEB49263B { height:28.2pt } .s2B956468 { height:7.25pt } Communicated on 15 May 2020 Published on 22 June 2020   FIRST SECTION Application no. 79696/13 Giacomo PANSITTA and Others against Italy lodged on 28 November 2013 SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE The applicants, members of the Revenue Police ( Guardia di Finanza ), complain about the ban provided by law (section 1475 § 2 of the Legislative Decree no. 66/2010) to form trade unions. By judgment no. 120 of 7 June 2018, the Constitutional Court confirmed the unconstitutionality of the above mentioned provisions. QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES 1.     Does the interference with the applicants’ freedom of association, in particular their right to form trade unions, provided for by section 1475 §   2 of the Legislative Decree no. 66/2010 (Military Code), constitute a violation of Article   11 §   1 of the Convention (see Matelly v. France , no.   10609/10, 2   October 2014, Demir and Baykara v. Turkey [GC], no.   34503/97, ECHR   2008 and National Union of Belgian Police v.   Belgium , 27 October 1975, §   39, Series A no. 19 )?   In particular, did the alleged interference in the present case fall within the State’s margin of appreciation in the organisation of its armed forces, to which reference is expressly made in Article   11 §   2?   Were the applicants - before judgment no. 120 of 7 June 2018 of the Constitutional Court - prevented from carrying out any associative activities? In that context, reference is made to the Constitutional Court’s case-law, according to which, under the old legal framework, while the military were denied the freedom to form trade unions, they were allowed certain activities, by way of specific bodies (see § 7 of the above mentioned judgment, which refers to judgment no 449 of 1999, § 3).   2.     Have the applicants suffered discrimination contrary to Article 14 of the Convention, read in conjunction with Article 11?   In particular, have the applicants been subjected to a difference in treatment compared to other public servants belonging to State Police forces ( Polizia di Stato ), which are not prevented from forming trade unions? Is the different status between members of Polizia di Stato (civilians) and of Guardia di Finanza (military) merely formal?   If so, did that difference in treatment pursue a legitimate aim; and did it have a reasonable justification?   3.     