CEDH · CASELAW;COMMUNICATEDCASES;ENG — 25 juin 2024

.s800EAC49 { font-size:12pt } .s379BC09C { margin-top:36pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:right } .sBB9EE52A { font-family:Arial } .s10950C61 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:14.2pt; text-align:justify } .s5E1364CA { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .s339D85E6 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:14pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s665E407E { margin-top:66pt; margin-bottom:14pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s29100277 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold } .s6B505E72 { margin:0pt; padding-left:0pt } .s5E8F5A28 { margin-top:14pt; margin-left:25.5pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:justify; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold } .sA36B60A1 { font-family:Arial; font-style:italic } .s3CA22BA { font-family:Arial; text-transform:uppercase } .s3AAE10DF { margin-top:14pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:justify; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .s5FFF0A75 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:7pt } .sA1D3DA2E { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:justify } .s32563E28 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt } .s75A32C27 { border-collapse:collapse } .s3695F815 { border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top; background-color:#dfdfdf } .s2EB42ED2 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:10pt } .sEECE831 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold; color:#474747 } .sE8934522 { border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top } Published on 8 July 2024   SECOND SECTION Application no. 27776/19 Serdal ATEŞ against Türkiye and 199 other applications (see list appended) communicated on 25 June 2024 STATEMENT OF FACTS 1.     A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix. The circumstances of the case 2.     The applications mainly concern the applicants’ conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the “Fetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structure” ( Fetullahçı Terör Örgütü / Paralel Devlet Yapılanması , hereinafter referred to as “the FETÖ/PDY”), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in Türkiye on 15 July 2016. 3.     According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia , on their alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”, which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÖ/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÖ/PDY’s hierarchical structure. 4.     