CEDH · CASELAW;COMMUNICATEDCASES;ENG — 12 novembre 2024

.s800EAC49 { font-size:12pt } .s379BC09C { margin-top:36pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:right } .sBB9EE52A { font-family:Arial } .s10950C61 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-indent:14.2pt; text-align:justify } .s5E1364CA { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .s339D85E6 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:14pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s665E407E { margin-top:66pt; margin-bottom:14pt; text-align:center; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid } .s29100277 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold } .s6B505E72 { margin:0pt; padding-left:0pt } .s5E8F5A28 { margin-top:14pt; margin-left:25.5pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:justify; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold } .sA36B60A1 { font-family:Arial; font-style:italic } .s3AAE10DF { margin-top:14pt; margin-bottom:12pt; text-align:justify; page-break-inside:avoid; page-break-after:avoid; font-size:14pt } .s3CA22BA { font-family:Arial; text-transform:uppercase } .s32563E28 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt } .sA1D3DA2E { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:justify } .s75A32C27 { border-collapse:collapse } .s3695F815 { border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top; background-color:#dfdfdf } .s2E932ED2 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; font-size:11pt } .sEECE831 { font-family:Arial; font-weight:bold; color:#474747 } .sE8934522 { border:0.75pt solid #949494; padding:1.02pt 5.03pt; vertical-align:top } .s4B8D41EE { font-family:Arial; font-size:10pt } .s598389F8 { margin-top:0pt; margin-bottom:0pt; text-align:center; font-size:11pt } Published on 25 November 2024   SECOND SECTION Application no. 52109/22 Muhammet BAŞOĞUL against Türkiye and 199 other applications (see list appended) communicated on 12 November 2024 STATEMENT OF FACTS 1.     A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix. The circumstances of the case 2.     The applications mainly concern the applicants’ conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the “Fetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structure” ( Fetullahçı Terör Örgütü / Paralel Devlet Yapılanması , hereinafter referred to as “the FETÖ/PDY”), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in Türkiye on 15   July 2016. 3.     According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia , on their alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”, which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÖ/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÖ/PDY’s hierarchical structure. 4.     