Can the applicants be still considered victims of the alleged violations of Articles 11 and 14 of the Convention in the light of the Constitutional Court judgment of 2018 no. 120, declaring the constitutional illegitimacy of Article 1475, paragraph 2, of the legislative Decree no. 66 of 15 March 2010 (Military Code), which now reads “ Military personnel may form professional associations of a trade union nature under the conditions and within the limits fixed by law; they cannot join external union associations "?   4.     Did the applicants have at their disposal, both before and after the above Constitutional Court’s judgment, an effective remedy for their complaints under Articles 11 and 14 of the Convention, as required by Article   13 of the Convention?   In particular, did the applicants have an effective remedy before the Regional Administrative Court (TAR) and could the TAR have interpreted the pre-existing legislative framework by recognizing the right in question, notwithstanding the disputed provisions, taking into account the decision of the Council of State no. 5845 of 2017 which recognised the military the right to register for a political party and the right to be elected with the limit of assuming a political office?. APPENDIX   No. Applicant’s Name Birth date Place of residence 1 Giacomo PANSITTA 04/04/1971 TRANI 2 Nunzio ABATE 01/10/1964 BERNALDA 3 Gianluca ACQUAVIVA 24/05/1968 MONTEIASI 4 Antonio ADDESSE 20/03/1976 SCOPPITO (AQ) 5 Marcello ADINOLFI 07/11/1966 VERONA 6 Roberto AGASUCCI 22/05/1969 SULMONA 7 Cosimo Vito ALBANO 31/01/1958 ASTI 8 Pierluigi ALBERTINI 16/05/1967 TROFARELLO (TO) 9 Luigi ALEARDI 05/09/1972 PREGANZIOL (TV) 10 Rocco ALESSIO 08/02/1967 TORINO 11 Claudio AMATO 16/10/1965 MONTE SAN VITO (AN) 12 Giorgio ANGELINO 28/11/1981 TORINO 13 Lucio ANNARUMMA 11/06/1973 POTENZA 14 Nicola APICELLA 26/10/1964 RIVOLI (TO) 15 Pierpaolo ARNOLD 06/12/1967 LATINA 16 Luigi ARZANO 17/09/1985 CARINARO (CE) 17 Nicola BALBO 04/05/1981 MARCIANISE (CE) 18 Danilo BALDONI 09/03/1972 PISA 19 Giovanni BARRALE 24/03/1964 REGGIO EMILIA 20 Basilio BARRECA 09/10/1964 REGGIO CALABRIA 21 Luca BARTALONI 04/01/1964 GIGNOD (AO) 22 Bruno BARTOLONI 08/10/1964 ROMA 23 Alessio BASILI 20/12/1974 PRATO 24 Leandro BATTAGLIA 30/10/1970 MORGEX (AO) 25 Giulio BATTAGLINI 25/06/1968 ROMA 26 Manuel Maria BELISARDI 11/11/1979 CASTELLETTO MONFERRATO (AL) 27 Nicola BELLOPEDE 15/06/1969 SAN MARCELLINO (CE) 28 Dino BERALDO 13/12/1967 SONA (VR) 29 Sergio BERNARDINI 08/10/1971 DOLO (VE) 30 Franco BERTAGNOLLI 17/06/1963 CEVA (CN) 31 Antonio BEVACQUA 29/08/1967 SETTINGIANO (CZ) 32 Cesare BIANCHI 14/12/1961 TRIESTE 33 Christian BIANCO 19/12/1978 MONOPOLI (BA) 34 Alessandro BIZZARRI 21/03/1975 CAPISTRELLO (AQ) 35 Gaetano BLASI 10/03/1977 TARANTO 36 Marco BOCCACCI 03/11/1962 ROMA 37 Luca BOERO 27/04/1975 GENOVA 