The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of Yüksel   Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 10-22 and   108-40, 26   September 2023).   Relevant domestic law and practice 5.     A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above, §§ 141-93) . COMPLAINTS 6.     The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article   6 § 1. QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see Yüksel Yalçınkaya v.   Türkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against Türkiye.     APPENDIX List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article   6   §   1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial) (conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY based, inter alia , on the applicants’ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock” ) :     No. Application no. Case name Lodged on Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality Represented by 1. 27776/19 Ateş v. Türkiye 02/05/2019 Serdal ATEŞ 1979 Çorum Turkish   2. 30183/19 Beyhan v. Türkiye 22/05/2019 Mustafa BEYHAN 1964 Manisa Turkish Emel BEYHAN 3. 40489/19 Kırcılı v. Türkiye 29/07/2019 Ali KIRCILI 1976 Aydın Turkish Selim Savaş SEYİTLİGİL 4. 59969/19 Sakarya v. Türkiye 05/11/2019 Samet SAKARYA 1990 Manisa Turkish   5. 811/20 Tezcan v. Türkiye 13/12/2019 Kemal TEZCAN 1977 Mersin Turkish   6. 1672/20 Çelik v. Türkiye 10/12/2019 Bekir ÇELİK 1976 Kayseri Turkish Özcan AKINCI 7. 2203/20 Demirbaş v. Türkiye 26/12/2019 Musa DEMİRBAŞ 1976 Niğde Turkish Özcan AKINCI 8. 5486/20 Topal v. Türkiye 16/01/2020 Cebrail TOPAL 1983 Malatya Turkish Esra TOPAL 9. 8420/20 Çiçek v. Türkiye 28/01/2020 Emre ÇİÇEK 1987 Isparta Turkish Recep BAKIRCI 10. 9952/20 Akarslan v. Türkiye 05/02/2020 Mustafa AKARSLAN 1976 Afyon Turkish   11. 10035/20 Kömür v. Türkiye 04/02/2020 Orkun KÖMÜR 1974 Osmaniye Turkish Merve MALGIR 12. 10753/20 Ulukütük v. Türkiye 11/02/2020 Yusuf ULUKÜTÜK 1984 Gaziantep Turkish   13. 11829/20 Bulut v. Türkiye 13/02/2020 Akif BULUT 1990 Sivas Turkish   14. 12367/20 Taş v. Türkiye 28/02/2020 Abdullah TAŞ 1980 Kayseri Turkish   15. 12564/20 Yayla v. Türkiye 19/02/2020 Resul YAYLA 1987 Rize Turkish   16. 13062/20 Olğun v. Türkiye 22/02/2020 Soner OLĞUN 1992 Adana Turkish Fikret OLĞUN 17. 13329/20 Danışman v. Türkiye 13/02/2020 Kazım DANIŞMAN 1973 Antalya Turkish   18. 14994/20 Vuruşkan v. Türkiye 16/03/2020 Yunus VURUŞKAN 1989 Çorum Turkish   19. 15135/20 Kurt v. Türkiye 10/03/2020 İbrahim Gökhan KURT 1987 Malatya Turkish   20. 15157/20 Çevik v. Türkiye 04/03/2020 Zeynal ÇEVİK 1986 Adıyaman Turkish   21. 15695/20 Dural v. Türkiye 17/03/2020 Naim DURAL 1974 Kayseri Turkish Leman TALASLIOĞLU 22. 