The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of Yüksel   Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, §§   10-22 and   108-40, 26   September 2023). Relevant domestic law and practice 5.     A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above, §§   141-93). COMPLAINTS 6.     The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article   6 §   1. QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see Yüksel Yalçınkaya v.   Türkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against Türkiye.     APPENDIX List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article 6 § 1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial) (conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY based, inter alia , on the applicants’ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock” ) :   No. Application no. Case name Lodged on Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality Represented by 1. 52109/22 Başoğul v. Türkiye 31/10/2022 Muhammet BAŞOĞUL 1981 Isparta Turkish Neslihan BAŞOĞUL 2. 52145/22 Mert v. Türkiye 24/10/2022 Muhammed MERT 1963 Bolu Turkish Samet YILMAZ 3. 52196/22 Arslan v. Türkiye 27/10/2022 Sarra ARSLAN 1983 Gaziantep Turkish İlyas BULDUK 4. 52221/22 Aksoğan v. Türkiye 26/10/2022 Süleyman AKSOĞAN 1986 Kayseri Turkish Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ 5. 52246/22 Ustaoğlu v. Türkiye 24/10/2022 Cemal USTAOĞLU 1972 Trabzon Turkish Meral ÖZATA ÖZGÜROL 6. 52285/22 Uysal v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 İbrahim UYSAL 1978 Balıkesir Turkish Burcu HAS 7. 52296/22 Uzunyol v. Türkiye 02/11/2022 Bülent UZUNYOL 1975 Ankara Turkish Latife Nazlı GÜVEN 8. 52346/22 Kartal v. Türkiye 31/10/2022 Fatih KARTAL 1988 İzmir Turkish Hatice ATMAZ DERİNCE 9. 52363/22 Altınkaya v. Türkiye 26/10/2022 Yaşar ALTINKAYA 1971 Erzurum Turkish Meral ÖZATA ÖZGÜROL 10. 52403/22 Uysal v. Türkiye 31/10/2022 Mustafa UYSAL 1975 Ankara Turkish Meryem GÜNER 11. 52466/22 Top v. Türkiye 03/11/2022 Numan TOP 1987 Afyonkarahisar Turkish Kadir ÖZTÜRK 12. 52640/22 Eser v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 Atilla ESER 1968 Ankara Turkish Hamdi Kenan SEVİNÇ 13. 52662/22 Emektar v. Türkiye 03/11/2022 Ahmet EMEKTAR 1979 Istanbul Turkish Samed ÖZBULUT 14. 52704/22 Sert v. Türkiye 08/11/2022 Tuncay SERT 1980 Denizli Turkish Mehmet TUNÇER 15. 52713/22 Selçuk v. Türkiye 14/10/2022 Mehmet SELÇUK 1985 Ankara Turkish Oğuz ŞENOCAK 16. 52723/22 Gürbüzler v. Türkiye 28/10/2022 Levent GÜRBÜZLER 1977 Tokat Turkish Süleyman KAYA 17. 52728/22 Karagöz v. Türkiye 31/10/2022 Ali KARAGÖZ 1975 İzmir Turkish Serhat ORTAPINAR 18. 52745/22 Tosun v. Türkiye 08/11/2022 Hamza TOSUN 1973 Ankara Turkish Yakup ATEŞ 19. 52843/22 Güngör v. Türkiye 05/11/2022 Engin GÜNGÖR 1989 Kırıkkale Turkish Büşra AVCI 20. 52860/22 Eryüksel v. Türkiye 03/11/2022 Emre ERYÜKSEL 1982 Ankara Turkish Adem BEDİR 21. 