38 Mauro BORGHINO 10/04/1970 SAN SALVATORE MONFERRATO (AL) 39 Mauro BORRELLI 15/03/1979 ZOLA PREDOSA (BO) 40 Giovanni BORSCI 20/01/1960 MONTEPARANO (TA) 41 Luigi BRAMATO 04/02/1964 MIGGIANO (LE) 42 Carmelo BUCCA 26/07/1963 BARCELLONA POZZO DI GOTTO (ME) 43 Giovanni BUONAIUTO 10/04/1968 RONCO BIELLESE (BI) 44 Filippo CADDEO 11/08/1978 QUARTU SANT’ELENA (CA) 45 Salvatore CAIAZZA 09/12/1975 PIOLTELLO (MI) 46 Luca CAIONE 24/04/1966 LECCE 47 Giovanni CALABRESE 16/06/1975 CASTELLAMMARE DI STABIA (NA) 48 Rosario CALANDRINO 05/08/1985 SEGRATE (MI) 49 Massimo CALATI 04/11/1970 LEPORANO (TA) 50 Francesco CALENZO 28/12/1976 MASSAFRA (TA) 51 Stefano CALLAI 19/12/1976 VIDIGULFO (PV) 52 Raffaele CAMBERLINGO 29/08/1964 BATTIPAGLIA (SA) 53 Luca CAMILOTTO 05/08/1965 ALESSANDRIA 54 Bartolomeo CAMMARINO 12/02/1977 TRIESTE 55 Emanuele Concetto CAMPAGNA 25/02/1990 ANCONA 56 Riccardo CAMPANELLI 13/08/1972 AOSTA 57 Pasquale CANNAVACCIUOLO 26/10/1972 TARANTO 58 Roberto CANNAVALE 13/02/1964 ROMA 59 Aristide CANOVA 17/02/1974 AOSTA 60 Enrico CANTA 03/02/1978 TERRACINA (LT) 61 Raffaele CAPASSO 03/08/1970 ROMA 62 Piercarlo CAPPELLINO 16/05/1960 RIVOLI (TO) 63 Patrick CAPRI 29/11/1971 SAN CANDIDO (BZ) 64 Davide CARANNANTE 24/06/1972 SETTALA (MI) 65 Tommaso CARBONE 20/10/1973 VICOPISANO (PI) 66 Michele Antonio CARETTO 27/02/1957 SAN GIOVANNI TEATINO (CH) 67 Antonio CARFORA 13/06/1969 GROTTAGLIE (TA) 68 Massimo CARLESI 19/12/1965 ROMA 69 Claudio CARLINI 05/09/1974 PONDERANO (BI) 70 Giuseppe CAROLI 30/05/1972 MONTEIASI (TA) 71 Luigi CARROZZO MAGLI 24/06/1965 CASCINA (PI) 72 Giuseppe CASAMASSIMA 22/05/1984 TARANTO 73 Luigi Matteo CASCAVILLO 05/07/1970 VERZUOLO (CN) 74 Arcangelo CASO 26/04/1973 VICO EQUENSE (NA) 75 Stefano CASTELLI 23/10/1963 SAN PIETRO IN CASALE (BO) 76 Stefania CASTRICONE 12/05/1973 ROMA 77 Gennaro Ciro CAVALIERE 31/01/1981 GROTTAGLIE (TA) 78 Amedeo Salvatore CELENTANO 18/04/1967 ROMA 79 Giuseppe CERCHIO 13/07/1981 LATINA 80 Vincenzo CETANI 23/01/1958 POTENZA 81 Loris CHIARAMELLO 22/12/1966 CUNEO 82 Mario CHIOCCINI 20/10/1966 EBOLI (SA) 83 Vittorio CICCHIELLO 23/08/1976 GROTTAGLIE (TA) 84 Luca CICERO 28/11/1972 SAN GIOVANNI IN FIORE (CS) 85 Francesco CILIONE 16/10/1981 REGGIO CALABRIA 86 Giuseppe CIMINO 03/06/1975 CATANIA 87 Agostino CIMMINO 08/11/1970 CATANIA 88 Francesco CIOLA 07/01/1962 FALCONARA MARITTIMA (AN) 89 Domenico CIPOLLA 02/11/1975 GIZZERIA (CZ) 90 Massimo CIPOLLA 03/08/1970 TORINO 91 Vincenzo CLEMENTE 13/06/1974 REGGIO CALABRIA 92 Marcello COFINI 11/03/1963 ROMA 93 Salvatore COLANGELO 02/08/1971 BERGAMO 94 Piero COLAZZO 13/07/1965 ANCONA 95 Roberto COLETTA 19/01/1974 AOSTA 96 Alessandro COMITINI 