16073/20 Körpe v. Türkiye 16/03/2020 Erol KÖRPE 1977 Çorum Turkish Neda BUYRUKÇU 23. 16111/20 Erden v. Türkiye 20/03/2020 Gülşen ERDEN 1984 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 24. 16208/20 Erdoğmuş v. Türkiye 18/03/2020 Rüştü ERDOĞMUŞ 1967 Kütahya Turkish Hasan KILIÇ 25. 16574/20 Kaya v. Türkiye 19/03/2020 Mustafa KAYA 1981 Kütahya Turkish   26. 16750/20 Konur v. Türkiye 20/03/2020 Zeynel KONUR 1966 Kütahya Turkish   27. 16767/20 Özcan v. Türkiye 14/04/2020 Halil ÖZCAN 1978 Kütahya Turkish Hasan KILIÇ 28. 16835/20 Gürlek v. Türkiye 25/03/2020 Zehra GÜRLEK 1989 Kahramanmaraş Turkish Abdurrahim SIĞIRTMAÇ 29. 17555/20 Kafa v. Türkiye 04/03/2020 Yusuf KAFA 1985 Afyonkarahisar Turkish   30. 18009/20 Oktay v. Türkiye 14/04/2020 Ali OKTAY 1985 Balıkesir Turkish Müzeyyen OKTAY 31. 19379/20 Dalkılınç v. Türkiye 30/04/2020 İbrahim DALKILINÇ 1971 Samsun Turkish Şeyma MISIRLIOĞLU 32. 19512/20 Kani v. Türkiye 05/05/2020 Özcan KANİ 1974 Kütahya Turkish Hasan KILIÇ 33. 20242/20 Yalçın v. Türkiye 14/05/2020 Tunay YALÇIN 1975 İzmir Turkish Özlem SUZAN 34. 20255/20 Taş v. Türkiye 15/05/2020 Murat TAŞ 1982 Kayseri Turkish   35. 20691/20 Aktaş v. Türkiye 30/04/2020 Engin AKTAŞ 1983 Denizli Turkish   36. 20739/20 İlhan v. Türkiye 20/05/2020 Necati Vefa İLHAN 1972 Manisa Turkish Kamile ÖZBULUT 37. 21516/20 Özbek v. Türkiye 27/05/2020 Bayram ÖZBEK 1983 Uşak Turkish Mehmet BAŞYİĞİT 38. 21808/20 Salı v. Türkiye 21/05/2020 Salih SALI 1980 Manisa Turkish Mustafa SOYLU 39. 22028/20 Ekici v. Türkiye 14/04/2020 İkram EKİCİ Antalya Turkish   40. 22036/20 İslam v. Türkiye 21/04/2020 Ahmet İSLAM 1984 Aksaray Turkish   41. 22051/20 İnanç v. Türkiye 29/04/2020 Murat İNANÇ 1987 Malatya Turkish   42. 22223/20 Kökten v. Türkiye 29/04/2020 Mustafa KÖKTEN 1981 Adana Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 43. 22233/20 Köroğlu v. Türkiye 07/05/2020 Mehmet KÖROĞLU 1970 Manisa Turkish   44. 22332/20 Köşker v. Türkiye 04/06/2020 Durdu KÖŞKER 1990 Kahramanmaraş Turkish Gül Ebrar KÖŞKER 45. 23126/20 Başık v. Türkiye 21/05/2020 Adem BAŞIK 1977 ORDU Turkish   46. 23558/20 Taş v. Türkiye 14/05/2020 Ekrem TAŞ 1981 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 47. 23929/20 Ece v. Türkiye 02/06/2020 Şerif ECE 1975 Denizli Turkish Zeynep AYDOĞAN 48. 23949/20 Danışman v. Türkiye 15/05/2020 Fadime DANIŞMAN 1984 İzmir Turkish Mahir ORAK 49. 24042/20 Satan v. Türkiye 02/06/2020 Hasan SATAN 1992 Şanlıurfa Turkish   50. 24224/20 Can v. Türkiye 21/05/2020 Ahmet CAN 1985 Kilis Turkish   51. 24286/20 İrsin v. Türkiye 13/05/2020 Mehmet İRSİN 1982 MALATYA Turkish Eyüp KUTLUBAY 52. 24772/20 Akgül v. Türkiye 29/05/2020 Burak AKGÜL 1984 Sivas Turkish   53. 