52932/22 Genç v. Türkiye 02/11/2022 Burak GENÇ 1993 Batman Turkish Mehmet SATICI 22. 53026/22 Şahin v. Türkiye 07/11/2022 Sümeyra ŞAHİN 1980 Turkish Ömer KÖSTEKÇİ 23. 53043/22 Önal v. Türkiye 02/11/2022 Cennet ÖNAL 1975 Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 24. 53097/22 Ak v. Türkiye 01/11/2022 Ahmet AK 1979 Turkish Nuri TAN 25. 53164/22 Kubilay v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 Zübeyr KUBİLAY 1989 Istanbul Turkish Zülfi Demir KUBİLAY 26. 53196/22 Türker v. Türkiye 11/11/2022 Büşra TÜRKER 1990 Balıkesir Turkish Burcu HAS 27. 53235/22 Keskin v. Türkiye 07/11/2022 Süleyman KESKİN 1976 Turkish Ömer KÖSTEKÇİ 28. 53238/22 Yavuz v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 Sabit YAVUZ 1981 Aydın Turkish Orçun MUŞLU 29. 53240/22 Yardım v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 Hasan YARDIM 1978 Aydın Turkish Orçun MUŞLU 30. 53247/22 Ekiz v. Türkiye 07/11/2022 Avni EKİZ 1968 Denizli Turkish Mehmet TUNÇER 31. 53249/22 Ersoy v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 Kamil ERSOY 1987 Aydın Turkish Orçun MUŞLU 32. 53261/22 Şenyiğit v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 Halil ŞENYİĞİT 1971 İzmir Turkish Orçun MUŞLU 33. 53267/22 Alancı v. Türkiye 07/11/2022 İbrahim ALANCI 1980 Denizli Turkish Mehmet TUNÇER 34. 53312/22 Güngör v. Türkiye 07/11/2022 Murat GÜNGÖR 1990 Istanbul Turkish Mahir ORAK 35. 53321/22 Işık v. Türkiye 09/11/2022 Hasan IŞIK 1961 Samsun Turkish Yakup GÖNEN 36. 53343/22 Onaylı v. Türkiye 02/11/2022 Ali ONAYLI 1968 Adana Turkish Mesut Can TARIM 37. 53365/22 Karabulut v. Türkiye 07/11/2022 Melik KARABULUT 1983 Eskişehir Turkish Ömer Tarık ORMANCI 38. 53366/22 İnan v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 Mesut İNAN 1981 Erzincan Turkish Vasfi Sedat KÜÇÜKYILMAZ 39. 53376/22 Durmuş v. Türkiye 11/11/2022 Tarık DURMUŞ 1988 Denizli Turkish Özge KIYAK MUSAN 40. 53422/22 Özen v. Türkiye 01/11/2022 Ali Tolga ÖZEN 1976 Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 41. 53446/22 Ünver v. Türkiye 17/10/2022 Ahmet ÜNVER 1977 Mersin Turkish Kadir ÖZTÜRK 42. 53456/22 Durmuş v. Türkiye 11/11/2022 Saliha DURMUŞ 1989 Denizli Turkish Özge KIYAK MUSAN 43. 53478/22 Şimşir v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 Sema ŞİMŞİR 1993 Bursa Turkish Adem FINDIK 44. 53493/22 Bıçakcı v. Türkiye 09/11/2022 Emrullah BIÇAKCI 1994 İzmir Turkish Selman Senih KÖSE 45. 53523/22 Karanfil v. Türkiye 07/11/2022 Coşkun KARANFİL 1976 Turkish Nihat KILIÇ 46. 53553/22 Tayan v. Türkiye 31/10/2022 Özlem TAYAN 1982 Samsun Turkish Ayşenur ÖZDEMİR 47. 53586/22 Aydın v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 Reşat AYDIN 1987 Turkish Ömer Faruk BOZDEMİR 48. 53660/22 Karagöz v. Türkiye 11/11/2022 Meryem KARAGÖZ 1978 İzmir Turkish Kamil Furkan CANDEĞER 49. 53689/22 Özçakır v. Türkiye 02/11/2022 İlyas ÖZÇAKIR 1993 Istanbul Turkish Samed KISACIK 50. 