10/05/1964 CAGLIARI 97 Raffaele Marco CONCAS 13/03/1974 SANGANO (TO) 98 Antonino CONIGLIO 15/03/1972 BARONISSI (SA) 99 Alessandro COPPOLA 24/10/1978 PAVONE CANAVESE (TO) 100 Angela COPPOLA 14/03/1984 SANT’ANTONIO ABATE (NA) 101 Massimo CORCHIA 27/07/1966 TARANTO 102 Giovanni Angelo CORDOVA 21/07/1965 FRUGAROLO (AL) 103 Davide CORSARO 15/01/1973 SEGRATE (MI) 104 Francesco COSCIA 07/08/1975 TORINO 105 Massimo COSTA 16/06/1973 SEGRATE (MI) 106 Salvatore COZZOLINO 28/04/1968 LECCE 107 Giuseppe CROCAMO 25/02/1972 BARDONECCHIA (TO) 108 Maurizio CUCCI 01/05/1970 FERMO 109 Giovanni CULICI 26/06/1969 PIANEZZA (TO) 110 Luigi CUOMO 26/08/1971 BARI 111 Patrizio CUOMO 24/02/1964 ARICCIA (RM) 112 Pierangelo CURRI 30/10/1981 LOCOROTONDO (BA) 113 Giovanni CUTRUPI 01/01/1967 APRILIA (LT) 114 Luca D’APOLLONIO 11/06/1975 VENEZIA 115 Franco D’AVANZO 26/05/1968 LEPORANO (TA) 116 Giuseppe D’ERCHIE 03/04/1959 CRISPIANO (TA) 117 Marco D’ADDIO 23/03/1975 BARI 118 Nicola D’ALBA 17/06/1976 VENTIMIGLIA 119 Ugo Raffaele DALLERICE 06/11/1957 ANDORA (SV) 120 Felice D’AURIA 18/10/1970 GALLARATE (VA) 121 Rosario DE DOMINICIS 30/06/1962 SOMMA VESUVIANA (NA) 122 Ippazio DE MATTEIS 04/12/1964 CASARANO (LE) 123 Domenico DE PINTO 08/07/1962 PALAZZOLO SULL’OGLIO (BS) 124 Corrado DE RUVO 23/10/1961 BISCEGLIE (BT) 125 Antonio DE VENEZIA 25/09/1961 ROMA 126 Domenico DEL SORBO 05/01/1962 CASTELLAMMARE DI STABIA (NA) 127 Dario DELLA PORTA 04/01/1970 LATIANO (BR) 128 Giorgio DENARO 20/02/1969 CANDELO (BI) 129 Daniele DI CHIO 17/01/1963 MACERATA 130 Enrico DI DIO 22/10/1975 MESSINA 131 Rocco DI FILIPPO 21/08/1972 SIANO (SA) 132 Cosimo DI FONZO 26/02/1970 CASTELLANETA (TA) 133 Felice Ruggero DI LELLO 03/10/1974 QUARTU SANT’ELENA (CA) 134 Vincenzo DI MATTEO 22/03/1958 RIETI 135 Pasquale DI NARDO 16/07/1970 MONZA 136 Emiliano DI SEGNA 25/08/1973 POSTALESIO (SO) 137 Angelo DITTA 26/07/1973 LECCE 138 Donatello DODARO 12/07/1972 MONTALTO UFFUGO (CS) 139 Angelo EFRATI 14/04/1974 AYMAVILLES (AO) 140 Antonino ESPOSITO 10/05/1975 GRUGLIASCO (TO) 141 Leondino ESPOSITO 03/02/1972 TRIESTE 142 Michele ESPOSITO 05/09/1969 ROMA 143 Stefano FALCONE 27/01/1969 SILANDRO (BZ) 144 Paolo FALZETTI 26/12/1964 ASTI 145 Domenico FARETRA 13/11/1964 COMO 146 Francesco FARINA 29/03/1967 APRILIA (LT) 147 Roberto FEDELE 13/10/1967 TRIVIGNANO UDINESE (UD) 148 Cristiano FEDERICI 21/08/1970 CASTEL GIORGIO (TR) 149 Carmine FERRANTE 17/06/1970 CASTEL FRENTANO 150 Natalino FERRI 05/04/1960 POLIGNANO A MARE (BA) 151 Paolo FESTA 18/03/1983 TORINO 152 Giuseppe FILIPPO 20/06/1972 SAN BENEDETTO ULLANO (CS) 153 Maurizio FILIPPONE 30/09/1969 NOVARA 154 Paolo FINETTI 25/05/1967 