24823/20 Eserer v. Türkiye 29/05/2020 Sadık ESERER 1971 Erzurum Turkish   54. 25550/20 Tuğ v. Türkiye 22/06/2020 Enes TUĞ 1988 Kahta Turkish   55. 26014/20 Gür v. Türkiye 25/06/2020 Coşkun GÜR 1975 Osmaniye Turkish Hanifi BAYRI 56. 27270/20 Aydavalı v. Türkiye 18/06/2020 Hidayet AYDAVALI 1976 Trabzon Turkish   57. 27415/20 Burkan v. Türkiye 13/04/2020 Bayram BURKAN 1986 Osmaniye Turkish Zehra KILIÇ 58. 27579/20 Altunay v. Türkiye 15/06/2020 Hacı Bayram ALTUNAY 1966 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 59. 27905/20 Ayhan v. Türkiye 09/06/2020 İlhan AYHAN 1974 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 60. 27975/20 Akçay v. Türkiye 29/06/2020 Talat AKÇAY 1974 Manisa Turkish   61. 28100/20 Poyraz v. Türkiye 22/06/2020 Bedri POYRAZ 1971 Ankara Turkish   62. 28148/20 Akbaba v. Türkiye 09/06/2020 İzzet AKBABA 1973 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 63. 28258/20 Aksungur v. Türkiye 03/07/2020 Ferhat AKSUNGUR 1984 Manisa Turkish Ahmet Oğuz ÖZMEN 64. 28411/20 Polat v. Türkiye 24/06/2020 Muhammet Nuri POLAT 1989 Gaziantep Turkish   65. 28756/20 Dönmez v. Türkiye 09/06/2020 Cafer DÖNMEZ 1971 Kırıkkale Turkish   66. 28841/20 Sarı v. Türkiye 02/07/2020 Sami SARI 1981 Samsun Turkish   67. 28935/20 Duymuş v. Türkiye 07/07/2020 Yener DUYMUŞ 1975 Kütahya Turkish   68. 29198/20 Gişi v. Türkiye 02/07/2020 Yakup GİŞİ 1988 Kahramanmaraş Turkish   69. 29236/20 Üstebay v. Türkiye 01/07/2020 Yavuz ÜSTEBAY 1989 İzmir Turkish Metin ÜSTEBAY 70. 29353/20 Güler v. Türkiye 11/06/2020 Halil GÜLER 1971 Uşak Turkish   71. 29357/20 Tombak v. Türkiye 01/06/2020 Nurdoğan TOMBAK 1983 Muğla Turkish   72. 29628/20 Yeşildağ v. Türkiye 01/07/2020 Şuayip YEŞİLDAĞ Ordu Turkish Oğuzhan YILMAZ 73. 29651/20 Çöller v. Türkiye 01/07/2020 Asım ÇÖLLER 1979 Ordu Turkish Oğuzhan YILMAZ 74. 29811/20 Yavuz v. Türkiye 25/06/2020 Harun YAVUZ 1974 Samsun Turkish   75. 29852/20 Mavzer v. Türkiye 25/06/2020 Ahmet MAVZER 1990 Kilis Turkish   76. 30393/20 Can v. Türkiye 24/06/2020 Kamil CAN 1981 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 77. 32518/20 Yüzgeç v. Türkiye 27/07/2020 Kubilay YÜZGEÇ 1989 Elazığ Turkish Mustafa KÜÇÜK 78. 34539/20 Ertem v. Türkiye 20/07/2020 Erhan ERTEM 1967 İzmir Turkish Ayşe AYGÜN 79. 34763/20 Kaptı v. Türkiye 20/07/2020 Aydeniz KAPTI 1976 Uşak Turkish Ayşe AYGÜN 80. 35290/20 Ulusoy v. Türkiye 09/06/2020 Şakir ULUSOY 1971 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 81. 36084/20 Bilben v. Türkiye 29/07/2020 Ramazan BİLBEN 1985 Manisa Turkish Hatice Çağla BİLBEN 82. 36608/20 Burdurlu v. Türkiye 28/07/2020 Sami BURDURLU 1967 Manisa Turkish Zeynep BURDURLU 83. 