Both the applicant and the public prosecutor filed an appeal with the Court of Appeal (Gerechtshof) of The Hague.

The defence sought an adjournment, asking the judge to assist the defence in obtaining a copy of the street security-camera footage, which arguably might have been exculpating or have clarified pertinent

It is therefore from this date at the latest that the applicant must be considered to have been directly affected by the investigations and consequently to have been charged with a criminal offence in

(d)     to examine or have examined witnesses against him ...” Admissibility 23.

Juge aux affaires familiales de VALENCIENNES APPELANT Monsieur [B] [B] né le [Date naissance 1] 1934 à [Localité 1] (MAROC) [Adresse 1] [Adresse 1] Représenté par Me Julie CAMBIER de la SCP

[T] [X] [L] épouse [B] née le 20 Septembre 1947 à [Localité 6] (13) de nationalité Française et Américaine [Adresse 1], VIRGINIE (ETATS UNIS) Représentée par Me Célia VILANOVA substituant Me Philippe

Madame [M] [S] épouse [C] née le 31 mai 1965 à [Localité 8] de nationalité française [Adresse 4] [Localité 5] représentée par Me Isabelle ALVES, avocat au barreau de GRENOBLE substituant Me Philippe

[O] [E] né le [Date naissance 1] 1941 à [Localité 1] demeurant [Adresse 1] [Localité 2] représenté et assisté par Me Jean-Philippe Verague, avocat au barreau d'Arras, substitué à l'audience par

Paul K..., demeurant Le Mont des Haies, 08220 Saint-Jean aux Bois, 39 / M. Michel L..., demeurant 08310 Bignicourt, 40 / M. Frédéric P..., demeurant Ferme d'Ecogne, 08090 Fagnon, 41 / M.

représenté par la SCP SIDER, avoués à la Cour, ayant Me Philippe HAGE, avocat au barreau d'AIX EN PROVENCE INTIMES Monsieur René Y... demeurant ...

The Court therefore concludes that failure by legal-aid counsel to provide effective representation cannot be said either to have been manifest or to have been sufficiently brought to the appeal court’

The majority in that case erred in interpreting Article 6 § 1 in light of the relevant rules of international law and so to have limited the effect of Article 6 § 1 because of the scope of the international

Remember that there is a real threat of United Russia’s total dominance and we have seen it blossom.” 16.

All other midwives refusing a part of the work on any other grounds would have been treated the same way as the applicant.

Granting the right to reply would not have unnecessarily prolonged the proceedings before the Federal Court.

The Court is therefore not convinced that an appeal to a court by the applicant, which could only have had the same effect, that is the annulment of a refusal to institute criminal proceedings, would have

    The applicants replied that when they lodged their application with the Court in May 2011 they could not reasonably have expected that new cassation appeal procedure would have been an effective

Besson, conseiller, Mme Mainardi, greffier de chambre ; Vu les observations écrites de la SCP Boré, Salve de Bruneton et Mégret, avocat de M.

  For these reasons, the Court unanimously Decides to adjourn the examination of the applicant's complaints concerning the scope of judicial review in the proceedings following his dismissal, the

    Having regard to the nature and scope of the violation found, the Court awards the applicant EUR 1,000 in respect of non-pecuniary damage, plus any tax that may be chargeable. B.