POGGIO RUSCO (MN) 155 Roberto FIORI 14/07/1974 CASTELSARDO (SS) 156 Stefano FOIANO 07/05/1957 GENOVA 157 Gianluca FORCELLINO 17/11/1973 ROMA 158 Joseph FORGIONE 03/02/1968 PREZZA (AQ) 159 Pasquale FRANCIOSO 28/03/1971 GALATONE (LE) 160 Donato FRATIANNI 11/05/1968 ROMA 161 Massimo FUSCO 17/06/1975 MARINO (RM) 162 Antonio FUSILLI 13/06/1960 BARI 163 Manielo GALASSO 14/02/1975 NONANTOLA (MO) 164 Giuseppe GALLINA 30/03/1969 GIANO VETUSTO (CE) 165 Armando GALLUCCI 01/05/1972 AIELLO DEL FRIULI (UD) 166 Alberico GAMBINO 03/10/1962 LORETO (AN) 167 Salvatore GENOVESE 21/09/1973 URGNANO (BG) 168 Luciano GERVASI 22/01/1962 GALLIATE (NO) 169 Antonio GIANNUZZI 15/05/1958 PALO DEL COLLE (BA) 170 Giuseppe GIORDANO 06/03/1964 ACQUI TERME (AL) 171 Basilio GIUFFRIDA 02/08/1957 MONFALCONE (GO) 172 Paolo GOZZERINI 11/11/1963 UDINE 173 Vincenzo GRASSO 05/04/1966 LECCE 174 Teresa GRAVANTE 05/01/1982 PESCHIERA BORROMEO (MI) 175 Marco GRAZIANO 21/06/1969 TORINO 176 Raffaele GRAZIANO 24/04/1975 SAN GIORGIO JONICO (TA) 177 Marco GRAZIOLI 22/10/1961 TORINO 178 Martino GRECO 16/04/1974 TRIVERO (BI) 179 Michele GUERRA 13/08/1977 MEDOLE (MN) 180 Gaetano GUERRIERO 11/12/1963 MARCIANISE (CE) 181 Alessandro GUTTUSO 11/02/1977 CAGLIARI 182 Cleto IAFRATE 22/09/1966 PALAGIANO (TA) 183 Massimo IERO 04/10/1971 S. STEFANO IN ASPROMONTE (RC) 184 Antonio IEZZI 25/01/1970 CAPRANICA (VT) 185 Gaetano INSINNA 16/06/1964 MILANO 186 Massimo LA GATTA 26/07/1974 ZELO BUON PERSICO (LO) 187 Giovanni LAI 18/04/1975 TORINO 188 Davide LANFRANCO 08/03/1975 SERMONETA (LT) 189 Gianni LASTELLA 30/10/1959 MILANO 190 Michele LAURO 15/10/1971 MESSINA 191 Simone LEDDA 15/06/1976 TORINO 192 Rosario Antonio LEONARDO 27/02/1968 TARANTO 193 Massimo Verdo LEONETTI 27/07/1972 AOSTA 194 Diego Mario LIBERTO 24/11/1968 VENARIA REALE (TO) 195 Filippo LO PRESTI 26/09/1969 LAMEZIA TERME (CZ) 196 Silvestro LO PRESTI 16/09/1963 LACES (BZ) 197 Davide LODDO 15/08/1976 TORINO 198 Massimo LOFFREDI 01/12/1967 ROCCA DI PAPA (RM) 199 Antonio LOMBARDI 17/09/1969 ROMA 200 Vincenzo LOMBARDO 24/09/1957 FIUMEFREDDO DI SICILIA (CT) 201 Luigi LOSASSO 05/06/1963 ROMA 202 Giovanni MAGLIE 12/06/1969 TARANTO 203 Giovanni MAGLIOLI 01/02/1978 SUCCIVO (CE) 204 Michele MAJORANA 17/03/1968 TERMOLI 205 Arnaldo MALVASO 10/02/1959 CATANZARO 206 Roberto MANCINI 03/08/1971 TORINO 207 Vincenzo MANDARANO 18/01/1965 VARZO (VB) 208 Marco MANGIACAPRA 14/06/1984 SIMERI CRICHI (CZ) 209 Giacomo MANNINO 22/09/1975 SOVERATO (CZ) 210 Bruno MARENCO 27/07/1967 QUARGNENTO (AL) 211 Alessandro MARGIOTTA 17/02/1963 BUDRIO (BO) 212 Andrea MARONGIU 15/07/1972 NOVARA 213 Alessandro MARRA 11/04/1979 ROMA 214 Valerio