36896/20 Asutay v. Türkiye 14/08/2020 Emine ASUTAY 1981 Mersin Turkish Aslı TEKŞAHİN 84. 38904/20 Aşula v. Türkiye 01/09/2020 Ulviye AŞULA 1984 İstanbul Turkish Abdurrahman BAYRAMOĞLU 85. 39314/20 Damarseçkin v. Türkiye 03/09/2020 Hakan DAMARSEÇKİN 1978 Patnos Turkish Sümeyye KETHÜDA 86. 40262/20 Demirel v. Türkiye 26/08/2020 Enes DEMİREL 1991 Eskişehir Turkish Elif Nurbanu OR 87. 40323/20 Özcan v. Türkiye 24/08/2020 Safa ÖZCAN 1982 Osmaniye Turkish Özcan AKINCI 88. 40530/20 Yılmaz v. Türkiye 26/08/2020 Rıza YILMAZ 1981 İstanbul Turkish Hacer YILMAZ 89. 40640/20 Baylan v. Türkiye 26/08/2020 Ümit BAYLAN 1982 Balıkesir Turkish Nuriye Beyza BİLGEN GÜÇ 90. 41839/20 Baz v. Türkiye 15/09/2020 Mustafa BAZ 1974 Isparta Turkish Fatma BAZ 91. 41898/20 Özaslan v. Türkiye 28/08/2020 Abdullah ÖZASLAN 1984 Şanlıurfa Turkish Fazilet TAŞTAN ARSERİM 92. 42460/20 Tunadurur v. Türkiye 17/09/2020 Ali Haydar TUNADURUR 1978 Balıkesir Turkish Abdurrahman ÇAKIR 93. 42471/20 Karakulak v. Türkiye 23/09/2020 Nurhayattin KARAKULAK 1974 Kahramanmaraş Turkish Ahmet AKSOY 94. 42827/20 Türk v. Türkiye 15/09/2020 Taşkın TÜRK 1980 Elazığ Turkish Onur KÖSELİ 95. 43368/20 Kaya v. Türkiye 17/09/2020 Mustafa KAYA 1977 Kırıkkale Turkish Tuğba AYGUR 96. 43599/20 Arsan v. Türkiye 24/09/2020 Hakan ARSAN 1975 Afyonkarahisar Turkish Fatih AVŞAR 97. 44259/20 Altuntaşlı v. Türkiye 02/09/2020 Onur ALTUNTAŞLI 1983 Gaziantep Turkish Merve MALGIR 98. 44388/20 Özdem v. Türkiye 05/10/2020 Seyyid Kutup ÖZDEM 1966 Aydın Turkish Gülümser ÖZDEM 99. 44430/20 Taş v. Türkiye 25/09/2020 Abdullah TAŞ 1989 Kayseri Turkish İrem TATLIDEDE 100. 44636/20 Saatçılar v. Türkiye 10/09/2020 Hüseyin SAATÇILAR 1991 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 101. 44981/20 Akmeşe v. Türkiye 30/09/2020 Yunus AKMEŞE 1987 Niğde Turkish İmran AKMEŞE 102. 45159/20 Sağlam v. Türkiye 29/09/2020 Osman SAĞLAM 1973 Trabzon Turkish Ayşe SAĞLAM 103. 45680/20 Ekici v. Türkiye 06/10/2020 Ahmet EKİCİ 1982 Konya Turkish Mehmet Nur TERZİ 104. 45788/20 Ay v. Türkiye 30/09/2020 Ramazan AY 1990 Elazığ Turkish Reşat YARATAN 105. 46288/20 Yıldırım v. Türkiye 16/10/2020 Turgay YILDIRIM 1977 Van Turkish Ülkü YILDIRIM 106. 46577/20 Çelik v. Türkiye 07/10/2020 Murat ÇELİK 1986 İzmir Turkish Özlem SUZAN 107. 46700/20 Ünal v. Türkiye 12/10/2020 Mustafa ÜNAL 1976 Ankara Turkish Zeynep Sacide SERTER 108. 47205/20 Kaya v. Türkiye 15/10/2020 Hasan KAYA 1980 Manisa Turkish Tuğçe Fatma YILDIZ 109. 50062/20 Leblebici v. Türkiye 30/10/2020 Fatih Mehmet LEBLEBİCİ 1966 Elazığ Turkish İlhan ÖNGÖR 110. 50171/20 Erdinç v. Türkiye 30/10/2020 Veysel ERDİNÇ 1980 Elazığ Turkish Ferhat YİĞİT 111. 50623/20 Akdoğan v. Türkiye 30/10/2020 Lokman AKDOĞAN 1982 Bingöl Turkish Mucahit NUSRETOĞLU 112. 