53746/22 Çalışkan v. Türkiye 02/11/2022 Serkan ÇALIŞKAN 1976 Giresun Turkish Meral ÖZATA ÖZGÜROL 51. 53759/22 Tiril v. Türkiye 11/11/2022 Ali TİRİL 1981 Gaziemir Turkish Ferhat CANBEDİR 52. 53808/22 Alceren v. Türkiye 03/11/2022 Naci ALCEREN 1974 Kayseri Turkish Vahap ÖZBUDAK 53. 53827/22 Gökce v. Türkiye 15/11/2022 Mehmet Emin GÖKCE 1974 Denizli Turkish Mehmet MİRZA 54. 53851/22 Şentürk v. Türkiye 09/11/2022 Mehmet ŞENTÜRK 1989 Çorum Turkish Zeynep ACAR KARAYILAN 55. 53890/22 Yeşilyurt v. Türkiye 15/11/2022 Munise YEŞİLYURT 1983 Balıkesir Turkish Mehmet MİRZA 56. 53942/22 Topal v. Türkiye 09/11/2022 Burcak Serap TOPAL 1981 Kocaeli Turkish Burcu HAS 57. 54005/22 Karakaya v. Türkiye 07/11/2022 Harun KARAKAYA 1977 Konya Turkish Merve ÇALIŞKAN 58. 54007/22 Alp v. Türkiye 18/11/2022 Serdal ALP 1990 Kırşehir Turkish Mustafa Enes EROL 59. 54100/22 Coşkun v. Türkiye 14/11/2022 Nurdan Ayşe COŞKUN 1986 Afyonkarahisar Turkish Levent MAZILIGÜNEY 60. 54168/22 Selim v. Türkiye 17/11/2022 Kamil SELİM 1984 Istanbul Turkish Muhammet ÜSTÜN 61. 54241/22 Mor v. Türkiye 18/10/2022 Vahdettin MOR 1966 Hatay Turkish Feyza Nur DURAN 62. 54256/22 Nar v. Türkiye 17/10/2022 Esat NAR 1989 Erzurum Turkish Çiğdem NAR 63. 54338/22 Ersöz v. Türkiye 08/11/2022 Süleyman ERSÖZ 1985 Bolu Turkish Sezgin ÖZDEMİR 64. 54343/22 Yurdalan v. Türkiye 16/11/2022 Ahmet YURDALAN 1991 Turkish Hande Sernur İNAL 65. 54348/22 Çomruk v. Türkiye 22/11/2022 Hanifi ÇOMRUK 1985 Türkoğlu / Kahramanmaraş Turkish Ali KIZILTEPE 66. 54352/22 Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye 22/11/2022 Murat YALÇINKAYA 1983 Adana Turkish Ali KIZILTEPE 67. 54389/22 Yatağan v. Türkiye 17/11/2022 Hatice YATAĞAN 1991 Sakarya Turkish Özge KIYAK MUSAN 68. 54419/22 Ulutürk v. Türkiye 18/11/2022 Ertuğrul ULUTÜRK 1973 Turkish Yunus TAMTÜRK 69. 54455/22 Seylan v. Türkiye 16/11/2022 Salih SEYLAN 1982 İzmir Turkish Veysel SEYLAN 70. 54520/22 Şahin v. Türkiye 04/11/2022 Tarkan ŞAHİN 1976 Giresun Turkish Şükrü KOCUK 71. 54534/22 Delen v. Türkiye 02/11/2022 Erhan DELEN 1983 Giresun Turkish Şükrü KOCUK 72. 54539/22 Sağır v. Türkiye 10/11/2022 Şerafettin SAĞIR 1984 İzmir Turkish Ömer Faruk YAZGELDİ 73. 54546/22 Durmaz v. Türkiye 17/11/2022 Mustafa DURMAZ 1975 Ankara Turkish Hasan TOK 74. 54548/22 Seymen v. Türkiye 07/11/2022 Serkan SEYMEN 1982 Ankara Turkish Ebubekir ÇAKIR 75. 54626/22 Şahin v. Türkiye 15/11/2022 Levent ŞAHİN 1973 Ankara Turkish Hakan TEKERCİOĞLU 76. 54641/22 Kaya v. Türkiye 15/11/2022 Mehmet Ali KAYA 1983 İzmir Turkish Remzi TURHAN 77. 54699/22 Temiz v. Türkiye 14/11/2022 Mustafa TEMİZ 1974 Ankara Turkish Halil ŞAHİN 78. 54710/22 Kırboğa v. Türkiye 21/11/2022 Mehmet KIRBOĞA 1986 Denizli Turkish Hazal KIRBOĞA 79. 54953/22 Doğrul v. Türkiye 11/11/2022 Hakan DOĞRUL 1971 Eskişehir Turkish İlhan ÇEÇEN 80. 