MARTINO 28/08/1967 CEVA (CN) 215 Ignazio MARTIRADONNA 10/12/1965 VARESE 216 Ilenia MARZO 20/02/1980 TORINO 217 Luca MASPERO 13/01/1967 TORINO 218 Maurizio MASSARENTI 28/03/1963 TORINO 219 Biagio MASTRANGELO 16/11/1986 PUTIGNANO (BA) 220 Gaetano MATRECANO 17/08/1960 SENIGALLIA (AN) 221 Vincenzo MATTEO 03/01/1961 ROMA 222 Marco MAURO 03/07/1975 TORINO 223 Giovanni MAZZARELLA 03/03/1964 FROSSASCO (TO) 224 Paolo MAZZEO 06/11/1973 CASIER (TV) 225 Francesco MAZZOCCHI 04/01/1971 ASSEMENI 226 Luigi Antonio MELIS 01/05/1969 NICHELINO (TO) 227 Luca MELLO 16/09/1967 CAMERANO (AN) 228 Sergio MELONI 04/12/1979 TORINO 229 Marco MENEGAZZO 09/04/1968 MILANO 230 Gian Luca MEOLA 17/04/1973 ROMA 231 Giampaolo MERLANO 13/03/1966 TASSAROLO (AL) 232 Cirino MICELI 08/07/1966 GROTTAGLIE (TA) 233 Americo MIGLIACCIO 31/03/1971 SERIATE (BG) 234 Domenico MILANESIO 18/02/1962 CUNEO 235 Giovanni MINIERI 10/02/1974 POZZUOLO MARTESANA (MI) 236 Angelo MONTRANO 01/03/1964 GIVOLETTO (TO) 237 Emanuele MORCIANO 22/09/1981 CAVALLINO (LE) 238 Mauro MORELLI 13/09/1962 SARRE (AO) 239 Alessio MORONI 07/04/1977 ROMA 240 Arturo MOZZILLO 06/08/1974 ORTA DI ATELLA (CE) 241 Giuseppe MUGNO 07/03/1964 LENTINI 242 Salvatore MUNDO 03/07/1976 TORINO 243 Pierluigi MUOIO 05/12/1981 TORINO 244 Giuseppe MURRI 16/08/1960 BRINDISI 245 Giovanni MUSELLA 05/09/1959 LATINA 246 Graziano NADILE 02/05/1968 SIDERNO (RC) 247 Luciano NAPOLITANO 25/12/1964 BANCHETTE (TO) 248 Felice NARDIELLO 09/02/1970 ACIREALE (CT) 249 Raffaele NARDONE 23/12/1961 ROMA 250 Donato NARDUCCI 05/06/1973 OLBIA (OT) 251 Germano NATRELLA 13/07/1970 L’AQUILA 252 Giuseppe NATUZZI 10/06/1971 PISTICCI (MT) 253 Daniele NEGRO 28/12/1974 COLLEGNO (TO) 254 Michele OLIVO 06/08/1974 SANTA MARIA LA CARITÀ (NA) 255 Michele Sandokan ORTODOSSO 23/03/1976 CAGLIARI 256 Lorenzo PACELLA 07/03/1968 BARI 257 Mario PAESANI 03/12/1970 SARRE (AO) 258 Luigi PAGLIARO 19/06/1973 RIVOLI (TO) 259 Luigi PALMA 18/05/1963 FORMIA (LT) 260 Pietro PALMAS 12/05/1962 COMO 261 Giuseppe PALMISANO 11/10/1963 BRINDISI 262 Luigi PALUMBO 12/09/1966 BORGIA (CZ) 263 Salvatore Giuseppe PANTALEO 11/04/1979 CARPIANO (MI) 264 Antonio PARADISO 21/02/1960 TARANTO 265 Tommaso PARADISO 18/04/1972 NOVOLI (LE) 266 Lucio PARISI 13/12/1962 MONDOVÌ (CN) 267 Pierpaolo PASCALICCHIO 23/01/1978 NARDÒ (LE) 268 Antonio PATACCOLI 03/11/1972 PESCINA (AQ) 269 Pasquale PATELLA 17/05/1978 GAETA (LT) 270 Domenico PAVONE 28/01/1966 CASELLE TORINESE (TO) 271 Andrea PERONE 04/12/1969 BONEA (BN) 272 Vincenzo PERULLI 18/09/1962 CAVALLINO (LE) 273 Mario Vito PESCE 20/04/1975 RUSSI (RA) 274 Silvio PETRELLI 10/03/1969 PRATO 275 Giovanni PETTERUTI 28/11/1970 