50678/20 Koyuncu v. Türkiye 06/11/2020 Bayram KOYUNCU 1986 İstanbul Turkish Mesut Enes AKBULUT 113. 51378/20 Aydoğdu v. Türkiye 09/11/2020 Muhammet AYDOĞDU 1977 İzmir Turkish Seçkin KESKİN 114. 51724/20 Ulaş v. Türkiye 19/11/2020 İsmail ULAŞ 1967 Ankara Turkish Ömer Furkan ULAŞ 115. 51728/20 Şahan v. Türkiye 17/11/2020 Fatma ŞAHAN 1991 Kayseri Turkish Sueda YILMAZ 116. 52047/20 Canbulat v. Türkiye 09/11/2020 İbrahim CANBULAT 1977 Kütahya Turkish Mehmet BAŞYİĞİT 117. 52913/20 Er v. Türkiye 17/11/2020 Adem ER 1983 Kocaeli Turkish Doğan BEKİROĞLU 118. 53050/20 Başkurt v. Türkiye 24/11/2020 Hasan BAŞKURT İzmir Turkish Muhammet ÜSTÜN 119. 53136/20 Arıcı v. Türkiye 23/11/2020 İbrahim ARICI 1988 Gaziantep Turkish İdris TAŞKIN 120. 53958/20 Sert v. Türkiye 01/12/2020 Osman SERT 1969 Adana Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 121. 54596/20 Gürkan v. Türkiye 16/11/2020 Akif GÜRKAN 1979 Isparta Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 122. 55030/20 Yılan v. Türkiye 10/12/2020 Mehmet YILAN 1984 Gaziantep Turkish Adem UZAK 123. 55419/20 Kaymak v. Türkiye 16/11/2020 Zekeriya KAYMAK 1978 Afyonkarahisar Turkish Hüsnü Şahin BÜLBÜL 124. 55636/20 Ozan v. Türkiye 03/12/2020 Turgut OZAN 1986 Balıkesir Turkish Merve OZAN 125. 26/21 Dal v. Türkiye 14/12/2020 Ahmet Kürşat DAL 1980 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 126. 112/21 Gürbüz v. Türkiye 14/12/2020 Yasir GÜRBÜZ 1992 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 127. 1219/21 Kabak v. Türkiye 28/12/2020 Yalçın KABAK 1978 Manisa Turkish Ozan ŞENYER 128. 2684/21 Minnetoğlu v. Türkiye 15/12/2020 Abdulhakim MİNNETOĞLU 1980 Malatya Turkish Enes Malik KILIÇ 129. 2938/21 Yıldız v. Türkiye 09/12/2020 İbrahim YILDIZ 1978 Antalya Turkish Nurgül YAYMAN YILMAZ 130. 3456/21 Karacan v. Türkiye 28/12/2020 Mustafa KARACAN 1971 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 131. 3637/21 Sarı v. Türkiye 29/12/2020 Ercan SARI 1975 Manisa Turkish Türkan SARI 132. 4042/21 Şentürk v. Türkiye 26/11/2020 Kani ŞENTÜRK 1974 İzmir Turkish Mehmet Ali UÇAR 133. 10064/21 Altun v. Türkiye 27/01/2021 Yunus ALTUN 1988 Elazığ Turkish   134. 10094/21 Zencir v. Türkiye 01/02/2021 Ali ZENCİR 1984 Kahramanmaraş Turkish   135. 10099/21 Saraç v. Türkiye 10/02/2021 Yıldırım SARAÇ 1984 Eskişehir Turkish Elif Nurbanu OR 136. 10226/21 Çetin v. Türkiye 02/02/2021 Osman ÇETİN 1974 İstanbul Turkish   137. 10230/21 Bektaşoğlu v. Türkiye 09/12/2020 İdris BEKTAŞOĞLU 1976 Çorum Turkish Şeyma ALKAN 138. 10262/21 Aksakal v. Türkiye 27/01/2021 Mehmet AKSAKAL 1976 Malatya Turkish   139. 10369/21 Taniş v. Türkiye 28/01/2021 Aydın TANİŞ 1985 Mersin Turkish Kadir ÖZTÜRK 140. 