55007/22 Temiz v. Türkiye 11/11/2022 Güngör TEMİZ 1989 Samsun Turkish Tahir EREN 81. 55061/22 Başçı v. Türkiye 15/11/2022 Namık BAŞÇI 1969 Denizli Turkish Gültekin AKKURT 82. 55063/22 Yılmaz v. Türkiye 11/11/2022 Nihat YILMAZ 1969 Tokat Turkish İlhan ÇEÇEN 83. 55065/22 Mat v. Türkiye 18/11/2022 Ömer Faruk MAT 1992 Gaziantep Turkish Hatice ATMAZ DERİNCE 84. 55069/22 Bugün v. Türkiye 10/11/2022 İsa BUGÜN 1989 Van Turkish Ümran TAŞ 85. 55100/22 Ertekin v. Türkiye 21/11/2022 Kanber ERTEKİN 1973 Kırıkkale Turkish Merve KOÇ 86. 55144/22 Koca v. Türkiye 23/11/2022 Ali KOCA 1970 Denizli Turkish Uğur BAY 87. 55159/22 Evli v. Türkiye 16/11/2022 Hakan EVLİ 1974 Ordu Turkish Türker TÜRKYILMAZ 88. 55328/22 Ustabaşı v. Türkiye 23/11/2022 İsmail USTABAŞI 1982 Balıkesir Turkish Kadri İNCE 89. 55341/22 Çadır v. Türkiye 26/11/2022 Nazlı ÇADIR 1985 Gaziantep Turkish İdris TAŞKIN 90. 55346/22 Likoğlu v. Türkiye 23/11/2022 Merve LİKOĞLU 1993 Turkish Kadri İNCE 91. 55380/22 Yıldırım v. Türkiye 21/11/2022 Yahya YILDIRIM 1979 Ankara Turkish Ebubekir ÇAKIR   92. 55452/22 Şimşek v. Türkiye 22/11/2022 Ömer ŞİMŞEK 1982 Kayseri Turkish Hatice ŞİMŞEK 93. 55456/22 Tulukçu v. Türkiye 21/11/2022 Fatma Rumeysa TULUKÇU 1994 Konya Turkish Refia TAŞCIOĞLU ERBİROL 94. 55475/22 Cerrah v. Türkiye 22/11/2022 İbrahim CERRAH 1960 Eskişehir Turkish Burak ÇAĞ 95. 55507/22 Aydın v. Türkiye 25/11/2022 Melike AYDIN 1992 Afyonkarahisar Turkish Güngör AYDIN 96. 55517/22 Ersoy v. Türkiye 22/11/2022 Güner ERSOY 1974 Erzincan Turkish Hayrünnisa Seda ERSOY 97. 55522/22 Sağlam v. Türkiye 22/11/2022 Bekir SAĞLAM 1972 Trabzon Turkish Sümeyye KETHÜDA 98. 55523/22 Yiğittepe v. Türkiye 28/11/2022 Hüdaverdi YİĞİTTEPE 1965 Eskişehir Turkish Ayşegül KUMAŞ 99. 55682/22 Özdemir v. Türkiye 08/11/2022 Selçuk ÖZDEMİR 1984 Bursa Turkish Abdullah TOMUR 100. 55809/22 Pakdil v. Türkiye 22/11/2022 Mehmet PAKDİL 1973 Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 101. 55842/22 Akdemir v. Türkiye 28/11/2022 Rukiye AKDEMİR 1976 İzmir Turkish İbrahim AKDEMİR 102. 55843/22 Zotluoğlu v. Türkiye 10/11/2022 Yusuf ZOTLUOĞLU 1979 Samsun Turkish Metin ATEŞOĞLU 103. 55861/22 İncetaş v. Türkiye 28/11/2022 Hüseyin İNCETAŞ 1989 Kahramamaraş Turkish Osman İNCETAŞ 104. 55903/22 Kutlu v. Türkiye 18/11/2022 Serdar KUTLU 1974 Samsun Turkish Metin ATEŞOĞLU 105. 55916/22 Durdu v. Türkiye 22/11/2022 Savaş DURDU 1976 Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 106. 55921/22 Aslanhan v. Türkiye 21/11/2022 Rubeyda ASLANHAN 1987 Erzincan Turkish Tahir EREN 107. 55925/22 Geçmek v. Türkiye 21/11/2022 Hüseyin GEÇMEK 1987 Samsun Turkish Tahir EREN 108. 55938/22 Tiryaki v. Türkiye 22/11/2022 Ercan TİRYAKİ 1982 Samsun Turkish Hasan YILMAZ 109. 56006/22 Ekinci v. Türkiye 28/11/2022 Mehmet Zeki EKİNCİ 1977 İzmir Turkish Elif GİRGİN 110. 