TARANTO 276 Guglielmo PICCIUTO 29/08/1964 SPINEA (VE) 277 Pasquale PINTO 07/03/1975 LATINA 278 Mariano PIRAS 24/05/1964 ROMA 279 Fabrizio PISANO 02/12/1976 CAPOTERRA (CA) 280 Paolo PISCITELLI 19/11/1973 ORBASSANO (TO) 281 Matteo PIZZI 07/01/1983 MONTJOVET (AO) 282 Francesco POLLIFRONE 27/11/1965 CHIERI (TO) 283 Rinaldo POMPILI 12/09/1960 GROSSETO 284 Lorenzo PONTILLO 29/09/1977 MARCON (VE) 285 Vincenzo PONZO 03/12/1962 POTENZA 286 Renzo PORFIRIO 03/03/1960 GIULIANOVA (TE) 287 Piero PORTALURI 03/12/1975 CORIGLIANO CALABRO (CS) 288 Salvatore POSA 06/07/1970 MASSAFRA (TA) 289 Luca POVERO 19/07/1972 MAZZÉ (TO) 290 Carmelo PRATICÒ 10/05/1969 CREMONA 291 Nicola PUCILLO 03/10/1969 POTENZA 292 Piero PUOZZO 02/08/1972 AOSTA 293 Giuseppe QUARTA 18/05/1970 MELENDUGNO (LE) 294 Giovanni RACANATI 19/10/1970 BARI 295 Carolina RAFFAELE 15/05/1980 CATANZARO 296 Luca RAGOZZINO 09/10/1972 BRINDISI 297 Enrico RAIMONDI 22/12/1967 ALGHERO (SS) 298 Fabrizio RICCHIELLO 18/07/1969 VERRÈS (AO) 299 Vincenzo RICCIARDI 02/05/1969 AOSTA 300 Pasquale Maurizio RICCIO 08/04/1964 ROMA 301 Bruno RIPEPI 09/06/1970 MEDA (MB) 302 Antonio RIZZO 28/10/1973 NARDÒ (LE) 303 Carlo RIZZO 28/02/1970 ROMA 304 Michele ROCA 24/02/1974 TORINO (TO) 305 Christian ROLLI 30/05/1973 ROMA 306 Antonino ROMEO 01/01/1972 REGGIO CALABRIA 307 Michele ROMONDIA 24/12/1968 VICO DEL GARGANO (FG) 308 Emiliano ROSSI 16/04/1976 ROMA 309 Filippo ROVETTO 01/01/1967 PINEROLO (TO) 310 Francesco RUSSO 16/12/1975 TRIESTE 311 Gaetano RUSSO 21/04/1968 MANDURIA (TA) 312 Mario RUSSO 04/03/1961 OSIMO (AN) 313 Eugenio SABATINO 11/05/1975 ROMA 314 Orazio SACCÀ 20/11/1972 CAROSINO (TA) 315 Michele SACCO 11/06/1969 GROTTAGLIE (TA) 316 Massimiliano SALCE 03/01/1964 L’AQUILA 317 Attilio SALESE 06/04/1967 TORINO 318 Vincenzo SALZANO 13/01/1984 AFRAGOLA (NA) 319 Flavio SANNA 08/12/1976 TORINO 320 Simone SANSONI 30/10/1972 COLLEGNO (TO) 321 Frank SANTINI 31/08/1962 TAGLIACOZZO (AQ) 322 Maurizio SANTO 08/06/1973 MINERVINO DI LECCE (LE) 323 Antonio SANTORO 19/04/1973 CONDOVE (TO) 324 Francesco SANTORO 15/08/1976 TRIESTE 325 Salvatore SAVASTA 07/06/1964 MONCALIERI (TO) 326 Cosimo SCARDINO 12/11/1957 TARANTO 327 Emanuele SCARSELLETTA 12/10/1965 CASALINO (NO) 328 Letterio SCILIBERTO 30/07/1960 MESSINA 329 Claudio SCRIMIERI 22/10/1973 SARRE (AO) 330 Giovanni SEMERARO 01/03/1960 CISTERNINO (BR) 331 Gaspare SENA 18/07/1972 MONTEROTONDO (RM) 332 Pierluigi SERRA 20/09/1965 GALATINA (LE) 333 Antonio SIANO 16/12/1965 CONDOVE (TO) 334 Michele SIRAVO 30/03/1979 MONTAQUILA (IS) 335 Domenico SISTI 10/10/1974 VIGNOLO (CN) 336 Angelo SORECA 06/11/1977 AOSTA 337 Salvatore SORRENTINO 11/03/1967 TORRE DEL