Hegemann and Ms   L. Schopp, lawyers practising in Berlin. 3.     The Government were represented by one of their Agents, Mr   H.J.

Upon this, Mrs Aslan had contacted the headman ( muhtar ) of her neighbourhood.

HEDERMAN, Barrister-at-Law,   Counsel ,       and by   MM. D. O'DONOVAN , Chief State Solicitor,   P.

After the car had driven off, İhsan ran to his home and told his mother Halise A. what had happened, who in turn informed the village headman.

It is to be noted that Celal Güneş submitted a certificate, signed and approved by the headman (muhtar) of his village, to the Court attesting his ownership of the property in Kalecik.

In rejecting the claim for damages based on breach of statutory duty, Mr Justice Finlay CJ (with whose judgment Mr Justice Griffin agreed and Mr Justice Hederman concurred) found that the Minister’s decision

  Justice Hederman concurred) first rejected the applicants' claim based on breach of statutory duty (ibid., pp. 757-758):   "...

    In his judgment in the Government of Canada case (cited in paragraph   15 above), Justice Hederman described the position of sovereign immunity in Irish law as follows: “The doctrine

    On 26 February 1992, on appeal, a majority (Finlay C.J., McCarthy   J., Egan J. and O’Flaherty J., with Hederman J. dissenting) of the Supreme Court discharged the injunction. 41.

HEDERMAN, S.C.,   Mr. R.J. O’HANLON, S.C.,   Mr. A. BROWNE, S.C.,   Mr. J. MURRAY, Barrister-at-Law,   Counsel ,   Mr. L. LYSAGHT, Chief State Solicitor,   Mr. P.P.D.

Hederman, S.C. Aidan Browne, Barrister-at-Law John Murray, Barrister-at-Law Liam Lysaght, Chief State Solicitor P.D. Quigley, Senior Legal Assistant, Attorney-General's Office E.

(Griffin J agreeing and Hederman J concurring) stated as follows: (ibid., p. 756):           "If a Minister of State, granted as a persona designata   

parents, having been tortured and questioned about the first      applicant;        f)    the accounts given by the first applicant's village headman

;    (a) the organisation styling itself the Irish         Republican Army (also the IRA and Oglaigh ne         hEireann

    Mehmet Nuri Sansar, the headman ( muhtar ) of the Karaorman village at the time of the alleged events, was questioned by the Kulp Prosecutor on 15 April 1998.

To the south-east of Kurşunlu village is the village of Kelekçi, where on 10 November 1992 security forces burned down the houses of nine villagers, including that of the village headman ( muhtar ) Hüseyin

arrest of the first applicant’s parents, brothers, sister and cousins in October 1989, and the arrest of another cousin in October 1990;   f)   the accounts given by the applicant’s village headman

After the car had driven off, İhsan ran to his home and told his mother Halise Acar what had happened, and she in turn informed the village headman.

maps, land-register and tax records, and other documents in the presence of interested persons and owners of the property [in question] and in the presence of at least three experts and the village headman

This instruction was communicated to the villagers by the headman ( muhtar ) of the village.