56023/22 Topkara v. Türkiye 25/11/2022 Adem TOPKARA 1981 Denizli Turkish Mehmet TUNÇER 111. 56131/22 Aslan v. Türkiye 15/11/2022 Ahmet ASLAN 1976 Zonguldak Turkish Arzu BEYAZIT 112. 56170/22 Öztürk v. Türkiye 29/11/2022 Serdar ÖZTÜRK 1975 Giresun Turkish İbrahim AYDIN 113. 56254/22 Topal v. Türkiye 18/11/2022 Sevilay TOPAL 1983 Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 114. 56441/22 Tekten v. Türkiye 29/11/2022 Murat Tuncay TEKTEN 1965 Antalya Turkish Nurgül YAYMAN YILMAZ 115. 56458/22 Kahraman v. Türkiye 22/11/2022 Zubeyir Selman KAHRAMAN 1992 İzmir Turkish Kamile KILDAN 116. 56714/22 Yurdalan v. Türkiye 06/12/2022 Muhammet YURDALAN 1992 Ankara Turkish Hande Sernur İNAL 117. 56801/22 Yaşarcan v. Türkiye 25/11/2022 Hacı Ali YAŞARCAN 1973 Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 118. 56842/22 Soydan v. Türkiye 05/12/2022 İlknur SOYDAN 1992 Isparta Turkish Orçun MUŞLU 119. 56850/22 Baz v. Türkiye 05/12/2022 Şeyma BAZ 1990 Isparta Turkish Orçun MUŞLU 120. 56856/22 Çetinkaya v. Türkiye 01/12/2022 Mehmet Sait ÇETİNKAYA 1986 Kırıkkale Turkish Mustafa SOYLU 121. 57034/22 Güngör v. Türkiye 28/11/2022 Ömer GÜNGÖR 1971 Giresun Turkish Meral ÖZATA ÖZGÜROL 122. 57121/22 Öztürk v. Türkiye 02/12/2022 Melike ÖZTÜRK 1991 Isparta Turkish Zülal BÜKER 123. 57148/22 Toy v. Türkiye 05/12/2022 Osman TOY 1973 Antalya Turkish Ayşe TOY 124. 57304/22 Sakman v. Türkiye 18/11/2022 Kemal SAKMAN 1981 Adana Turkish Fatih DERTSİZ 125. 57333/22 Doğan v. Türkiye 30/11/2022 Tuncay DOĞAN 1975 Ankara Turkish Mustafa SOYLU 126. 57337/22 Tunç v. Türkiye 01/12/2022 Şükrü TUNÇ 1979 Isparta Turkish Mehmet MİRZA 127. 57390/22 Eker v. Türkiye 05/12/2022 Hasan EKER 1973 Çorum Turkish Muhammet MARAŞLI 128. 57421/22 Çelen v. Türkiye 05/12/2022 Murat ÇELEN 1960 Isparta Turkish Ayşe ÇELEN 129. 57442/22 Avan v. Türkiye 06/12/2022 Ahsen Nur AVAN 1994 Bursa Turkish Nazire UYANIK 130. 57449/22 Bilgin v. Türkiye 06/12/2022 Cemil BİLGİN 1979 Kayseri Turkish Selim YILMAZ 131. 57661/22 Şentürk v. Türkiye 08/12/2022 Taci ŞENTÜRK 1976 Kayseri Turkish Merve ÇALIŞKAN 132. 44/23 Cuma v. Türkiye 16/12/2022 Mustafa CUMA 1985 Osmaniye Turkish Elif Nurbanu OR 133. 83/23 Karagüven v. Türkiye 16/12/2022 Cafer KARAGÜVEN 1981 Aksaray Turkish Kübra GÜLAÇTI 134. 94/23 Alptekin v. Türkiye 14/12/2022 Mahmut Selim ALPTEKİN 1989 Eskişehir Turkish İbrahim Halil UZUN 135. 101/23 Çömez v. Türkiye 25/11/2022 Abdullah ÇÖMEZ 1980 Giresun Turkish Elif CİVELEKOĞLU 136. 112/23 Fidan v. Türkiye 17/11/2022 Mustafa FİDAN 1972 Erzincan Turkish Songül FİDAN 137. 287/23 Bodur v. Türkiye 16/12/2022 Harun BODUR 1982 Ankara Turkish Merve BODUR 138. 372/23 Ustaoğlu v. Türkiye 02/12/2022 Ersoy USTAOĞLU 1977 Ankara Turkish Burhan DEMİRCİ 139. 728/23 Çetin v. Türkiye 14/12/2022 Emine ÇETİN 1979 Istanbul Turkish Harun AYDIN 140. 844/23 Dere v. Türkiye 14/12/2022 Ayşe DERE 1984 Turkish Ayşe AYGÜN 141. 