10402/21 Yakut v. Türkiye 02/02/2021 Halil İbrahim YAKUT 1974 Balıkesir Turkish   141. 10579/21 Çelebi v. Türkiye 01/02/2021 Kurban ÇELEBİ 1974 Erzurum Turkish Fatih TOPAL 142. 10581/21 Çalar v. Türkiye 05/02/2021 Ahmet ÇALAR 1980 İzmir Turkish Nesrin BAL 143. 10951/21 Kent v. Türkiye 12/02/2021 Murat KENT Gaziantep Turkish İdris TAŞKIN 144. 11139/21 Can v. Türkiye 18/02/2021 Fatih CAN 1980 Aydın Turkish Mehmet MİRZA 145. 11173/21 Kahraman v. Türkiye 09/02/2021 Reşit KAHRAMAN 1979 Kilis Turkish   146. 11311/21 Baştuğ v. Türkiye 15/02/2021 Murat BAŞTUĞ 1975 Ordu Turkish Büşra URLU 147. 11373/21 Özkaya v. Türkiye 12/02/2021 Hüsnü ÖZKAYA 1981 Ankara Turkish Oğuz ÖZKAYA 148. 11483/21 Uğurlu v. Türkiye 15/02/2021 Murat UĞURLU 1980 Ordu Turkish Büşra URLU 149. 11541/21 Karaduman v. Türkiye 13/01/2021 Mustafa KARADUMAN 1985 Kocaeli Turkish Metehan USLUEROL 150. 11576/21 Çimen v. Türkiye 16/02/2021 Nurullah ÇİMEN Manisa Turkish   151. 11601/21 Yeşilyurt v. Türkiye 17/02/2021 Ömer YEŞİLYURT 1985 Bursa Turkish   152. 11862/21 Başkurt v. Türkiye 16/02/2021 Ersin BAŞKURT 1986 Mersin Turkish Merve MALGIR 153. 11869/21 Hocaoğlu v. Türkiye 29/01/2021 Ahmet HOCAOĞLU 1978 Samsun Turkish Mehmet ÖNCÜ 154. 11874/21 Karaboğa v. Türkiye 03/02/2021 Muammer KARABOĞA 1975 İzmir Turkish Özlem SUZAN 155. 11945/21 Sağır v. Türkiye 22/01/2021 Mehmet SAĞIR 1980 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 156. 11956/21 Ahmedali v. Türkiye 16/12/2020 Asliddin AHMEDALİ 1979 Ankara Kirghizstan,Turkish Süeda KADIOĞLU 157. 11961/21 Ülkemen v. Türkiye 15/02/2021 Sinan ÜLKEMEN 1974 Afyonkarahisar Turkish Rana Nuran ÖZKÖKELI 158. 11979/21 Aksak v. Türkiye 18/02/2021 Mehmet AKSAK 1980 Ankara Turkish   159. 12092/21 Vardal v. Türkiye 20/01/2021 Fahri VARDAL 1974 İzmir Turkish Kadir ÖZTÜRK 160. 12095/21 Yılmazkeçeci v. Türkiye 04/02/2021 Celal YILMAZKEÇECİ 1978 Manisa Turkish Özgür ÖZÇAM 161. 12178/21 Yılmaz v. Türkiye 21/01/2021 Kerem YILMAZ 1987 Kocaeli Turkish   162. 12197/21 Karslı v. Türkiye 27/02/2021 Şahin KARSLI 1993 Erzurum Turkish   163. 12363/21 Gündüz v. Türkiye 25/02/2021 Mustafa Yasin GÜNDÜZ 1980 İzmir Turkish   164. 12401/21 Kaya v. Türkiye 29/01/2021 Ahmet KAYA 1978 Manisa Turkish   165. 12523/21 Doğan v. Türkiye 11/12/2020 Hüsamettin DOĞAN 1984 Balıkesir Turkish Bayram Ali AYYILDIZ 166. 12619/21 Kılıç v. Türkiye 15/02/2021 Emrah KILIÇ 1986 Erzurum Turkish   167. 12964/21 Yılmaz v. Türkiye 17/02/2021 Emrah Yusuf YILMAZ 1984 Manisa Turkish   168. 13051/21 Polat v. Türkiye 23/02/2021 İbrahim POLAT 1973 Bursa Turkish   169. 13142/21 Baran v. Türkiye 31/12/2020 Talip BARAN 1985 İzmir Turkish   170. 13377/21 Semerci v. Türkiye 23/02/2021 Mustafa SEMERCİ 1975 Burdur Turkish   171. 13394/21 Çakır v. Türkiye 22/02/2021 Mehmet Serkan ÇAKIR 1974 Denizli Turkish   172. 13442/21 Taşbulut v. Türkiye 05/03/2021 Cengiz TAŞBULUT 1991 Ağrı Turkish   173. 13461/21 Altınbaş v. Türkiye 26/02/2021 Seyhan ALTINBAŞ 1986 İzmir Turkish Seçkin KESKİN 174. 13705/21 Bağan v. Türkiye 01/03/2021 Cuma BAĞAN 1989 Giresun Turkish Abdullah TIKMAN 175. 13718/21 Ateş v. Türkiye 25/02/2021 Naci ATEŞ 1970 Balıkesir Turkish Nesibe ATEŞ 176. 13724/21 Çarık v. Türkiye 05/03/2021 Orhan ÇARIK 1986 Manisa Turkish Tuğba YIKMAZ 177. 13873/21 Karataş v. Türkiye 01/03/2021 Ali KARATAŞ 1967 Kastamonu Turkish Muammer ŞENLİK 178. 13988/21 Koçak v. Türkiye 01/03/2021 Mehmet Sefa KOÇAK 1981 Adana Turkish İlhan ÖNGÖR 179. 14077/21 Aydın v. Türkiye 23/02/2021 Mustafa Suat AYDIN 1990 Elazığ Turkish   180. 14079/21 Akbay v. Türkiye 10/03/2021 Feyza AKBAY 1983 Manisa Turkish Emre ATEŞ 181. 14122/21 Bozkurt v. Türkiye 05/03/2021 İsmail Hakkı BOZKURT 1993 Balıkesir Turkish Mehmet BOZKURT 182. 14253/21 Çeken v. Türkiye 05/03/2021 Mesut ÇEKEN 1975 Ankara Turkish   183. 14460/21 Akçay v. Türkiye 08/03/2021 Ali Osman AKÇAY 1984 Yozgat Turkish Yasemin AKÇAY 184. 14623/21 Kuşçu v. Türkiye 23/02/2021 Uğur KUŞÇU 1986 Manisa Turkish İlknur KUŞÇU 185. 14753/21 Bayram v. Türkiye 24/02/2021 Mustafa BAYRAM 1982 Tokat Turkish Hasan YILMAZ 186. 14772/21 Doğan v. Türkiye 09/02/2021 Ümit DOĞAN 1978 Kahramanmaraş Turkish   187. 14777/21 Sıdar v. Türkiye 18/02/2021 Oğuz Cabbar SIDAR 1981 Adana Turkish   188. 15011/21 Karataş v. Türkiye 02/03/2021 Mevlüt KARATAŞ 1986 Sivas Turkish Mücahit AYDIN 189. 15213/21 Altay v. Türkiye 10/03/2021 Nurullah ALTAY 1988 Manisa Turkish Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY 190. 15225/21 Kaya v. Türkiye 01/03/2021 Salim KAYA 1989 Malatya Turkish   191. 15421/21 Çelik v. Türkiye 10/03/2021 Ülvi ÇELİK 1984 Erzurum Turkish   192. 15535/21 Karakuş v. Türkiye 10/03/2021 Tamer KARAKUŞ 1986 Manisa Turkish   193. 15578/21 Yılmaz v. Türkiye 18/03/2021 Rasim YILMAZ 1970 Ankara Turkish   194. 15714/21 Özkan v. Türkiye 09/03/2021 Fatih ÖZKAN 1985 Ankara Turkish Meral ÖZKAN 195. 15929/21 Özdiken v. Türkiye 19/03/2021 Süleyman ÖZDİKEN 1960 Aydın Turkish İlyas ÖZDİKEN 196. 15964/21 Doğar v. Türkiye 19/03/2021 Gökhan DOĞAR 1980 Osmaniye Turkish   197. 16004/21 Kıymaz v. Türkiye 09/12/2020 Ramazan KIYMAZ 1980 Manisa Turkish   198. 16072/21 Yıldırım v. Türkiye 15/03/2021 Fatih YILDIRIM 1983 Elazığ Turkish Ayla TUNÇDEMIR 199. 16097/21 Sarıkaya v. Türkiye 15/02/2021 Cebrail SARIKAYA 1976 Bolu Turkish Enes Malik KILIÇ 200. 16103/21 Konukseven v. Türkiye 18/02/2021 Tahir KONUKSEVEN 1980 Yozgat Turkish