GRECO (NA) 338 Giuseppe SOTTILOTTA 07/12/1967 CORBETTA (MI) 339 Marcello SPADA 20/10/1975 SAINT CHRISTOPHE (AO) 340 Mario SPIGA 06/08/1973 SESTU (CA) 341 Vincenzo SPIZZIRRI 13/07/1969 CERISANO (CS) 342 Ernesto STELLA 09/04/1969 BARI 343 Vincenzo STELLAVATECASCIO 07/08/1960 PEVERAGNO (CN) 344 Antonio STERPETTI 08/11/1967 ROMA 345 Michele STIMOLA 06/04/1963 ROMA 346 Pasquale STRIANO 22/02/1965 ROMA 347 Gianluca SUNDA 13/10/1967 SELARGIUS (CA) 348 Gianluca TACCALOZZI 07/07/1974 GUIDONIA MONTECELIO (RM) 349 Raimondo TAFURI 30/07/1970 PRATO 350 Giancarlo TANCREDI 08/04/1963 TORINO 351 Michele TANTULLI 15/04/1975 MATERA 352 Pietro TAURINO 04/05/1967 CASTEL SAN PIETRO TERME (BO) 353 Eliseo TAVERNA 19/11/1966 L’AQUILA 354 Salvatore TERRANOVA 21/11/1964 CUNEO 355 Simone TERRERI 30/10/1984 PESCOPENNATARO (IS) 356 Luca TESTA 05/01/1975 GIAVENO (TO) 357 Daniele TISCI 09/07/1968 ROMA 358 Giancarlo TOCCI 17/06/1960 ROMA 359 Tommaso TODARO 13/04/1968 DECIMOMANNU (CA) 360 Roberto TOFANELLI 07/10/1974 GROSSETO 361 Fulvio TOIGO 11/01/1968 LIVORNO 362 Giuseppe TONDI 16/02/1975 REANO (TO) 363 Michelangelo TONTI 13/11/1950 BARI 364 Luca TORNELLO 04/01/1972 LEQUILE (LE) 365 Salvatore TORRISI 28/06/1977 GIARRE (CT) 366 Giuseppe TORTORELLI 02/04/1973 POZZUOLI (NA) 367 Pier Luca TOSELLI 09/05/1965 GALLO DI POGGIO RENATICO (FE) 368 Mauro TRAMIS 14/09/1977 MILANO 369 Cosimo TRANI 13/06/1980 GROTTAGLIE (TA) 370 Giuseppe TRENTINO 17/01/1983 AOSTA 371 Giuseppe TRIA 20/03/1972 MILANO 372 Salvatore TRINX 01/02/1960 TORINO 373 Cesare TROVATO 30/08/1978 AOSTA 374 Vincenzo VACCA 03/08/1960 NAPOLI 375 Luca VALENTE 02/05/1967 SAN NICOLA MANFREDI (BN) 376 Nicolino VALENTI 10/04/1964 PISTOIA 377 Domenico VALLEFUOCO 01/01/1963 ROMA 378 Vincenzo Christian VARONE 07/07/1976 AOSTA 379 Antonio VECCARI 28/10/1971 CATANZARO 380 Giovanni VENAFRO 25/06/1963 EMPOLI (FI) 381 Antonio VENTRIGLIA 13/11/1979 SEREGNO (MB) 382 Pietro VENUTOLO 29/04/1971 SALERNO 383 Alessandro VERALLI 19/10/1977 LA LOGGIA (TO) 384 Alessandro VERARDO 22/07/1975 REGGIO EMILIA 385 Fabrizio VERCELLI 02/11/1966 BIENTINA (PI) 386 Giovanni VERNA 04/12/1971 RIVOLI (TO) 387 Carmelo VERSACE 28/05/1969 METAPONTO DI BERNALDA (MT) 388 Giuseppe VIGLIOTTI 28/03/1981 GROTTAGLIE (TA) 389 Pietro Paolo VOLLONO 18/08/1963 CASTELLAMMARE DI STABIA (NA) 390 Emilio VOLPE 23/07/1956 ROMA 391 Enrico ZACCARIA 11/02/1973 PULSANO (TA) 392 Mario ZARRILLO 30/03/1953 BALVANO (PZ) 393 Francesco ZAVATTOLO 01/11/1971 POMEZIA (RM) 394 Domenico ZINGARO 25/03/1963 LORETO 395 Giovanni Antonio ZITO 30/10/1973 NOVA SIRI (MT) 396 Fabio Pasquale ZUCCO 11/08/1974 SARRE (AO) 397 Maurizio ZUMMO 04/01/1961 ROMA