993/23 Altunbulak v. Türkiye 30/12/2022 Mustafa ALTUNBULAK 1972 Niğde Turkish Oktay BAHADIR 142. 1453/23 Özçelebi v. Türkiye 27/12/2022 Emre ÖZÇELEBİ 1986 Keskin Turkish Mehmet ÖNCÜ 143. 2117/23 Teke v. Türkiye 15/12/2022 Mehmet Ali TEKE 1983 Adana Turkish Havva TEKE 144. 2335/23 Hayrettin v. Türkiye 30/12/2022 Kaya HAYRETTİN 1993 Van Turkish Yüksel ERSOY 145. 2363/23 Meydan v. Türkiye 02/01/2023 Emrah MEYDAN 1987 Ordu Turkish Şeyma MISIRLIOĞLU 146. 2425/23 Ersoy v. Türkiye 16/12/2022 Necati ERSOY 1975 Antalya Turkish Mehmet SATICI 147. 2605/23 Saydam v. Türkiye 19/12/2022 Murat SAYDAM 1986 Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 148. 2905/23 Toprak v. Türkiye 30/11/2022 Zeynel TOPRAK 1975 Samsun Turkish İrem ÇAVUŞOĞLU 149. 2926/23 Özkarslı v. Türkiye 05/12/2022 Gökhan ÖZKARSLI 1987 Samsun Turkish İnan UZUN 150. 2939/23 Kaşkar v. Türkiye 28/12/2022 Muhammet Emin KAŞKAR 1968 Çanakkale Turkish Sinem KURAL 151. 2953/23 Güngör v. Türkiye 20/12/2022 Ali Fırat GÜNGÖR 1982 İzmir Turkish İhsan MAKAS 152. 2968/23 Bahar v. Türkiye 26/12/2022 Ali BAHAR 1972 Ankara Turkish Ayşenur ÖZDEMİR 153. 3048/23 Sezer v. Türkiye 27/12/2022 İrfan SEZER 1974 Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 154. 3132/23 Tuşan v. Türkiye 23/12/2022 Zülfükar TUŞAN 1985 Hatay Turkish Esma TUSAN 155. 3191/23 Sazil v. Türkiye 27/12/2022 Selami SAZİL 1972 Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 156. 3286/23 Taş v. Türkiye 28/12/2022 Ahmet TAŞ 1976 Ankara Turkish Arzu BEYAZIT 157. 3478/23 Dağlı v. Türkiye 27/12/2022 Muhammed DAĞLI 1984 Konya Turkish Mehmet ÖNCÜ 158. 3556/23 Baber v. Türkiye 26/12/2022 Orhan BABER 1976 Osmaniye Turkish Elçin MERİÇ 159. 3683/23 Küçük v. Türkiye 10/01/2023 Murat KÜÇÜK 1969 Çorum Turkish Muhammet MARAŞLI 160. 3701/23 Tafracı v. Türkiye 03/01/2023 Gazanfer TAFRACI 1974 Karabük Turkish Yakup Yaşar MİRZAOĞLU 161. 3929/23 Güney v. Türkiye 17/01/2023 Özcan GÜNEY 1989 Ankara Turkish Hasan TOK 162. 5047/23 Kılısarı v. Türkiye 20/01/2023 Hasan KILISARI 1975 Konya Turkish Kübra GÜLAÇTI 163. 5073/23 Gündüz v. Türkiye 19/01/2023 Esra GÜNDÜZ 1986 Kırıkkale Turkish Merve KOÇ 164. 5101/23 Layık v. Türkiye 17/01/2023 Nurullah LAYIK 1983 Çorum Turkish Murat ÇAM 165. 5129/23 Yıldız v. Türkiye 13/12/2022 Cahit YILDIZ 1971 Adana Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 166. 5209/23 Akça v. Türkiye 25/01/2023 Adem AKÇA 1984 Ankara Turkish Çağrı Seyfettin GÖKDEMİR 167. 5281/23 Altın v. Türkiye 17/01/2023 Hatice ALTIN 1979 Ankara Turkish Kamile ÖZBULUT 168. 5355/23 Gençoğlu v. Türkiye 29/11/2022 Mehmet GENÇOĞLU 1989 Afyonkarahisar Turkish Sultan TEKE SOYDİNÇ 169. 5366/23 Arslansan v. Türkiye 06/01/2023 Musa ARSLANSAN 1972 Kastamonu Turkish Meral ÖZATA ÖZGÜROL 170. 5381/23 Özçelik v. Türkiye 21/01/2023 Halil ÖZÇELİK 1975 İzmir Turkish Mehmet MİRZA 171. 6214/23 Çelik v. Türkiye 19/01/2023 Adem ÇELİK 1978 Samsun Turkish Kamile KILDAN 172. 6251/23 Yılmaz v. Türkiye 13/01/2023 Muharrem YILMAZ 1980 Ordu Turkish Neziha YILMAZ 173. 6445/23 Hıçkıran v. Türkiye 02/01/2023 Mehmet Şahin HIÇKIRAN 1978 Denizli Turkish Mehmet MİRZA 174. 7094/23 Turan v. Türkiye 06/02/2023 Serpil TURAN 1991 Ankara Turkish Çağrı Seyfettin GÖKDEMİR 175. 7705/23 Ekşi v. Türkiye 09/02/2023 Tekin EKŞİ 1987 Sakarya Turkish Çağrı Seyfettin GÖKDEMİR 176. 7856/23 Bulut v. Türkiye 07/02/2023 Hikmet BULUT 1970 Turkish Şeyma MISIRLIOĞLU 177. 8082/23 Köroğlu v. Türkiye 02/02/2023 Sadık KÖROĞLU 1987 Turkish Nihat KILIÇ 178. 8300/23 Aynı v. Türkiye 18/01/2023 İsa AYNI 1984 Sivas Turkish Şeyma MISIRLIOĞLU 179. 8374/23 Özkan v. Türkiye 09/02/2023 Rafet ÖZKAN 1966 Manisa Turkish Mehmet ÖNCÜ 180. 10722/23 Aslan v. Türkiye 06/03/2023 Mustafa ASLAN 1981 Osmaniye Turkish Ali KIZILTEPE 181. 11186/23 Kılıçaslan v. Türkiye 27/02/2023 Fatih KILIÇASLAN 1985 Giresun Turkish Şeyma MISIRLIOĞLU 182. 11578/23 Orhan v. Türkiye 22/02/2023 Recep ORHAN 1982 Ankara Turkish Ahmet Serdar GÜNEŞ 183. 12599/23 Harmandar v. Türkiye 13/03/2023 Onur HARMANDAR 1988 Ankara Turkish Hasan TOK 184. 12825/23 Aras v. Türkiye 09/03/2023 Müslüm ARAS 1977 Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 185. 13044/23 Çete v. Türkiye 02/03/2023 Mehmet ÇETE 1975 İzmir Turkish Elif GİRGİN 186. 13120/23 Topal v. Türkiye 16/02/2023 Adem TOPAL 1988 Rize Turkish Mehmet ÖNCÜ 187. 13260/23 Akça v. Türkiye 17/03/2023 Ramazan AKÇA 1975 Erzurum Turkish Fatih TOPAL 188. 13781/23 Kılınç v. Türkiye 24/03/2023 Zafer KILINÇ 1971 Boğazlıyan Turkish Özcan AKINCI 189. 14071/23 Uslusoy v. Türkiye 20/03/2023 Mehmet Coşkun USLUSOY 1975 İzmir Turkish Bülent ÖNÜR 190. 14073/23 Karakoç v. Türkiye 17/03/2023 Mustafa KARAKOÇ 1980 Elazığ Turkish Özcan AKINCI 191. 14109/23 Yılmaz v. Türkiye 20/03/2023 İsa YILMAZ 1987 Istanbul Turkish Emre AKARYILDIZ 192. 14974/23 Sayğılı v. Türkiye 28/02/2023 Salih SAYĞILI 1984 Ankara Turkish Kamile ÖZBULUT 193. 17814/23 Kul v. Türkiye 18/04/2023 Süleyman KUL 1966 Turkish Mehmet ÖNCÜ 194. 17882/23 Pazar v. Türkiye 14/04/2023 Ali PAZAR 1980 Aksaray Turkish İhsan MAKAS 195. 19623/23 Sever v. Türkiye 19/04/2023 Abdullah SEVER 1975 Gaziantep Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 196. 21110/23 Sarı v. Türkiye 24/05/2023 Ali SARI 1992 Denizli Turkish Ali KIZILTEPE 197. 24092/23 Purtas v. Türkiye 22/05/2023 Hüseyin PURTAŞ 1984 Yozgat Turkish Kamile KILDAN 198. 24097/23 Kahraman v. Türkiye 17/05/2023 Mümin KAHRAMAN 1979 Mersin Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU 199. 27624/23 Yaşa v. Türkiye 27/03/2023 Hasan YAŞA 1981 Bilecik Turkish Tarık Said GÜLDİBİ 200. 28014/23 Karayel v. Türkiye 04/07/2023 Murat KARAYEL 1984 Mersin Turkish Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU